Neanderthals chose not to break the 150-person barrier
I keep hearing the claim that Neanderthals never left evidence of forming groups larger than 150 people.
Homo sapiens could share fictions — stories everyone believes together, like myths, nations, and money — so they could form large groups even among people who’d never met face to face.
That’s why they won.
Yuval Noah Harari’s Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind made this storyline widely known, and some people put it this way: Neanderthals lacked the language skills or the capacity for empathy, so they stayed in small bands and vanished.
Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind
Every time I read this, something about it bothers me.
I’ve seen, more than once, how completely the atmosphere of an organization changes on either side of the number 150. I’ve been fortunate enough to spend time in organizations of all kinds of sizes, from a handful of people at a startup to a large manufacturer, so I think I have some sense of the unpleasant feeling that hangs around that threshold. Knowing that feeling, I can’t quite swallow the phrase “couldn’t get past it.” Isn’t it possible they simply didn’t?
Let me first write down what I’ve felt firsthand.
I think the most comfortable size for an organization is somewhere between 5 and 20 people. Information reaches everyone properly, and when something needs deciding, everyone can decide it together. Nobody gets left out, and no strange factions form. You can’t do big things with so few people, but as an organization, you can get fairly close to an ideal state.
Once you reach 50 to 100 people, information no longer flows perfectly and communication is no longer seamless, so the organization has to be split into several units. Once it’s split, turf wars and friction between the units increase. Still, at this size, everyone can still rally around a charismatic leader.
Once you cross 150 or 200 people, people start showing up who try to govern the organization.
This is the birth of politics.
From there, a typical problem emerges. Something someone does with good intentions turns out to be overwhelmingly bad for someone else. Decisions made with good intentions slowly ruin the organization. Rule after rule gets made that saps initiative and flexibility. I’ve seen several executives grow so disgusted with this that they stepped down from leading their organizations (I understand the feeling completely).
This dividing line isn’t just something I imagined. The anthropologist Robin Dunbar says that the relationships a person can maintain fall into layers of roughly 5, 15, 50, and 150: five close friends, fifteen good friends, and an upper limit of 150 for relationships you can keep stable. W. L. Gore & Associates, the company known for Gore-Tex, became famous for a practice: whenever a single site approached 150 people, they would build a new site nearby. The founder reportedly learned from experience that things get awkward past 150 people — a nice detail, given that he arrived at it on his own, unrelated to Dunbar’s research.
How Many Friends Does One Person Need?: Dunbar’s Number and Other Evolutionary Quirks
There’s also research on the “good intentions ruin the organization” side of things. In a paper Larry Greiner wrote for the Harvard Business Review in 1972, he argues that organizations pass through crises as they grow, and that a solution that works well at one stage becomes the very problem at the next. The sequence runs: an organization driven by the founder’s leadership grows, a command structure gets introduced as headcount rises, and that command structure then becomes an obstacle to autonomy. Reading it stings a little (though maybe it’s not my own ears that sting, but the ears of a few people I know).
Evolution and Revolution as Organizations Grow (Harvard Business Review)
hbr.org
Now, back to the Neanderthals.
The first explanation that comes to mind for why they never exceeded 150 is that they weren’t intelligent enough. But it turns out Neanderthal brain volume was equal to ours, if not larger, and we now know they buried their dead and made elaborate tools and ornaments. At the very least, they don’t seem like a case you can dismiss with “they just weren’t smart.”
So was it a lack of capacity for language or fiction? Honestly, I’m not sure here. Several arguments try to estimate linguistic ability from fossils, but the matter doesn’t seem settled even among specialists.
The least interesting but most plausible explanation is simply that the population was small. If people were thinly scattered across a cold landscape, there was never an opportunity for 150 of them to gather in the first place. In that case, you can’t really say whether they “couldn’t” or “didn’t” exceed the number.
That’s a coherent explanation in its own right. But there’s one interesting piece of research worth mentioning here.
In 2022, Nature published a paper analyzing the DNA of Neanderthal remains found at Chagyrskaya Cave in the Altai Mountains of Siberia. It found a cluster of close relatives, including a father and his teenage daughter, and concluded that they likely lived in small bands of roughly 10 to 20 closely related individuals. The bands apparently stayed connected mainly through women moving between them.
Genetic insights into the social organization of Neanderthals (Nature, 2022)
Ten to twenty people.
That’s exactly the number I said felt most comfortable to me.
Of course, this is one cave from one period, and we can’t say Neanderthals lived this way everywhere. The paper’s authors themselves are cautious, saying we’ll need further discoveries to know whether this small size was the exception or the norm. Even so, the group they lived in was exactly the size where information reaches everyone and everyone can decide things together.
Here something occurs to me.
One hypothesis seriously discussed lately for why sapiens could form larger groups is “self-domestication.” The anthropologist Richard Wrangham and the evolutionary anthropologist Brian Hare, among others, have put it forward. Over a long span of time, sapiens groups collectively eliminated individuals who bullied others or who lashed out impulsively. As a result, traits with lower aggression — people less prone to suddenly striking someone in anger, and more friendly and docile — were selected for. The idea is that something like what turned some wolves into dogs also happened within humans themselves. Hare’s book even suggests that Neanderthals may have undergone less of this “domestication” than we did.
The Goodness Paradox: The Strange Relationship Between Virtue and Violence in Human Evolution
Survival of the Friendliest: Understanding Our Origins and Rediscovering Our Common Humanity
Reading this helped me sort my thinking a little.
Recall what happens in an organization once it passes 150 people. People who want to govern it appear, and rules get made that don’t match what you yourself want. To keep working in such an organization, you have to compromise, submit to some degree, and tell yourself it’s fine. I think the people who thrive in large organizations are not only capable, but also good at this kind of resignation (this isn’t an insult — most working people, myself included, earn their salary exactly that way).
What if the reason sapiens could form large groups had less to do with empathy or intelligence, and more to do with this skill at resignation? Maybe Neanderthals were simply holding on to the size at which life felt good.
It’s true that sapiens, who could form large groups, were strong. They hunted large animals through strength of numbers, expanded trade, and eventually spread across the whole planet. Looking only at the outcome, the contest is settled. But winning doesn’t mean the winners were living the right way. Watching people in organizations beyond 150 wear themselves down, buffeted by well-intentioned policies, I can’t help thinking that.
To be fair, with the evidence we have now, there’s no way to tell whether they “chose” small bands or simply “couldn’t choose otherwise” because of the cold and low population. My hypothesis is probably somewhat biased, coming from someone who knows how comfortable a small team can feel.
Still, if asked whether they couldn’t exceed it or didn’t exceed it, I’d cast my vote for the latter.
On the cliffs above Chagyrskaya Cave, a band of fewer than 20 people lived out their lives. Everyone probably knew what everyone else was thinking, and they likely decided together how to divide up the game they caught. There was probably no factionalism there, and no mysterious rules made with good intentions.
Honestly, I’m a little envious.
References
- Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, Kawade Shobo Shinsha
- Robin Dunbar, How Many Friends Does One Person Need?, Intershift
- Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point (on Gore’s 150-person rule)
- Larry E. Greiner, Evolution and Revolution as Organizations Grow, Harvard Business Review (1972, 1998)
- L. Skov et al., Genetic insights into the social organization of Neanderthals, Nature 610 (2022)
- Nature Digest, “A Genetic Snapshot of a Neanderthal Family”
- Richard Wrangham, The Goodness Paradox, NTT Publishing
- Brian Hare and Vanessa Woods, Survival of the Friendliest, Hakuyosha
This piece was conceived and directed by Kuzuryu, and written by AI.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2026/10/1901/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.