China's wireless certification demands more time and money, but that is no reason to skip it
This may be unfamiliar territory for those who have never been involved in a product release, but it’s a story told often enough in the industry.
What should and shouldn’t be released naturally differs by product, so nothing can be said categorically here. What follows is simply my take on why people say such things.
I first noticed a certain unease while researching country-by-country certifications for a product release, more than ten years ago. There’s a convenient certification method for wireless products called “module certification.” Of the two categories mentioned earlier, intentional radiation and unintentional radiation, the intentional radiation portion can be certified at the module level, and as long as the same module is used, re-certification isn’t required. Many countries, including Japan, use this scheme. Wireless certification requires putting the wireless device into several special states, for example radiating only at a specific frequency at a specific power, or applying a specific modulation, and taking measurements. Most engineers at finished-product manufacturers don’t know how to do this.
Module manufacturers do, however, so when a module manufacturer obtains module certification in advance, it saves the finished-product manufacturer enormously. It shortens certification time and cuts costs for wireless products. It’s a measure designed to stimulate the market. China has no such mechanism, so any manufacturer there must run wireless testing on the finished product itself. That’s one hurdle. I remember naturally prioritizing countries where module certification was possible.
There’s also the matter of certification standards. Many countries reference standards organized under the IEC. Some countries, though, find it hard to reference these and instead build their own national standards. In those cases, it’s common to see a “CE marking is enough” approach. This doesn’t mean “if it has the CE mark, you can sell it here.” It means “hand over all the documentation behind your CE certification, and then you can put our country’s certification mark on it.” That’s a bit of a hassle, but ending the process with a document review is still, in its own way, a great help to manufacturers, since it cuts the man-hours needed for certification. Countries like Japan, the US, and South Korea are different: confident in their own technical capabilities, with the resources to run their own certification bodies, and motivated to protect their domestic manufacturing industries, they build their own standards instead. China belongs in this group too.
Starting from Japan, I prioritized North America and Europe, the major markets at the time, then moved on to countries in Asia, Oceania, South America, and elsewhere where CE results could be reused, and eventually arrived at China. A real sense of unease set in partway through the China application, when I was asked to “provide all drawings and software.” In other countries, you’re sometimes asked to explain the parts related to wireless functionality, and the custom there was to provide the schematic or block diagram of the analog front-end portion, the circuit that actually transmits radio waves. Being asked for all schematics and software was a different matter: it meant, quite simply, that someone could build a copy from that information. On top of that, the certification process was said to take four months at the time. (It’s a bit shorter now.)
Even today, it’s far from rare to see a product launched simultaneously worldwide carry a note saying “Note: sales in China TBD.” The company that once displayed this most blatantly was Apple, with its iPhone series. Certification taking time and effort is one reason, of course, but I imagine the bigger concern was design information leaking out.
That said, looking at the tense US-China relations of recent years, I understand there was another side to it: China, too, had to become sensitive about selling other countries’ products domestically, particularly in communications equipment, to avoid leaks of its own confidential information.
China remains a promising market. But for the past 20 years it has also remained a market that’s hard to enter, because of political complexity. I recently learned, to my renewed shock, that releasing an LTE product in China requires registering as a telecommunications carrier, which alone costs tens of thousands of dollars. (There’s always something.)
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please consider purchasing it.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/10/1109/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.