The Trap of Being a Halfway White-Collar Worker
There was once a time, I think, when people could innocently say that white-collar workers were the winners.
You build up an education, put on a suit, type on a keyboard in an air-conditioned office, and earn an above-average salary. Compared with people working in factories or driving trucks, this was supposed to be physically easier and come with a longer lifespan. In fact, the advanced economies of the postwar era ran on the premise that “moving up from blue-collar to white-collar” was affluence itself.
Lately, this picture has started to seem suspicious to me.
I’ve been on the hiring side many times. During my time in the Bay Area, I watched laid-off middle-aged white-collar workers never make it back into a job. Since returning to Japan, I keep hearing the same story: “once you lose your seat in your 50s, there’s fundamentally no finding a new one.” The difficulty older workers face in changing jobs feels, from my own firsthand experience, bluntly cruel.
Meanwhile, I hear that people with a trade in their hands — electricians, plumbers — are still in such demand that the work never runs out.
A premise worth doubting
You earn a high white-collar salary when you’re young, and you raise your standard of living accordingly. You take out a mortgage, send your kids to private school, live in the city center — all on the premise that you can keep running at that pace until your 50s.
Then, somewhere along the way, it quietly collapses. You get laid off. There’s no new job you can adapt to. Or young white-collar workers simply get replaced more cheaply to begin with. Before you know it, your standard of living is fixed in place, but your income has vanished.
A study by the Urban Institute in the US found that among the “stable” group — people aged 50 and over who had worked for the same employer for five years or more — 28% experienced a major employer-driven layoff before retirement (Urban Institute “How Secure Is Employment at Older Ages?”). Median household income drops sharply after a job loss, and even those who find new work mostly never return to their previous level. Some reports even find almost no difference in resilience to this shock between college graduates and non-graduates. A degree doesn’t protect you from a layoff.
So what about blue-collar work? There are unions, the ability to strike, local ties, and a residue of seniority-based trust. Licenses and skilled expertise don’t disappear with age — in some trades, the work actually grows more valuable as you get older.
Wait — isn’t blue-collar actually the happier path? The hypothesis crosses my mind.
History tells us the opposite
Here I have to be careful.
Nobel laureate economist Angus Deaton co-wrote Deaths of Despair and the Future of Capitalism (Anne Case and Angus Deaton), and it demolishes the hypothesis above.
Between 1999 and 2015, the group in the US that saw an explosive rise in deaths from suicide, drug overdose, and alcoholic liver disease was none other than white blue-collar workers without a college degree. Among college graduates, these death rates stayed essentially flat. Over this period, non-college-educated white men alone saw roughly 500,000 excess deaths — on the same scale as the death toll of the AIDS crisis.
In other words, the “blue-collar worker protected by unions, community, and generational succession of trades” I had pictured in my head was already a thing of the past. The hollowing-out of manufacturing, the collapse in union membership rates, the disintegration of local communities: since the 1970s, blue-collar America has been under continuous, structural fire.
The blue-collar image I had in my head is closer to the Shōwa-era blue-collar worker. It is not blue-collar work as it exists now, in progress.
And now, we may be at a turning point
Here’s where it gets interesting.
This relationship may now be reversing.
- In the US, skilled trades (electricians, plumbers, welders, etc.) are approaching a retirement cliff, and demand is expanding rapidly
- Union members earn 11.2% higher wages on average than non-union members, and have a 39% higher rate of health insurance coverage (BLS Union Members Summary)
- And while AI doesn’t directly replace physical manual labor, it has begun eroding entry-level white-collar jobs at a ferocious pace
Just as “globalization plus robotics” once devastated blue-collar workers in the Midwest, it may now be white-collar workers’ turn to be shaken by “globalization plus AI.” A reviewer of Case and Deaton’s book at LSE called this globotics, writing that white-collar workers are likely to join the despair that blue-collar workers have long experienced (LSE Review of Books).
Watching people come and go in the field as I do, this prediction honestly doesn’t feel far-fetched to me.
A brief word on AI coding
In this context, I want to write a little about software engineering, an area I understand relatively well myself. Purely as a personal opinion.
The evolution of AI coding has, frankly, been dramatic. Around 2022, it was “handy as an autocomplete tool” at best. By 2024–2025, it had reached the stage where you hand over a spec and it returns the implementation itself, in verifiable units. People who are seriously mastering agentic tools like Claude Code, Cursor, and others no longer discuss “an era without programmers” as a hypothetical — they discuss it as a matter of timing.
Whenever I write this, someone inevitably objects: “No, no, AI code still makes plenty of mistakes and can’t be trusted.” A few years ago that objection was fair. Say it today, though, and the air in the room shifts to suspecting the speaker themselves of not putting in the effort to master tool selection and usage. Which model you choose, how you design your prompts, how you build AI into your workflow, how you run review and testing — the gap between people who have pushed hard on these questions and people who haven’t is bigger than you’d expect. Even I, who have fortunately kept one foot in the field the whole time, increasingly find myself on the “not in the know” side, scrambling to catch up.
