Having a gyaru explain the Bakumatsu era turned out oddly clear (Part 1: the Kinmon Incident)
I’m reading Miko Yasu’s Dan Doon. It’s a Bakumatsu-era work by the author of Hakozume, and the protagonist is Kawaji Toshiyoshi of Satsuma, who would later lay the foundations of Japan’s police system. It’s funny, but every incident that appears in it is real history.
While reading, it occurred to me that this Kawaji is said to be the man who shot Kijima Matabei of Chōshū at the Kinmon Incident. So if someone asked me to explain the Kinmon Incident, could I actually do it?
Honestly, I’m pretty shaky on it.
In 1864, Chōshū attacked the Imperial Palace in Kyoto and lost. Also called the Hamaguri Gomon Incident. That much I can say. But ask me why Chōshū did something so reckless, who was on which side, what happened that day, and what it led to afterward, and I suddenly go quiet. I’ve read the textbook explanations and the summary articles several times, but there are too many domain names, too many people’s names, too many years, and it all slips away as soon as I read it.
So it occurred to me to have an AI write a dialogue script where one gyaru teaches history to another gyaru. The first version had the temperature of a slightly casual history show — not bad, but ordinary. So I asked again for “more frivolous and childish phrasing sprinkled throughout.”
Here’s what came out. The one teaching, Rina, is set up as “a history otaku who’s secretly an elementary schooler on the inside,” and the one listening, Mai, “lives entirely off her reactions.”
Mai: “Hey Rinaaa~, tomorrow’s Japanese history quiz has the Kinmon Incident on it apparently. Ugh. I literally only know the name, it’s so bad lol.”
Rina: “Wait what~, the Kinmon Incident is seriously nothing but drama, you know? Also called the Hamaguri Gomon Incident, but basically Chōshū got so worked up they stormed the Imperial Palace in Kyoto.”
Mai: “Storming the palace, isn’t that intense? Isn’t that where the Emperor is? That’s so unhinged.”
Rina: “Right? That’s why it’s crazy. But Chōshū didn’t just snap out of nowhere. There’s a proper setup, give them credit.”
Mai: “I wanna hear the setup. Quick quick.”
Rina: “So, Kyoto in the late Edo period — this ‘foreigners get out’ sonnō jōi movement was super trending, and Chōshū was at the center of it. They were tight with the court nobles too, basically the popular clique of the Kyoto class.”
Mai: “Chōshū was the cool kids huh~.”
Rina: “So cool that even Emperor Kōmei was kind of like ‘uh, that’s scary…’ and backed off a bit. Then, in the third year of Bunkyū, 1863, on the eighteenth day of the eighth month, Aizu and Satsuma joined hands and kicked Chōshū and their court noble buddies right out of Kyoto. This is the Coup of August 18.”
Mai: “Wait, suddenly excluded? That’s so mean!”
Rina: “Totally excluded. Sanjō Sanetomi and six other nobles fled to Chōshū crying, it’s called the Flight of the Seven Nobles. From Chōshū’s perspective, it’s like being the popular clique yesterday and then waking up removed from the group chat.”
Mai: “Waaah, that’s the kind you never recover from.”
Rina: “And then there’s another blow, the Ikedaya Incident. The next year, in the sixth month, the Shinsengumi raided a bunch of Chōshū-aligned activists who were gathered at an inn in Kyoto called the Ikedaya. A bunch of them got cut down or captured, and Chōshū’s anger meter maxed out completely.”
Mai: “The Shinsengumi show up there?! That’s my fave’s big moment.”
Rina: “Right, the Shinsengumi’s most famous moment. And within Chōshū, the faction going ‘isn’t the only option left to go to Kyoto and complain directly?’ starts getting cocky, and they bring troops and head to Kyoto.”
Mai: “Who went? Tell me the lineup~.”
Rina: “Here’s the Chōshū team. First, three senior retainers: Fukuhara Echigo, Masuda Uemonnosuke, and Kunishi Shinano. That’s the ‘important people’ slot.”
Mai: “So many important people. The names are too hard lol.”
Rina: “And the hot-blooded field commander slot is Kijima Matabei. This guy was basically ‘we gotta go!’ hardline all the way, and he’s the one who dragged everyone along.”
Mai: “This guy’s way too intense. Exhausting, but I don’t hate it.”
