Fewer Bicycles Is the Strongest Traffic Safety Policy
Even though everyone was worked up about it in April.
The blue ticket system for bicycles was introduced on April 1. Television aired footage of the crackdown day after day. Everyone was talking about the 113 types of violations, the fines of up to ¥12,000, what would happen if you rode on the sidewalk.
Now nobody is talking about it.
There must be a reason it’s been forgotten, I thought, so I went to look at the numbers.
The National Police Agency published the operational status for the first month. Blue tickets were issued 2,147 times nationwide. The previous year’s monthly average number of enforcement actions, limited to the violation types now covered by blue tickets, was 4,268, so that’s roughly half. Even counting red tickets together, the total enforcement count was 2,980, about 60% of the same month the previous year.
Meanwhile, guidance warning cards were issued 135,855 times. That’s 1.5 times the previous year’s monthly average.
In other words, in the month the police gained this authority, tickets were cut in half.
And warnings increased by 1.5 times to make up for it.
A National Police Agency official explained it this way: this is likely the result of placing weight on on-the-spot guidance and warnings in order to spread awareness of the system and traffic rules. Blue tickets, the official said, were mainly issued for cases where people ignored a police officer’s warning, or cases where pedestrians were put in danger.
The blue ticket isn’t being operated as a punishment for the violation itself, but as a punishment for ignoring a warning.
I don’t think this is a failure. If anything, isn’t it working exactly as designed?
A person carrying a sword doesn’t need to draw it. Once the other side knows you’re carrying one, that’s enough to make them comply. The number of times you actually draw it goes down. Once the warning carries real backing, that’s naturally what happens.
The goal was never to make everyone comply. It was to create a state in which people could be made to comply. That’s how the numbers read.
By the way, here’s the breakdown of blue tickets: failure to stop, 846 cases, 40%; using a phone while riding, 713 cases, 33%; running a red light, 298 cases, 14%; entering a crossing with the barrier down, 156 cases; riding on the right side of the road, 63 cases.
Surprisingly, “riding on the sidewalk” isn’t on the list.
The very “riding on the sidewalk” that was such a hot topic, that stirred up so much debate.
What is this, I thought.
But here’s where it gets interesting.
Behavior did change.
JAF Mate’s editorial team conducted an observational survey on a road in Tokyo with a bicycle lane. Between 7 and 8 a.m. on a weekday, 384 of 465 bicycles rode in the lane, 83%. 81 bicycles rode on the sidewalk, 17%.
In the same survey in June 2024, 155 of 262 bicycles, 59%, used the lane, and 107, 41%, used the sidewalk. In two years, sidewalk riding dropped from 40% to under 20%.
So it’s fair to say the rule worked.
But only where a lane exists.
A survey by Nomura Research Institute covering Tokyo and the six surrounding prefectures shows a different picture. About 40% of bicycle users have made some kind of behavioral change. Here’s what that looks like.
21.9% reduced how often they ride a bicycle at all. 14.1% stopped riding on rainy days.
As for what people who stopped riding switched to: walking, 77.1%; public transit, 36.7%; private car, 22.6%. And 5.8% said they’re holding back on going out or shopping.
In another survey, the top scenario where people said they’d started feeling anxious after the blue ticket system was introduced was “riding on roads with heavy traffic,” at 45.7%.
Put together, this is what it comes to.
Where a lane exists, everyone started riding in the lane. Where no lane exists, people gave up cycling.
A rule can raise the utilization rate of infrastructure that already exists. It cannot create infrastructure that doesn’t exist. So in places without that foundation, the rule doesn’t correct behavior, it erases the behavior itself.
Crack down on bicycles, and bicycles decrease.
And this doesn’t show up as a failure in the statistics. Violations go down. Accidents might go down too. People who stopped riding don’t appear in any table.
Here I want to talk about the Netherlands.
I’ve been there several times, and no matter where you go in that country, the bicycle paths are well developed. It’s the kind of thing you notice within minutes of arriving. Germany and the UK are both far better than Japan, but the Netherlands is a cut above even them, several cuts above, really.
I once asked a Dutch friend why they go to such lengths.
The answer came instantly.
“To cut medical costs.”
It wasn’t an answer that came after thinking it over. It had the speed of someone being asked something obvious.
At the time, I just took it at face value and moved on. Later I looked it up, and there were real numbers behind it.
There’s a study published in the American Journal of Public Health in 2015. Written by three authors, Fishman, Schepers, and Kamphuis, it uses the WHO’s HEAT (Health Economic Assessment Tool) and life table calculations to estimate, at the population level, the health benefits that cycling brings to the Dutch.