And this is about programmers — a corner of white-collar work that was thought relatively “trade-like” and relatively AI-resistant. Clerical work, accounting, legal, marketing, middle management, and other forms of “proceduralized knowledge work” should face even more direct pressure.
The problem of the in-between white-collar worker will probably start collapsing from this layer first.
What’s truly dangerous is the “in-between majority”
To organize what I’ve said so far, the picture looks like this.
First, there are white-collar workers who have secured their own place. Protected by autonomy, scarcity, and personal brand, they can turn around and use AI as a tool rather than be replaced by it.
Second, there’s the blue-collar layer doing physical, manual work. They have traditionally been placed in harsh conditions, and as the deaths-of-despair research shows, they’ve taken serious damage too. But at least this isn’t the kind of suffering that comes from the collapse of a self-image built on “I made it, I climbed up to white-collar.”
And finally, there’s the white-collar middle layer: a decent-but-unremarkable salary, generalist skills, replaceable by someone younger, yet fixed living costs.
It’s this middle layer that sits in the structurally hardest spot of all. You could say it’s the position where the suffering of a fall hits hardest.
Research by Modrek and colleagues at Columbia University shows that depression and anxiety among middle managers run higher than among frontline staff (Modrek & Cullen, 2012, “Job Insecurity during Recessions”, and follow-up studies). It’s the classic bind: no authority above, only responsibility below, autonomy that’s half-given at best. The research points out that middle managers fare better with either complete autonomy or comprehensive oversight — being caught in between is the worst.
In-between is the worst. I couldn’t agree more.
CDC data shows a sharp rise in suicide rates among white-collar managers aged 35–54, reportedly the steepest rise of any occupational group. This isn’t simply a matter of individual mental health — it should be seen as an injury inflicted by structure.
Bullshit Jobs and Golden Handcuffs
This argument can be reinforced from two more directions.
The first is the late David Graeber’s Bullshit Jobs: A Theory. In a YouGov survey conducted in the UK, 37% of respondents said their job made no meaningful contribution. In 2023, Simon Walo of the University of Zurich published a paper in Work, Employment and Society that gave this theory its first quantitative empirical support (Walo (2023) “‘Bullshit’ After All?”). People working in the white-collar occupations Graeber named are statistically significantly more likely to feel their work is socially useless.
Graeber drew a sharp line between shit jobs (blue-collar work that’s hard but necessary) and bullshit jobs (white-collar work that’s well-paid but meaningless). The latter comes wrapped in honor and prestige — respected as a professional, well paid, treated as a high achiever. And yet the person secretly feels they’ve accomplished nothing.
The second is Golden Handcuffs. The phenomenon where quitting a high-paying job feels impossible is, in clinical terms, not a matter of logic but of the nervous system. Identity fused with job and compensation, concentrated risk (retirement savings, mortgage, and children’s education all tied to the same company’s stock), and the fear of losing social standing.
Logically, you know “quitting and doing what you want on a lower income would make you happier” — but your nervous system won’t allow it.
I feel this acutely myself, on the receiving end of career consultations.
So, what do we do
Whenever I write something like this, people always ask: “So what should we do?”
Honestly, there’s no clean prescription.
One thing I can say is this: it’s better to assume that a life plan built on the premise of running forever as a white-collar worker is no longer a viable premise.
If you let a high salary in your youth dissolve entirely into a higher standard of living, the damage when things collapse in your 40s or 50s grows exponentially larger. Once you’ve raised your standard of living, lowering it is brutally painful, and with a family to support, it’s not even something you can decide to do alone.
The years of high income should be treated not as a time to raise your standard of living, but as a time to buy future options — assets, skills, networks, health, relationships with family. This isn’t idealism; it’s structural self-defense.
The other thing is to seriously weigh a choice between two paths: become a white-collar worker who can build their own place, or, if not, build another axis early on. I happen, fortunately, to be on the former side — someone who has managed to build a reasonable place for myself — but not many people can do this. A career built on the premise that “staying employed somewhere equals safety” is going to get considerably harsher over the coming decades.
As for blue-collar work, it may be due for a reassessment. Work done with your hands, work tied to physical space, work where licenses and trust carry weight — these are relatively sheltered from the first wave of AI, and demand is growing on the back of labor shortages. The unspoken social premise that looks down on blue-collar work may be due for an update before too long.
In closing
Looked at positively, I’m fortunate to be someone who has managed to carve out his own place on the edges of white-collar work. I run my own company, I do advisory and consulting work, and I teach at a university. I’m aware that this is a lucky position to be in.
But when I look around me, I see so many people stuck in the white-collar middle, carrying a quiet “this isn’t how it was supposed to go.” They studied, they worked reasonably hard, they didn’t do anything wrong. And yet, somehow, they find themselves with nowhere to go.
What these people needed, I think, was probably a chance, much earlier on, to question their faith in white-collar work.
I’m not going to go so far as to say blue-collar work is the happier path. But I do think that if we, as a generation, don’t start questioning the premise that “running the white-collar race to the finish means winning,” the next 10 to 20 years are going to be fairly brutal.
This piece was conceived and directed by Yuichiro Kuzuryu; the writing itself was done by AI.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2026/04/1570/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.