Rina: “And the other main character is Kusaka Genzui. A disciple of Yoshida Shōin, and actually married to Yoshida’s younger sister. Still in his mid-twenties, a young elite, super sharp. Actually, Kusaka was the cautious type going ‘isn’t it a bit early to attack now~?’”
Mai: “Wait, he was cautious but went anyway? Why, why?”
Rina: “That’s the emotional part. He couldn’t stop them, so in the end he went along with everyone. There was also a veteran activist from Kurume named Maki Izumi.”
Mai: “So who was on the defending side?”
Rina: “The team protecting the shogunate and the court. The Kyoto Shugoshoku was Matsudaira Katamori of the Aizu domain. From Chōshū’s perspective, they think the exclusion and the Ikedaya thing are all his fault, so he’s a genuine arch-enemy. Someone they really hated.”
Mai: “So they were like, booo, hate that guy.”
Rina: “Probably. Also the one in overall charge of defending the palace was Hitotsubashi Yoshinobu. The later last shogun, Tokugawa Yoshinobu.”
Mai: “Yoshinobu shows up here?! I had no idea!”
Rina: “He shows up, he shows up. And the one commanding the Satsuma forces was Saigō Takamori.”
Mai: “It’s an all-star lineup. Too lavish, I’m full.”
Rina: “The Chōshū army camped out split between Fushimi, Mount Tennōzan at Yamazaki, and Tenryūji in Saga, pleading ‘our lord isn’t the bad guy!’ while demanding ‘Matsudaira Katamori, get out!’”
Mai: “Sounds like they’d actually say ‘the bad guy!’ like that. Cute.”
Rina: “There’s a standoff for a while, but Yoshinobu and the Emperor stay cold, like ‘we will not forgive Chōshū,’ and finally the battle begins.”
Mai: “Finally the real thing? I’m nervous.”
Rina: “The nineteenth day of the seventh month of the first year of Genji — August 20, 1864 in the Western calendar. Before dawn, the Chōshū army advances toward the palace, charging forward.”
Mai: “Where did they fight?”
Rina: “The fiercest fighting was at Hamaguri Gomon, the west gate of the palace. Kijima Matabei’s unit charged in there and went head-to-head with the defending Aizu troops. At first, Chōshū was actually pushing hard.”
Mai: “Wait, could they have actually won?”
Rina: “For a moment. But then Satsuma’s reinforcements came rushing in, and the tide turned completely. Kijima Matabei was shot, and that’s where he lost his life.”
Mai: “Nooo, the hot-blooded guy… so sad.”
Rina: “And Kusaka Genzui took a different route, entering the residence of a court noble named Takatsukasa near Sakaimachi Gomon, trying to get a petition delivered to the court. But by then they were already surrounded. In the end, wounded, he took his own life along with his comrades.”
Mai: “The guy who was cautious… that hits hard.”
Rina: “Fukuhara Echigo’s unit, which came from the Fushimi side, also got defeated along the way, and Chōshū’s whole army collapsed. Maki Izumi retreated to Mount Tennōzan and took his own life there a few days later along with his comrades.”
Mai: “Basically wiped out. Too sad, beyond sad even.”
Rina: “And on top of that, it’s hell because of the fire. A fire broke out during the fighting and spread blazing through the city of Kyoto. It’s called the Dondo fire, and they say tens of thousands of houses burned down.”
Mai: “The townspeople didn’t do anything wrong. That’s so unfair.”
Rina: “Really. And in the chaos, activists who’d been locked up in jail were executed too, on the grounds of ‘it’d be a problem if they escaped.’”
Mai: “Brutal. So awful. Ugh. By the way, what about Katsura Kogorō?”
Rina: “Oh, good catch~. Katsura was in Kyoto too, but after the battle he fled around in tattered disguise, and eventually went into hiding in a place called Izushi in Tajima. The story that his lover Ikumatsu secretly supported him is famous too.”
Mai: “Protected by his crush. Katsura’s survival skills are strong.”
Rina: “He was even called ‘the Fleeing Kogorō,’ that’s how good he was. A hide-and-seek pro. And from here on is the impact on later history. First, because Chōshū fired guns at the Imperial Palace, they got treated as an enemy of the Emperor, that is, chōteki.”
Mai: “The one thing you’re never supposed to become. The thing that gets you in the most trouble with the teacher.”
