Changing someone's opinion is impossible through persuasion alone
This is the kind of consultation I often receive, though it takes various forms.
If the question were something like “is A or B technically better,” you could just debate the merits of each option to the end, and no one would actually be stuck. Even if someone were stuck, it would be more like a minor complaint. That’s not the case I’m dealing with here.
The question is: “Is it possible to change something like a person’s personal convictions?”
Suppose, for example, you have a subordinate who is a technically outstanding engineer. His skills are solid, but he’s the type who pushes himself extremely hard, and his slow progress is affecting the tasks of other team members. Suppose you point this out, and the exchange goes like this.
“I’d like you to cut some corners here and there and speed up your output.” “I just want to do my job properly. What happens if a mistake occurs because I cut corners like that? And even if my speed is slower than expected, wasn’t that already clear from past development before you assigned me the task? Isn’t that a management problem?”
This is a tough one.
Put simply, I believe it’s impossible to change someone’s opinion through persuasion. Especially for things like “concerns about the future” or “matters nobody knows the right answer to,” as in the example above, how a person thinks about them varies from person to person. If he has his own history behind him and has built a certain philosophy from it, there’s no way to overturn that.
So if trouble is occurring, then just as he says, it’s “a management problem.”
So just accept it calmly and move on. That’s what I’d say first, but there’s something I should add here. It is possible to guide someone from a medium- to long-term perspective.
Most people build their policies through experience. Incidentally, I’ve made it a rule not to engage in activities requiring creativity for more than six hours a day. The scope of what counts as “activities requiring creativity” is fairly broad, and includes most “non-administrative activities” such as design, debugging, and planning new business ventures. Back in my twenties, when I relied on physical stamina and worked overtime constantly, I made a major mistake, and everything I had thought was “for the best” backfired as a result.
I’m embarrassed to admit that at the time I felt something like “I’m working so hard overtime I could die, how cool am I.” But the results were so terrible that I reconsidered my thinking afterward. Now, if my productivity drops even a little, I take a break. If ideas stop coming, I play with my kids. I don’t work on holidays. I learned that this approach raises creativity overall, and as a rough guideline, I’ve come to settle on “roughly six hours” in my own way.
As in my own case, what triggers a major change in a person’s opinion is, in most cases, failure.
To begin with, opinions and convictions are born out of introspection. They come from reflection. Very few people reflect or reconsider, and change their thinking as a result, when nothing has gone wrong. Even without a clear failure, sometimes a small stumble, anxiety, inconsistency, or disappointment can also serve as a trigger for introspection. In any case, one thing is clear: you cannot skip over that trigger.
If you’re in a management position, for example, keep stating the behavior and mentality you expect. Say it persistently, even to the point of annoyance. But that alone won’t change other people’s behavior. They change because of triggers that are their own. In most cases, all you can do is wait.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/523/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.