Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Among 48 World Cup teams, 'padding' sides win 8 group games

When I heard it was going to be 48 teams, my first thought was “that’s a blatant padding of numbers.”

From 32 to 48. A jump to 1.5 times the size. The bar for qualifying drops, the group stage turns into a showcase for weak teams, and easy games pile up for the top sides. I suspect a lot of people had exactly that thought.

Still, before criticizing, I decided to actually count. The full group stage schedule (all 72 matches) wrapped up yesterday, so now is exactly the time to check. How many wins did the teams that wouldn’t have qualified under the 2022 standard — the “picked-up” group — actually get this time? I’m going to count this for real.

All figures are as of the end of the group stage. The knockout round (round of 32) has just begun.

First, defining the “picked-up” group

Before counting, I need to decide who got “picked up.” Leave this vague and the conclusion can’t be verified.

The method is simple. 2026 has 48 slots. Applying each confederation’s actual 2022 slot count (32 total), the difference comes out to exactly 16. For each confederation, I used qualifying standings and FIFA rankings to identify the “lower-ranked teams that exceeded the 2022 slot count.” The remaining 16 are below.

Confederation2022→2026Picked-up group (teams that would have been cut)
UEFA13→16 (+3)Czechia, Scotland, Bosnia
CAF5→10 (+5)DR Congo, Tunisia, South Africa, Cabo Verde, Ghana
AFC6→9 (+3)Uzbekistan, Jordan, Iraq
CONCACAF4→6 (+2)Curaçao, Haiti
CONMEBOL4→6 (+2)Colombia, Paraguay
OFC0→1 (+1)New Zealand

Below, I count the results of these 16 teams.

Counting it up: 8 wins total

The group-stage wins for the 16 teams in the picked-up group came to 8 wins total.

But the meaning changes depending on who the opponent was. Broken down, it looks like this.

(A) “Giant-killing” wins over teams that would normally have qualified… 4 wins

(B) “Internal” wins between picked-up teams… 4 wins

The 4 wins in (B) are matches that wouldn’t have been scheduled at all under a 32-team format. Since neither team would normally be there, that matchup exists only because of the expansion. The wins that can genuinely be called “upside from expansion” are the 4 in (A), where favorites were beaten.

That said, it’s debatable whether even those 4 wins in (A) deserve to be called giant-killing. The teams beaten were South Korea, Qatar, Panama, and Turkey, none of which can unambiguously be called “favorites.”

Paraguay vs. Turkey in particular deserves a note on what it looked like to watch. Paraguay’s defense was extremely tight, and even after going down to ten men with a red card just before halftime, they held on for almost the full 90 minutes. That’s simply remarkable, and it’s not something you can do without endless patience and a relentless will to win. Turkey lacked ideas and showed tactical instability, but even accounting for that, Paraguay deserved praise here. The balance of power between the two sides is a separate question, though: Turkey sits in the 20s in the FIFA rankings, Paraguay around 40th. Both are mid-table, neither has reached the last two World Cups, and their recent records are similarly middling. With no clear favorite-underdog relationship, it was an impressive win, but too weak a case to call giant-killing.

For what it’s worth, 7 of the 16 teams advanced to the knockout stage. Given the assumption of “nothing but cannon fodder,” that’s a high number. Five teams finished with three straight losses (Tunisia’s goal difference was −10), so there certainly were teams making up the numbers, while others fought well. If it stopped here, the conclusion would simply be “expansion wasn’t so bad.”

Suspecting Colombia

But there’s one snag in this table of 8 wins. Colombia.

Colombia went through the group stage unbeaten, 2 wins and 1 draw, finishing top of their group. Their FIFA ranking sits around 13th, making them roughly South America’s third-strongest side after Brazil. They don’t look like a picked-up weakling. Even so, they ended up in the picked-up group because they finished 5th in South American qualifying. Under the 2022 standard (4 direct spots plus 1 intercontinental playoff spot), 5th place meant no direct qualification, only a playoff. Since they couldn’t qualify unconditionally, I mechanically placed them here.

But this isn’t accurate. Colombia didn’t finish 5th because they’re weak; South American qualifying is a round-robin among 10 teams where top sides grind each other down, so even a team ranked around 13th in the world can sink in the standings. In other words, I mistook the standing — a reflection of how brutal the qualifying format is — for actual strength.

So counting Colombia’s 2 wins in the picked-up group isn’t appropriate. They should be excluded. But excluding them needs one more piece of justification. Without clarifying whether “South America’s 5th-place slot” is a weak berth or one that’s nearly a lock to go through, the call can’t be made.

The culprit was Australia

So I lined up the past five tournaments’ worth of South America’s 5th-place slot (the 4.5-slot era, 2006–2022).

TournamentSouth America’s 5th placePlayoff opponent (confederation)Result
2006UruguayAustralia (then OFC)●Eliminated (on penalties)
2010UruguayCosta Rica (CONCACAF)○Advanced
2014UruguayJordan (AFC)○Advanced (5–0)
2018PeruNew Zealand (OFC)○Advanced
2022PeruAustralia (AFC)●Eliminated (on penalties)

The success rate is 3 out of 5, or 60%. At first glance that doesn’t look like “practically a straight ticket in,” but the breakdown changes the picture.

Against everyone except Australia (Costa Rica, Jordan, NZ), it’s 3 wins in 3 matches. In 2014 it was a one-sided 5–0 against Jordan. Meanwhile, both eliminations came against Australia, and both were decided on penalties (0–0 and 1–1). There wasn’t a single loss on the run of play; the reality is that the penalty-shootout coin flip landed on Australia’s side both times.

What’s more, Australia came via OFC in 2006 and via AFC in 2022. The gateway confederation was different each time, yet the opponent who dropped in happened to be Australia both times. It’s an accident where, in a down year for Asia/Oceania, a side that normally doesn’t belong to that tier slips in.

