Startups don't need a grand vision, but one helps
That’s not always true, but I hope it will be. Here are the reasons why.
First, there has never been a moment in human history when an industry stayed fixed in place.
No matter the era, if you look at it on a hundred-year scale, no industry has ever been stable. Old things always get crushed by new attempts and new ideas, and that is how humanity has grown. Even before the word “startup” existed, humanity had already been repeating the startup cycle over and over. So if you aspire to start a company, I think it would be wonderful if you added one more page to that story. That’s always what I think whenever I take it on myself.
So concretely, what is the key point of a “developmental vision”? My personal view is that being developmental does not necessarily mean having a long-term plan. It is better captured by the phrase “functioning as a kind of reference.” You might call it “inventing a form.” A startup brings some new perspective or new ingenuity into the market (sometimes called innovation), and the application of that becomes, within the company, a “long-term milestone,” while for other people it becomes a “reference as a new foundation.” It lives on inside the company, and inside other people, and then inside the people who see that in turn — propagating outward that way. I think that process itself is what deserves to be called “developmental.” In other words, “Don’t aim to scrape together a little money with some fiddly, slightly-modified business model — paint a big vision!” is easier to understand if you read it as: bring to market a new perspective or ingenuity that can become a model for others.
Second, there are a great many things in the world that simply will not move forward unless a startup does them.
Concretely, there are far too many things that are impossible no matter whether you stay at a large company for 10 years, 20 years, or 40 years. This is not at all a matter of superiority or inferiority — I think it should be understood as a division of roles. The world runs on all kinds of infrastructure, and it is mainly large companies that bear the role of supporting it.
One characteristic of a startup is that “no one would be surprised if it collapsed six months from now.” Suppose logistics suddenly stopped. If Amazon deliveries stopped coming, and then mail stopped arriving, and then air freight stopped arriving too, maybe nothing fatal would happen right away, but it is easy to imagine society falling into chaos. This kind of thing (some of it, anyway) is too important to entrust to a startup that might collapse in six months.
But a challenge like switching part of logistics — for a limited time, in a limited region — to, say, unmanned delivery by self-driving vehicles, is something better suited to a startup than to a large company. The reason: all sorts of trouble is bound to happen.
Large companies almost always have some core business separate from any new venture. They take the profits earned there and invest them elsewhere. A first-year loss is fine. A second-year loss is probably fine too. But if the losses continue into the third and fourth year, the position of the person in charge of that project within the company gradually worsens. Depending on circumstances, the person in charge might be replaced. Or the project’s budget might get cut in the fallout from a drop in the core business’s revenue. Project members, too, might request a transfer, judging that it is better for their career and compensation to work on something in the core business where results come easily, rather than stay on a project with no visible exit. I think this is “the ordinary thing” that happens at large companies.
A startup, on the other hand, has no escape route, no options. There is nothing to do but “just do it.” No matter how many years of losses pile up, there is nothing to do but burn through every single day in order to produce a clear result before the invested capital runs out (the term “burn rate” captures it well). Which one is more likely to produce results — I think that is obvious.
Finally, I would point to the fact that a startup is a thing in which the gap between risk and reward is stretched open to its absolute limit. There might be nothing left in two or three months, but in two or three years it might have turned all of society upside down. To draw employees, collaborators, and customers into a company like that, a big developmental vision is indispensable.
Everyone knows how low the success rate of startups is. But even so, the reason a certain number of people still join startups is, I think, never “because running the numbers showed a high probability of winning.” It is because they saw there “a dream worth betting on.” A developmental vision, in most cases, gives off a charm that draws people in.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1223/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.