A Founder's Company Stops Being His Own Sooner Than He Thinks
There seem to be several ways to think about the answer to this question.
① When you step down as CEO ② When your shareholding falls below the one-third veto threshold ③ When your shareholding falls below a majority ④ When your shareholding falls below two-thirds (absolute control)
These are probably the candidates that come to mind. Technically, once you drop below ④, you can no longer have things entirely your own way — a third party could exercise a veto on major decisions — so in that sense things get more complicated. You now have to think, to some degree, about reaching agreement with shareholders as a whole, and your control is no longer absolute in substance. You could say that at that point “you’re no longer fully in control.”
As far as I know, though, few startup founders lose sleep over that two-thirds line. And it isn’t because of the technical point that “with a majority you can still exercise effective control, including appointing directors” — in fact, most people don’t seem to worry much about the veto threshold either. For someone who has grown a business mainly through equity funding, raising money properly and growing the business properly matters far more than the fine details of shareholding ratios. As long as he can do that, he remains CEO. That view is, broadly speaking, correct. So I think many people regard ① as the moment the company stops being “their” company.
But this, too, is only one facet of being a founder. Let me add some other ways of thinking about it, some other options.
⑤ When you take your first equity investment ⑥ When a stakeholder other than yourself joins
My own thinking leans more toward ⑤ or ⑥. Go back to that employee’s pointed outburst (laughs) at the start. The person making that remark might be a rank-and-file employee holding no actual shares at all. Not a director, not an officer — possibly even a junior-level engineer.
But he is a stakeholder. In the sense of sharing the same fate.
The idea that “he’s just an employee, after all” is a dangerous one. What I said about the contrast between “the angel investor who gets too deeply involved in the business” and the founder holds true here too, in a different form. A company and its employees stand in a contractual relationship, an employment contract. Under it, the company provides money and benefits in exchange for the employee’s time and effort. Put simply, both sides bring money and time to the table and exchange them.
Now, what are money and time, for each side? In this case, in fact, for both of them, what they put in must come from only a small portion of what they have. What else could you call that but a shared fate? It’s a thoroughly fair relationship. Both sides came together because they saw possibility in the business, a chance to grow it and share in the harvest together.
So — whose company is it, anyway?
The content of this post is drawn (in its original wording) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1235/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.