Rina: “Right. So the shogunate sends a huge army saying ‘we’ll teach Chōshū a lesson,’ the First Chōshū Expedition begins. And around the same time, at Shimonoseki, they get pounded by a four-nation fleet including Britain. Chōshū’s biggest crisis of its life.”
Mai: “Insult to injury, so much. What happened?”
Rina: “In the end Chōshū doesn’t fight, says sorry, and the three senior retainers take responsibility by committing seppuku. Within the domain, the ‘let’s stop defying the shogunate’ faction gets stronger, but then Takasugi Shinsaku raises an army and flips it all around, bringing it back to the path of fighting the shogunate again.”
Mai: “Takasugi Shinsaku’s too strong. Nobody beats Takasugi.”
Rina: “And Chōshū resented Satsuma so bitterly that there’s even a story about writing ‘Satsuma thieves, Aizu scoundrels’ on the sole of their geta and walking on it.”
Mai: “The way they hold grudges is so elementary school lol. It’s like writing your least favorite classmate’s name inside your indoor shoes.”
Rina: “I know right~. And yet, two years later in 1866, people like Sakamoto Ryōma step in, and Chōshū and Satsuma make up and join hands. The Satchō Alliance.”
Mai: “Wait, after saying they hated each other that much?! That’s so tsundere.”
Rina: “That’s the interesting part of the Bakumatsu era. To achieve the goal of overthrowing the shogunate, they had no choice but to join hands with yesterday’s enemy. And this Satsuma-Chōshū alliance becomes the center of the Meiji Restoration.”
Mai: “What about Aizu?”
Rina: “The grudge against Aizu lingers on and on, leading into the flow where Aizu gets attacked in the Boshin War. The tragedy of the Byakkotai and so on comes out of that too.”
Mai: “They really hold grudges… but I guess it’s not surprising given what was done to them. So the Kinmon Incident wasn’t just a case of losing — it’s more like the starting point for everything that came after.”
Rina: “Exactly. Chōshū hit absolute rock bottom once, and because of that the domain’s internal makeup shifted, they made up with Satsuma, and in the end they became the side that overthrew the shogunate. It’s like the starting point where all the foreshadowing of the Meiji Restoration pays off.”
Mai: “I totally get it now! Might be a genius.”
Rina: “Okay, I’ll tell you what to memorize. First year of Genji, 1864, Hamaguri Gomon, Kijima Matabei and Kusaka Genzui. And defeated by Satsuma and Aizu, becoming an enemy of the Emperor. You’ve got this test in the bag.”
Mai: “Got it! Love you Teacher Rina! Byebyeee!”
That’s the whole thing.
Having finished reading it, I thought Teacher Rina was an absolute genius. Since I’ve gone this far, let me go back through the flow of the story and revisit what became clear, and where.
First, the triggering event, the Coup of August 18. In 1863, Chōshū, which had been running Kyoto’s politics, got shut out of Kyoto overnight by Aizu and Satsuma. The textbook closes that one sentence and moves on, but in Rina’s hands it becomes this.
From Chōshū’s perspective, it’s like being the popular clique yesterday and then waking up removed from the group chat.
Waaah, that’s the kind you never recover from.
That made it click instantly. I understood what Chōshū was angry about before I understood the logic of it.
Onto that is layered the following year’s Ikedaya Incident. The incident where the Shinsengumi raided Chōshū-aligned activists gathered at an inn in Kyoto.
A bunch of them got cut down or captured, and Chōshū’s anger meter maxed out completely.
The faction going ‘isn’t the only option left to go to Kyoto and complain directly?’ starts getting cocky, and they bring troops and head to Kyoto.
Excluded from the popular clique, comrades cut down, anger pushed past the limit — Chōshū sends troops. The causality up to this point connects in a single line.
Next are the characters. The three senior retainers of the domain are sorted, rather roughly, into “the important people slot,” and the fierce general Kijima Matabei into “the hot-blooded field commander slot,” but that roughness is exactly what makes it memorable. And here, what worked best for me was the introduction of Kusaka Genzui.
Actually, Kusaka was the cautious type going ‘isn’t it a bit early to attack now~?’
Wait, he was cautious but went anyway? Why, why?
That’s the emotional part. He couldn’t stop them, so in the end he went along with everyone.
