Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

A Degree Does Not Decide Who Can Start a Company

This question has two sides to it: a question of “how things should be” and a question of “how things actually are.”

First, the “how things should be” side.

Whether you hold a degree isn’t the essential issue. When I was in Silicon Valley, I got to know a number of engineers. I was often surprised that, whenever I met someone and thought “this guy is amazing,” they frequently turned out not to have a degree in Computer Science. When I asked why, the answers were never more than things like “back then I wanted to become a so-and-so” or “none of the classes really clicked for me” or “you all should think more seriously about your future!” And yet these people were complete “software nerds” — the kind who wake up on Sunday and code until they go to sleep. It would hardly be an exaggeration to say they’d given everything to it. They just happened not to have a degree. So you see, technical skill and a degree aren’t necessarily the same thing. I suspect most of you already know this, more or less from experience.

Now the “how things actually are” side.

Say your company grows steadily and gets featured in Forbes’ “Startups to Watch Next Year (working title).” Suppose your degree has nothing to do with your business. The interviewer hears about your background and thinks, “(Hm… the degree doesn’t connect to the business at all… huh).” Probably. They brace themselves and ask, “(Maybe there’s an interesting story about getting some other degree instead?),” but nothing resembling good material comes falling out (as described above). Your background just doesn’t photograph well for the media. I don’t know whether they secretly wished you’d gotten a PhD in CS at Stanford and then an MBA, but — ha.

Or say your company is raising funding. Suppose your business is developing AI-related edge devices. You manage to connect with an overseas venture capital firm, and you reach the point of being considered for due diligence. At that moment, another company happens to show up in front of them at the same time, with a similar idea, at a similar stage, chasing a similar amount of funding. The other company is a Chinese startup whose CEO holds a PhD in computer science from Tsinghua University, with team members who studied at Peking University, the University of Science and Technology of China, and who’ve done exchanges at NYU or MIT — an impressive lineup of credentials. Your team, by contrast, are graduates of mid-tier Japanese universities in electrical engineering or chemistry. How does that look to the VC? No chance of winning?

But suppose your team actually started together at a major development firm, and spent over five years working in a division developing cutting-edge IoT devices and communication equipment. How does that look to the VC now? Your prototype is already nearly complete, and your business plan projects profitability next fiscal year, and it’s not an unreasonable projection either. How does that look…

That’s about where it evens out, I’d say. With that much behind you, it evens out.

To be clear, VCs are extremely sharp and serious people. They’re not sitting there flipping through resumes and muttering comments like some defunct Showa-era hiring interview template. But a VC is someone who repeats, over and over, the task of choosing one company to invest in out of hundreds of candidates. In other words, they can’t go in with a “well, this one seems fine, I guess” attitude. They make their investment decisions carefully, thoroughly, leaving no gaps, with solid conviction, checking and double-checking everything. In that process, of course they look at the degree. Of course they do. And naturally they don’t look only at the degree — they also look at the person’s research achievements, the papers they’ve written, and so on. That’s how they arrive at their overall judgment. And there’s no question that, in that overall judgment, the degree carries a certain weight.

The content of this post is drawn from (the original text of) the following book. If you’re interested, please consider picking up a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1255/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.