Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Should You Start A Company In A Field You Already Know Well

This point is best approached by considering how you’d answer the “frequently asked questions thrown at startups.”

【Question 1】Why do you think you can win in that domain? 【Question 2】How do you plan to differentiate yourself from other companies? 【Question 3】How do you plan to validate your needs hypothesis?

<Case 1>

Suppose, for instance, that you are a renowned researcher or inventor in some field. When you start a company in an area of expertise you know well, the answer to these questions is extremely clear.

【Answer 1】Because I’m the best specialist in the industry 【Answer 2】Because the XX I developed has industry-leading performance that no other company can match 【Answer 3】I’ve been running hypothesis validation for over a decade now. I have strong conviction about the market need

And that’s it. It’s almost a defiant presentation, as if to say “anyone who has a problem with that can come say it to my face.” But as long as it’s true, no one can really argue with it.

<Case 2>

Now suppose instead that your situation is more like “I have a few years of experience in that domain.”

【Answer 1】 I have ◯ years of experience in that domain, but I’ve seen most manufacturers stumble because they couldn’t solve XX. In fact, my previous company also failed to scale its service enough because of XX. But the ×× we’ve developed this time is expected to solve that problem. 【Answer 2】 The ×× we developed this time requires material △△, which only one manufacturer in China can produce. We’ve signed a limited supply agreement with that manufacturer through 202X, which we intend to use to secure a first-mover advantage. Competitors will likely emerge eventually, but we plan to address that by locking in users before they do. 【Answer 3】 As I mentioned, I have ◯ years of experience in the industry and have direct contact with promising prospective customers. We already have PoC plans in place with several companies and intend to finish the hypothesis validation phase by the end of this year.

The overall impression isn’t bad. Each answer offers a reason that’s logically sound and reasonably convincing.

<Case 3>

Finally, suppose you’re trying to start a business in a domain you’re completely unfamiliar with.

【Answer 1】 I admit I have no professional experience in the field of 〇〇, but I’m confident that no one loves 〇〇 more than I do. I’ve built up experience hoping to someday start a business related to 〇〇. My main specialty is ××, but actually, almost all of that is technology that can be repurposed for 〇〇. No one in the 〇〇 field seems to have had that idea, and it even seems to be treated as taboo in the industry. So I want to boldly apply my experience in ×× to create △△ and bring about a revolution in the 〇〇 field. 【Answer 2】 As I mentioned, there isn’t even a single company currently considering introducing △△. Also, using △△ requires experience with ××. We have both of these, but at this point our competitors have neither. We can secure a decisive first-mover advantage. 【Answer 3】 This is actually the point where I feel the most risk. I’m not optimistic enough to think no one has ever considered introducing △△ in the past. That means there’s some reason within the 〇〇 field that prevents △△ from being actively adopted, and we’ve already formed several hypotheses about that reason and are working on solutions. That said, there’s a mountain of very real challenges, such as the risk of unforeseen reasons emerging or whether a smooth workflow can actually be achieved, and we think we should eliminate those risks as early as possible. Fortunately, one of our existing shareholders has a portfolio company related to 〇〇, and we’re planning to build a scheme to tackle hypothesis validation using that connection.

These aren’t bad responses at all, are they?

Actually, the answer itself doesn’t matter.

Every one of these people gave a reasonably good response. One that would make an investor think “maybe I should invest in this.” One that would make someone in a hiring or executive recruitment scenario think “maybe I should join this company.”

This is a common trick, but the questioner is almost always trying to see the entrepreneur’s character through how they answer. This is especially true the earlier the stage.

For example, there’s significant risk in someone who is actually in Case 2 but behaves as if they were in Case 1. That’s because they’re misjudging themselves. Confidence is a wonderful thing, but overconfidence can erode humility, make someone stop listening to others, or cause them to keep marching down a dead-end road without realizing they’re already finished.

Likewise, someone in Case 3 who doesn’t anticipate any fragility in their hypothesis might also be a bit overconfident. Conversely, someone who is clearly in Case 1 by any measure but is drawing up a plan like Case 2 might lack the drive and sense of speed needed, and might fail to hit the accelerator when they should. I wouldn’t join a company like that myself, and I wouldn’t bring one into my portfolio either.

Personally, I think that for someone who can objectively view themselves and the market, build a legitimate plan in response, and take action, which domain they choose to start a business in is, honestly, a trivial matter.

The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1261/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.