Kusaka, who was just a name in the textbook, becomes a real person in these three lines. A young man who opposed it but couldn’t abandon his comrades, and went along. On the defending side are Matsudaira Katamori of Aizu, Hitotsubashi Yoshinobu guarding the palace, and Saigō Takamori of Satsuma, and it’s no wonder Mai says “it’s an all-star lineup.”
And then, the day itself, the nineteenth day of the seventh month on the old calendar in 1864.
The fiercest fighting was at Hamaguri Gomon. (…) At first, Chōshū was actually pushing hard.
Wait, could they have actually won?
For a moment. But then Satsuma’s reinforcements came rushing in, and the tide turned completely. Kijima Matabei was shot, and that’s where he lost his life.
Chōshū, which had nearly broken through the gate, gets flipped by Satsuma’s intervention. Where the turning point of the battle was becomes clear from this exchange alone.
Kusaka’s final moment is told like this.
In the end, wounded, he took his own life along with his comrades.
The guy who was cautious… that hits hard.
The earlier “he was cautious but went anyway?” pays off here.
Incidentally, in the scenes where people die, neither Rina nor Mai makes light of the facts themselves. The narration stays matter-of-fact; only Mai’s reactions stay light. If everything were turned into a joke, it really would be exhausting to read. As the series went on, this is one thing I decided clearly from the start.
After the battle, the town of Kyoto burns.
It’s called the Dondo fire, and they say tens of thousands of houses burned down.
The townspeople didn’t do anything wrong. That’s so unfair.
Chōshū, having fired on the palace and burned the town besides, becomes an enemy of the Emperor, a chōteki.
The one thing you’re never supposed to become. The thing that gets you in the most trouble with the teacher.
The shogunate sends a huge army to subdue Chōshū, and around the same time Shimonoseki gets bombarded by the four-nation fleet. Mai’s “insult to injury, so much” is exactly right, and this is Chōshū’s rock bottom. Chōshū surrenders without fighting, and has its three senior retainers commit seppuku. And yet, right there, Takasugi Shinsaku raises an army and flips the whole domain around.
Takasugi Shinsaku’s too strong. Nobody beats Takasugi.
And now, here’s my favorite part.
Chōshū resented Satsuma so bitterly that there’s even a story about writing ‘Satsuma thieves, Aizu scoundrels’ on the sole of their geta and walking on it.
The way they hold grudges is so elementary school lol. It’s like writing your least favorite classmate’s name inside your indoor shoes.
I laughed at that. And Chōshū joins hands with the very target of that grudge just two years later.
And yet, two years later in 1866, people like Sakamoto Ryōma step in, and Chōshū and Satsuma make up and join hands. The Satchō Alliance.
Wait, after saying they hated each other that much?! That’s so tsundere.
Tsundere, indeed. For the sake of overthrowing the shogunate, they had no choice but to join hands with yesterday’s enemy. And with this Satsuma-Chōshū alliance at its center, the Meiji Restoration happens, and Aizu, which had defended the palace at the Kinmon Incident, ends up on the side being attacked next time around.
So the Kinmon Incident wasn’t just a case of losing — it’s more like the starting point for everything that came after.
Mai’s summary here is probably the most correct one.
Getting carried away, I had several more made after this, covering the Namamugi Incident, the Anglo-Satsuma War, the Boshin War, the Satsuma Rebellion, and the Ansei Purge. Along the way, Rina’s speech gradually started sounding more adult, so I pointed out that the frivolousness was getting lost and had it dialed back. As the sessions went on, Mai started remembering what had happened in previous episodes, and began connecting incidents together on her own.
In this series, I plan to introduce, one at a time, the Bakumatsu-era incidents explained this way by a gyaru (since it’s a gyaru’s explanation, please go easy on the fine details).
Back to the original question. Can I now explain the Kinmon Incident?
Now I can say it. Chōshū got removed from the group chat, their anger meter maxed out at the Ikedaya, they stormed the palace and lost and became an enemy of the Emperor, wrote “Satsuma thieves, Aizu scoundrels” on the sole of their geta, and yet two years later made a tsundere alliance with Satsuma, and in the end ended up on the side that overthrew the shogunate.
First year of Genji, 1864, Hamaguri Gomon, Kijima Matabei and Kusaka Genzui. You’ve got this test in the bag.
References
This piece was planned and directed by Yuichiro Kuzuryu, written by AI.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2026/11/1912/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.