Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

I spent a day as a mentor at NEDO's NEP training

Starting this fiscal year, I’ve been involved in several NEDO projects. One is “NEP Kaitaku” — NEP is a program for developing next-generation entrepreneurs, and Kaitaku (“Pioneer”) targets people closer to the very starting line.

The one-day training session was a storm of hellish one-on-ones… no, actually it was more like a heavenly pile of happy mentoring.

In short, it was a one-day triathlon of group mentoring and one-on-ones, in which I talked intensively with around 15 budding entrepreneurs. I sat on the mentor side.

Physically, I’m exhausted. Mentally, it was a deeply fulfilling day. So let me ramble about it below.

Everyone is interesting

Everyone who gets into NEP goes through a selection process. A fairly substantial subsidy comes with it, so that makes sense. I took part in that selection process too. Most of the participants are researchers of some kind, and every one of their research topics is interesting.

I have to say this loudly.

Some of the research gets me fired up — “This needs to go into the world right now!” Some of it makes me burn with anger alongside the researcher — “Why can’t something this important get past the regulations! Argh.” And some of it leaves me thinking, “Interesting, but who exactly does this help, and with what?”

Still, everyone is interesting.

Plenty of people in NEP Kaitaku say “I’m still researching.” Some haven’t settled on when, or whether, to start a company. That’s completely fine.

That’s exactly what this place exists for.

NEDO is an incorporated administrative agency funded by the national budget. What it needs isn’t to make money — it’s to give a little water and a little nutrient to seeds that could connect to the next generation, without crushing them, and to support them until they can grow on their own.

“Interesting research” doesn’t mean “funny” or “fun.” It means “fascinating.” You can’t know yet whether it will change the world, but it’s interesting because you can glimpse even a few microns of that possibility.

I don’t think we should crush that, and I don’t think a country that crushes it has a future. VCs won’t put up money for it — of course they won’t — so the state has to.

It’s fine to head in either direction

I’ve run startups myself more than a little, and I still serve as an advisor to startups today, so I know firsthand both the appeal and the brutality of equity funding.

When an acquaintance or a friend of mine raises funding, the people with experience don’t say “Congratulations!” or “Amazing!” They say things like “This is where it really begins. Brace yourself,” or “Well, there’s no turning back now” — with a wry smile.

Most people in NEP aren’t at that stage yet. That’s exactly why it’s a very good thing that it’s fine to head in either direction.

Basic research is, in most cases, an act of committing decades of one’s life. So is founding a company: a few years at minimum, and for some, decades — an act of committing everything you’ve got.

But it’s different from basic research. You do it even covered in humiliation, even as your relationships collapse, your body breaks down, your private life gets torn to shreds. You understand that in this unreasonable zero-sum game, most people end up losing, land back at zero, battered in body and mind — and you choose to commit anyway.

Someone who warns you about that, I think, is a good mentor. The optimal strategy for the dark side of capitalism that clings to startups is to maximize the denominator of reckless fools and then extract as much profit as possible from the few who succeed — so the reckless fools are best pushed off a sheer cliff. But someone who warns you properly, instead, is a sincere person who understands that suffering and doesn’t hide it.

The advisors at NEP probably all tell everyone it’s fine to head in either direction.

Why? Because there’s no capital relationship involved.

NEDO is simply an agency that attaches subsidies, and for those of us on the advisor side, one condition is that we form no capital relationship with participants during the period we’re advising them.

In other words, all we want is to guide each person toward the answer that’s best for them personally.

We have no intention of luring anyone with bait and casting a line into a raging sea.

As a result, we speak quite openly and without hesitation: “your model doesn’t suit equity funding,” or “maybe build up more basic research before doing this,” or “this model probably doesn’t work, so maybe pivot,” or even just “I honestly don’t get it.”

We don’t criticize harshly for no reason, we don’t nitpick, we don’t care whether you go public or get acquired. I think that’s a genuinely fair way to operate.

No need to put up a front

Because of that kind of relationship, the people being mentored don’t need to put up a front either. I’ve been involved in fundraising many times myself, and yes — you exaggerate. A lot.

I have no fundraising planned anytime soon, and I’m a reasonably restrained middle-aged man at this point, so I’ll say it plainly: you really do pile it on. Early-stage startup materials. What you say. How you carry yourself.

But the truth is that in most cases, a startup founder at that stage is nobody in particular — they don’t yet have the value or the capacity for responsibility that would warrant hundreds of thousands of dollars. Plenty of people, having actually received that money, turn around two or three months later and say something like, “Well, turns out that business model wasn’t so great, so we’ve decided to pivot.” Nobody has exact numbers, but there are surely plenty of them.

