Entrepreneurs are not supermen
Technical skill, a name known in the field, management ability, charisma, the power to draw people in…
Is that a superman?
My own view actually runs the opposite direction. You can’t generalize about which entrepreneurs or executives succeed, but if you look at “the type of executive who seems to bat a high average,” the pattern is overwhelmingly what you’d call a “lovable mess of a person” (true of the people around me too). You can’t say this to their face, mostly because they have no intention of being that way.
Looking from the outside, I think the media works a clever bias into how entrepreneurs get portrayed. That’s natural enough — without it, nothing would feel exciting. If some brilliant serial entrepreneur who launches one bold venture after another turned out to be well-behaved, a careful listener, and ran things democratically based on employee input rather than through forceful leadership, no drama would come of it at all. Readers need a steady stream of rival showdowns, internal coups, private gossip, and last-minute comebacks from the brink, or they lose interest fast.
In short, a good deal of it is fabrication or exaggeration.
Now, time to talk about what’s actually real. Entrepreneurs fall into a few categories. For example, an old book, “Beyond Entrepreneurship” by Collins & Lazier, defines leadership style as including:
- Authenticity
- Decisiveness
- Focus
- Personal Touch
- Hard/Soft People Skills (the ability to work members hard while still making them feel fulfilled)
- Communication
- Ever Forward
The book argues that a great leader doesn’t rely on a single one of these styles but holds several and knows how to switch between them. This isn’t limited to entrepreneurs. Think of a leader close to you — someone you’d call “a good leader” — and they probably carry several of these, maybe even most. I’d go further: I can’t think of anyone regarded as “a good leader” who scores low across the board here.
So, thinking in terms of “several,” consider someone who has only “Focus,” “Communication,” and “Ever Forward.” Someone intent on setting a goal and pushing toward it, good at talking that goal up to the people around them.
That’s basically a con artist. (laughs)
But I think this is the pattern for “people who aren’t great but still succeed” (based on what I’ve observed). The point is that when the people around a leader can see clearly where the weakness lies, there’s a lot they can do to help. Take decisiveness: the people around a leader can gather useful information and act as a sounding board, effectively filling in for weak decision-making. Even a leader who’s bad with relationships rarely causes real breakdowns if the team members themselves have built solid relationships with each other. If communication is handled well, even a leader who’s a bit sloppy about delegating tasks shouldn’t be a problem, since the members can support and push each other forward.
But when a leader lacks drive, or doesn’t try to articulate a vision and strategy and get it to take root in the team, the people around them end up in real trouble. It’s not a pleasant thing to say, but the team often splits apart. Someone else inside the team starts exercising their own leadership instead. At that point the question of whether the business succeeds or not is already beside the point.
A person who fully receives the support of the people around them, is grateful for it, and keeps pushing forward no matter how many times they stumble, without giving up or growing discouraged — most people find meaning and fulfillment in supporting someone like that. That’s one of the ways a startup comes together as a going concern.
All of this was a shock I came to realize fairly early after moving from Japan to Silicon Valley. Back in Japan, I’d assumed “having technical skill” and “being smart” were the absolute conditions for a startup’s success.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1267/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.