Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Starting a company in the countryside carries real disadvantages

One of the rankings published here and there is the “ranking of cities by number of unicorn companies.” In 2020, the top spot reportedly went to Beijing, followed by San Francisco in second and Shanghai in third. There’s also a “ranking of cities by startup funding amount,” among others, and as you’d guess, the names of regional cities almost never appear in rankings like these. Occasionally a region that a nation is strategically building up will show up, but in most cases the top spots belong to that country’s capital or its most densely populated area.

So if you’re going to start a company, a big city is the way to go, right?

That might be a bit hasty a conclusion. Every choice carries its own built-in merits and demerits. Let me talk through this with a few episodes.

This goes back more than 5 years, to when a friend of mine came to me for advice. My friend J was Canadian and was attending MIT at the time, so he was living in Boston, but before that he’d had an interesting career as a small-town doctor in a rural area. He had a plan to start a company with a colleague from his doctoral program, and the first round of funding already had a prospect lined up, but at that point the investor proposed — forced, really — that they relocate to Silicon Valley, and he agreed. So he came to me, since I was living in Silicon Valley at the time, to ask about livability, which areas to set up an office in, and the state of talent and salary levels.

Naturally (?), I irresponsibly rattled off all the wonderful things about Silicon Valley and told him it was “seriously an Exciting Paradise, come immediately!” He went on to set up an office in Silicon Valley, poached talent from companies like Google and Tesla to build his product, and even won a TechCrunch business contest, but about a year ago he closed the business. We exchanged a few messages recently, and it turns out he didn’t go back to Boston or Canada — he stayed in Silicon Valley and now works at Facebook. “It’s not as intense as when I was running the startup, but I’m enjoying it reasonably well,” he says now.

Let me offer my own take on a few points here.

First, when it comes to securing talent, the advantage of big cities doesn’t easily waver. Competition for talent gets fierce, but the inflow to match it never dries up, as J’s story shows. Honestly, I’ve rarely seen a city where this supply-demand balance has broken down significantly. Supply and demand seem to stay in equilibrium, or supply stays slightly ahead.

Diversity of options is also an advantage of big cities, I think. J unfortunately had to shut down his own startup, but his current employer is Facebook. Not bad — in fact, it’s a position most people would envy. You can take on challenges, you can work at a big company, and of course you can also work at a small or medium-sized one.

Now let me introduce another episode.

A Japanese friend of mine, Y, runs a company in a city in the Tōhoku region. Needless to say, it’s not Sendai. It’s Aizu.

The name is well-known enough, but it’s deep in snow country, far from the shinkansen, and not somewhere you’d go very often — that’s purely my personal impression.

Don’t jump to thinking “that must be tough, then.” There are several things I find quite impressive about how he’s done this. After all, his company has been around for more than 25 years.

First, there’s the connection to a university. He originally worked at the University of Aizu, and that’s where he started the company together with students. Since then, he’s apparently kept up a cycle of student interns, then employment, then in some cases, moving on and leaving the nest. Universities and startups generally have a strong connection. Even without a direct link, cities with many startups always have excellent universities nearby. It’s a chicken-and-egg thing, but where young talent gathers, new innovation happens. And that in turn draws in more young talent — a very simple story, I think.

I was also struck by how skillfully he makes use of the advantages of being in a regional area. In his case, for instance, he does a good job of picking up local work.

Anyone who has run a company knows that “money coming in every month” and “money coming in every year” are extremely valuable things. Put this way, it might sound like I’m talking purely about playing defense, but a steady source of income makes it easier to plan for the medium term. And it’s precisely because you can plan that you’re able to play both offense and defense.

National-level projects might involve large sums, but the competition for them is fierce too. In practice, those kinds of opportunities mostly get snatched up by big corporations — again, purely my personal impression. Startups and small-to-medium businesses end up as the children, or grandchildren, getting whatever scraps trickle down.

Given that, if you instead skillfully pick up projects from the prefecture or municipality, you can efficiently generate stable, sufficient revenue and use that as capital for taking on various challenges. This approach might not suit someone who thinks “let’s raise tens of millions of dollars and go for broke in one big gamble!” but seeing this kind of management, this kind of approach to taking on challenges, taught me a lot.

Another interesting thing about regional areas, I think, is the “similarity of context.”

Aside from people who originally lived there, many residents of regional areas have settled there either for work reasons or by their own choice. Such people, I’ve found, very often share a common context on a few fronts, like why they ended up there, or the fact that they don’t really intend to leave, one way or another. I understand this well from my own experience living in Hamamatsu — I did eventually leave, but I never disliked the place.

A very important factor in organizing a company is “culture fit”: whether one’s way of thinking, principles, and preferences align with the people around them. In a sense, regional areas are very uncomfortable for people who don’t fit the culture, so such people tend to leave quickly, which means anyone still there is very likely to be a culture fit. I’d guess the probability of a hiring mistake is also considerably lower.

The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1251/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.