Startups chase speed because rivals and money force it, not by nature
That’s true, but I think it’s a “speed” choice accumulated from working backward, backward, and backward from several surrounding circumstances. It isn’t necessarily something fundamental to the definition of “startup” as a whole. Let me sort this out below.
A friend of mine who once received support from 500Startups told me, “There are at least two other teams in the same batch working on the same idea as us.” As I’ve mentioned in other sections, ideas with truly standout novelty don’t really exist. Most business ideas are applications of similarities from other categories, small twists on which market a new technology gets applied to, or a focus on a market that hasn’t gotten much attention paired with meeting a need that already exists there. They rarely turn the world upside down. Naturally, then, tens of thousands of people across America and across the world are thinking about the same thing.
So put yourself in the shoes of a customer actually considering adopting a service. There’s a big difference between hearing “we’re currently developing it and expect to hand you a beta in six months” and hearing “the implementation is basically done, it’s being evaluated right now, and if an evaluation version works for you we can issue an account right here on the spot.” The former team may well be building a better product, but that’s a subtle difference that’s hard to convey. The customer will inevitably go with the latter proposal, thinking “well, I guess it’s fine to at least start evaluating it.”
Then there’s fundraising. An acquaintance of mine, Mr. T, told me he built the prototype for his first funding round in two weeks. He raised $5.3 million in that round, and at the time the team was just two people: Mr. T and a CTO who was about to join. With people moving at that kind of speed, if you’re thinking “let’s polish the prototype carefully before taking it to investors,” your competitors will be two or three laps ahead by the time you’re done. So if you show up a few months later with a slightly higher-quality prototype for a similar business idea, the VC that already put $5.3 million into Mr. T is, frankly, not going to react to your pitch at all.
In most cases, startup founders are nobody in particular at that point. Just a grad student, or a third-year salaryman fresh out of school. They might be able to scrape together a few hundred dollars, but a few thousand or tens of thousands would be a major struggle.
No money = no time
After all, as long as you’re alive you have to eat, drink, and have somewhere to sleep.
The first office of the startup I joined in the Bay Area was a cramped space above a pizza shop, on the second floor, so small that three people filled it up. It was a corner room overlooking Castro Street, and across the hall was a company with two Indian guys. They always sat in front of their displays without even turning the lights on. How do I know? Because their door was always left wide open. Why? I think it was to save on electricity (the hallway had air conditioning).
One day they suddenly disappeared. It turned out they’d gotten funding and moved to a bigger office. It’s a fairly touching story, but that kind of thing is scattered all over the startup world.
Castro Street, by the way, was a famous restaurant street in the Mountain View area, but I never once saw them go out to eat, nor did I ever see them eating in their room.
VCs (venture capitalists) have an inseparable, deep relationship with startups, and their funds generally come with deadlines. VCs raise money from partners and funnel it into investments. When raising funds you’ll see terms like “Fund No. X,” and each of these always has a redemption deadline — the point at which the fund is dissolved and the money returned to everyone. So it’s a basic premise that VCs have to produce results by that deadline (there are plenty of exceptions, but I won’t go into them here since it would be redundant).
When investing in a startup, VCs have to decide where to invest while keeping an eye on that deadline. In other words, a constraint naturally emerges: a startup likely to produce results within the redemption deadline is one planning to compete speedily.
Of course, there are all kinds of VCs out there forming funds with all kinds of redemption deadlines, so startups just need to pick ones that seem like a good match for them. But naturally, the more short-term the plan to compete, the higher the odds of a favorable reception, and everyone knows this. It’s as simple as that.
I’m often asked, “Is it true that startups have to exit in 2 or 3 years?” The reasons behind it are exactly as I’ve described above.
As I’ve laid out above, I personally don’t think speed is fundamentally a MUST requirement for startups. That said, I do think it’s a problem that various environmental factors have narrowed the range of options to roughly this degree.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please consider purchasing it.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1242/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.