In other words, the real expected value of South America’s 5th-place slot is essentially a straight ticket in, if you set Australia aside. The call to put Colombia in the picked-up group was, after all, a mistake.

Colombia, to begin with, is a strong side that fought through South American qualifying, the toughest qualifying league there is, competing head-to-head with Brazil and Argentina. They should have been seen not as part of the picked-up group but as one of the tournament favorites. Out of respect, I’m removing them from the table.

Subtracting their 2 wins (both internal matchups), the picked-up group’s effective tally becomes 6 wins (4 giant-killings, 2 internal).

Setting the denominator: 6 wins out of 52

To see whether 6 wins is a lot or a little, let’s place it against the whole.

The group stage had 72 matches total. There were 20 draws, so 52 matches had a decisive result.

Of those 52 wins, 6 belong to the picked-up group (excluding Colombia). Of those, 4 came against what could be called stronger opponents (though, as noted, the substance of those wins is shaky).

One in twelve of the matches with a decisive result was a win for the picked-up group, and wins over favorites come in at under a tenth of the total. Not so many as to call it “nothing but cannon fodder,” but not so many as to praise it as “a strong showing” either. Seen against the whole, it’s a number that shows up only occasionally.

Was the “yield” small? — Same as a lottery

Only 4 giant-killings, and even those are shaky. You could read this as “the yield from expansion was small.” But that’s only true if you view football purely as a comparison of strength.

Viewed as entertainment, the assessment changes.

If you want to accurately determine the hierarchy of strength, upsets get in the way. Fewer of them means the strongest teams advance as expected. But as entertainment, a predictable result is precisely what’s boring.

The 48-team format separates these two things. The upper tier, where the title is contested, is protected by seeding so the top sides don’t grind each other down early, letting them advance as expected. The lower tier (weak groups, first-time qualifiers), on the other hand, is left with room for anything to happen. It’s a design that barely moves “who contests the title” while only increasing “where and what kind of upset happens.”

Seen this way, the easy games aren’t a design flaw; they’re the cost of making upsets possible. It’s the same as how losing lottery tickets are what make a winning ticket possible: Tunisia’s and Iraq’s three straight losses sit on the flip side of the match where Cabo Verde held Spain to a 0–0 draw, or Scotland’s first win in 36 years. Erase only the losing tickets, and you erase the winning ones too.

This is a familiar pattern in business as well. Lower the barrier to entry, and the value of “getting in” itself thins out, while evaluation shifts to “what you did once you got in.” FIFA expanded the slots to capture fans and broadcast reach in new countries and regions, and the metric it’s watching is “number of participating countries.” The metric for someone purely watching the football is “the substance of who survives.” It’s the same tournament; only the number being emphasized differs.

Prediction: the quarterfinals will almost certainly be the usual suspects

How far up will the upsets reach? This part is a prediction, but I’m fairly confident.

Some of the picked-up group will remain through the round of 16. But the lineup of the quarterfinals will almost certainly end up the same as under the old 32-team format.

Two reasons. The top favorites are protected by seeding from meeting each other early. And among the picked-up group’s survivors (6 teams, excluding Colombia), internal matchups like Colombia vs. Ghana mean the number naturally thins out the further the tournament goes.

Corroborating evidence just arrived. In the first knockout match involving the picked-up group, South Africa lost 0–1 to Canada and was eliminated. They were the strong performer who came through as group runner-up, but the host nation stopped them. Exactly the start one would expect.

Just in case, let me set the condition for being wrong, up front.

If even one team from the picked-up group (excluding Colombia) takes one of the 8 quarterfinal slots, this prediction is wrong.

If I’m wrong, I’ll own it. But I expect those slots simply won’t be filled. If the prediction holds, the conclusion is: even with the slots expanded to 48, the ones left standing at the end are, after all, the usual names. What expanded was only the entrance; the height of the summit hasn’t changed.

Closing

Starting from “that’s padding,” I went on to suspect Colombia, went back through five tournaments, and arrived at Australia. Not the conclusion I expected.

What’s left is this. There was cannon fodder in the expanded slots, but there were also teams that fought well. The pure upside is 4 wins, and even those are shaky in substance. But that’s not “a small yield” so much as the type of yield shifting, from “a comparison of strength” to “upsets.” And the lineup at the summit will probably settle back into the usual shape.

Finally, a word on the teams that suffered heavy defeats this time.

I watched the Scotland, Haiti, and Uzbekistan matches in full. There’s plenty to work on, visibly. The gap in strength against top nations is clear, and there are plenty of careless mistakes. They fall short in individual quality too.

Still, the basics — defending from midfield back, in particular — were something every one of these teams ran for, endured, and held firm on. Teams that don’t cut corners there will grow. It’s a road Japan has walked too, and as a fan I think I understand how hard what comes next is. It won’t happen overnight. It can only be built up over 10, 20 years, piecing together a football of your own.

Cabo Verde and Curaçao in their first appearances, Uzbekistan, Jordan, and even the teams that finished with three straight losses — they must have felt, firsthand this time, just how high the wall of the world’s best really is. Seeing it on television and standing there yourself carry different weight. Even Scotland took 36 years to finally get that one win. I hope this experience spurs them on, and that they come back again, grown enough in their own football that no one can call them “making up the numbers.” When that day comes, I’ll count the wins again.

The 48-team format was a well-made tournament, built to preserve a system where the strong properly survive while still letting the underdogs’ fighting spirit and the occasional upset be enjoyed in part. The lesson for myself, who dismissed it outright as “padding,” is: don’t decide before you count.


This piece: concept and direction by Yuichiro Kuzuryu, text by AI.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2026/06/1683/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.