Labeling coworkers as 'the people in XX' signals a refusal to think
There is an organizational risk I pay very close attention to when I work with a company as an advisor or consultant.
It’s whether people use the phrase “the people in XX” to refer to members of a different department or office within the same company.
“The sales people,” “the development people,” “the people on the first floor,” “the people at the XX office.”
These phrases are the typical starting point of labeling. Labeling is very useful for simplifying things through abstraction, but inside a company, it’s a warning sign. In most cases it comes from an escapist psychology, a refusal to think.
There are situations where you have no choice but to talk about things macroscopically as a whole, or where doing so is appropriate. Marketing is the clearest example. “Housewives in their 40s,” “affluent households,” “elderly people living alone in the greater Tokyo area” — without dividing things into clusters like this and labeling them, conversation becomes nearly impossible. Inside a company, though, the opposite should be true.
In any project, if proper management is functioning, it’s rare for things to grow to a scale where “it’s unclear who’s even involved.” Before that happens, the project gets properly divided, resources get reviewed, and milestones get reset. So in a healthy project, everyone involved should be “within view.” Not in the sense of being physically visible, but in the sense that each member is close enough that you could find out, if you wanted to, what role they have, what they’re thinking, and what they’re doing.
Labeling is a snap judgment. Everyone knows it’s not appropriate, especially when applied to a large group. “Japanese people are polite.” “People over 50 are stubborn.” “People who came up through sports clubs are strict about hierarchy.” Objections like “That may be true in general, but I’m different” are everywhere.
At the same time, labeling has a psychological effect of guiding people. It works exactly like hearing the result of a fortune-telling and thinking, “Maybe that’s true.” So the basic rule is to use it positively. “We can do this.” “We’re made up of a rare group of excellent people.” “You all always do such careful research, it’s wonderful.” These carry an implicit instruction: go ahead and believe you can do it, be excellent, do thorough research. It’s not magic, so it has to be repeated, but labeling of this kind can work effectively for an organization.
Used the other way, it does the opposite. “The development people make a face whenever you ask them for something.” “Sales is always out of the office and has no idea what’s happening internally.” “The people on the first floor have no motivation.” “The people at the Osaka branch provide low-quality customer support.” Statements like these only invite resentment (“I’m different”) and lead to nothing positive. Labeling is also an expression of a psychological urge to keep one’s distance. By abstracting people, it lets you flee from the effort of thinking deeply about them, of listening to them. Whether the words that follow turn out to be positive or negative is something you can tell without even having to think about it.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1181/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.