Here’s the result. Cycling prevents roughly 6,500 deaths a year. Thanks to cycling, Dutch life expectancy is six months longer on average. And this health benefit exceeds 3% of GDP.
The paper’s conclusion is even more direct. Policies that promote cycling, such as investment in improving bicycle infrastructure and facilities, are likely to produce a high benefit-cost ratio in the long run.
In other words, the Netherlands justified building bicycle paths using health economics.
They ran the calculation, and chose the option that cost more money.
And that calculated result has sunk in deeply enough that an ordinary person can produce it instantly, off the top of their head.
So what about Japan?
Honestly, I don’t know whether medical costs will rise in Japan. The top substitute is walking at 77%, and walking isn’t bad for your health. Looking only at that, you could say it’s not a big deal.
But walking can only substitute for short distances. 22.6% have shifted to private cars. Exercise drops to zero, emissions increase, and the severity of accidents is nowhere near comparable to bicycle accidents. 5.8% are holding back from going out at all. And the single most common purpose for cycling is shopping, accounting for 44.5%. What’s being cut away is movement within people’s daily living areas.
I don’t know whether the net result is positive or negative.
The problem is that nobody knows.
Because nobody has calculated it. The Netherlands put numbers into HEAT, got an answer of 3% of GDP, and spent money on that basis. In the legislative process behind Japan’s blue ticket system, I can’t find this kind of assessment anywhere.
If you asked a Japanese person why the blue ticket system exists, I doubt you’d get an answer at that speed. I can’t answer it either.
And yet the public already knows the answer.
In one opinion poll, people were asked what they thought would be effective for promoting safe bicycle use. The top answer was “road infrastructure improvements such as dedicated bicycle lanes,” at 65.1%. Enforcement came in at 53.4%, in third place.
Making rules is cheap. Building infrastructure is expensive. So the cheap option got implemented.
Up to this point, well, it’s unfortunate, but it’s a familiar story.
I think there’s one more twist worth making, though.
Not calculating is precisely the condition that makes the cheap option possible.
The Netherlands ran a rigorous estimate. That’s only natural when deciding policy. But once you’ve run the calculation, you’re forced to choose the more expensive option. That’s exactly what happened to the Netherlands. A country that produced a figure of 3% of GDP could never choose not to build bicycle paths.
So as long as Japan decides not to calculate, this system can never fail.
A person who doesn’t ride a bicycle will never cause a bicycle accident. Nor will they commit a violation. So the 21.9% who stopped riding are, statistically speaking, a success. If accidents decrease, it gets announced as the effect of safety measures; if violations decrease, it gets explained as the result of awareness efforts taking hold. The 5.8% who are holding back from shopping trips appear in no table at all. There’s no column to put them in.
The numbers are guaranteed to improve.
The safest bicycle user is the person who doesn’t ride a bicycle.
Thinking about it this way, it starts to make sense that no follow-up report has come out since the first month’s tally. No three-month figures, no six-month figures, not yet. Probably they never will come. If you don’t measure it, nothing comes out. If nothing comes out, nothing was ever wrong.
The system continues. Guidance warnings are being issued today, too. Nobody is talking about it.
A few years from now, there will probably be an announcement saying bicycle accidents have decreased.
That won’t be a lie. And it’s precisely because it won’t be a lie that it’s so vicious.
References
- National Police Agency, “On the Operational Status One Month After the Introduction of the Traffic Violation Notification System for Bicycles” (May 14, 2026) https://www.npa.go.jp/news/release/2026/20260514.pdf
- JAF Mate Online, “After the Start of Blue Tickets for Bicycles, the Share of Bicycles Riding in Bicycle Lanes Rather Than on Sidewalks Jumps to Over 80%” https://jafmate.jp/car/surveyteam_20260505.html
- Nomura Research Institute, “Behavioral Change Accompanying the Introduction of Blue Tickets for Bicycles” https://www.nri.com/jp/knowledge/report/20260515_1.html
- Kioicho Strategy Institute, “59% Say Introduction of Blue Tickets for Bicycle Violations ‘Affects Daily Life’” https://ksi-corp.jp/topics/survey/2026/web-research-114.html
- Fishman E, Schepers P, Kamphuis CBM. Dutch Cycling: Quantifying the Health and Related Economic Benefits. Am J Public Health. 2015;105(8):e13-e15. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26066942/
This piece was planned and directed by Yuichiro Kuzuryu, and written by AI.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2026/07/1711/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.