To get chosen out of that chaos, out of the faceless crowd, you have no choice but to accept that some degree of embellishment is simply how it works.

Something different happened at the training session the other day.

A young participant shared progress on a certain solution, and I pushed back: “Technically, plenty of other people are already working on something similar — don’t you need to go more vertical, or there’s no path to winning?”

In front of a VC, he probably would have said — and would have needed to say — something like, “No no, we already have this much traction, this many potential customers, and here’s what next term’s revenue will look like. It would be a loss not to invest now.” You have to say that, or investors won’t fund you.

But what he actually said was, “No, you’re right. I honestly don’t know where to go vertical…” We discussed it from there, and concluded that by steadily building up the proof of concept in front of him, without spending out of pocket, the right vertical to target might become visible. Wonderfully constructive.

Without that kind of front, instead of an all-or-nothing gamble, you get a flat, constructive discussion — and advice is actually worth giving.

For anyone who’s just founded a startup, or is thinking about founding one, having someone nearby who can talk this fairly with you is essential — a mentor, an advisor, a consultant, or in some cases an angel investor. About 15 years ago, I remember telling someone at JETRO how thin that kind of support was here. Silicon Valley is overflowing with people like that; Japan, I said then, really didn’t have much of it. At this one-day NEP training session, there must have been around 20 people acting as mentors. I was struck by how much that’s changed since then.

On the advisor as a profession

The backgrounds of the people serving as mentors in the NEP project vary widely. There are former investors, and I often see the title “registered management consultant” on business cards. There are people out of R&D at manufacturers, former senior executives from the R&D divisions of major corporations, and people from think tanks and consulting firms.

I founded my own startup, raised funding myself, and I’m originally a development person who has also done project management. That’s my actual profession, and I take on the advisor role out of a feeling that I should share what I can from my wide-ranging, stumble-through-everything real-world experience — more “it’d be nice if I could share it” than anything grander.

I can speak from “here’s how it was in my own experience,” or “here’s how it went for people who founded startups around the same time as me.” Modesty aside, I think that’s fairly substantial. But I have to be honest that the topics I can speak to are limited to the range my own expertise and curiosity can reach.

Listening to a certain senior advisor speak, I was struck by how much broader his range was. He can pick up any topic and attach advice to any category — environmental issues, AI, healthcare, beauty, vegetables, toilets, mining, anything.

He draws on things like “something Professor So-and-so, whom I know, said,” or “in a project I was involved with in the past.” He hasn’t founded and run a startup himself. He hasn’t tasted that particular bitterness: the mental struggle of fighting the fear of running out of money every month, the mistrust of people that makes you not want to talk to anyone for months, jolting awake in the middle of the night upon realizing some terrible mistake.

And yet, from the sheer density of having watched, at close range, all sorts of things happen to all sorts of people, the volume of knowledge he can pull out instantly, like opening a drawer, made me realize this reaches a level that genuinely constitutes a profession.

For someone like me, whose differentiator is giving advice backed by lived experience, there’s a dilemma I keep stumbling over: an N=1 experience isn’t necessarily meaningful to the person listening. There’s a kind of enlightenment that can justify this — “there’s no such thing as perfect advice” — but even so, I think there are times it isn’t useful to the recipient, or is even harmful.

People like him, who have worked as professional advisors across so many fields, who have glimpsed so many different situations firsthand, and who can respond sharply to any topic whatsoever, carry enough value on that alone to count as a profession. I felt like I was grasping that for the first time, and honestly, I was moved by it.

Everyone, do your best

Everyone in NEP is quite early on their respective paths, and honestly, you need to discount heavily how many of them will actually found a company, let alone reach fundraising.

But that’s fine.

The goal each person reaches is different, and so is the process to get there. Someone might not start a company around the idea they’re considering now, but a few years later, through some chance encounter, found one and casually raise funding. Someone might found a company on momentum, fail to raise any funding at all, fold it, think “I’m never doing that again” — and then have some turn of life’s cycle reawaken that entrepreneurial spark. Someone might found a company, succeed or fail, and end up in a position like mine, giving advice.

And if, somewhere along that process, after time has passed, something triggers a memory and someone thinks,

“Come to think of it, 10 years ago — or was it 20? — someone at NEDO said something like this…”

that would be a perfect score. I’d say I’ve fully repaid what I owe that person.

It’s not a debt worth much, so there’s no need to repay it. Just don’t stop moving forward. Good luck.

That, I was reminded once again, is the mentality of most good mentors and advisors.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2026/10/1887/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.