Chase value, not market size
Do as you like.
That’s because there are two ways to look at this.
First, nobody knows whether a market everyone currently considers big enough will still be big ten years from now. Second, I think it’s better to think in terms of value rather than money.
The first point is an overwhelming fact. Nobody knows what lies ahead. Take AI or autonomous driving, which became commonplace almost overnight. Ten years ago might have been one thing, but how many people were seriously committing to these fields twenty years ago? Probably nobody but a handful of specialists paid them any attention. The people who kept pursuing these areas undeterred back then are now reaping what’s called the first-mover advantage.
Now think back to before Windows appeared. Nobody thought word processors would disappear. In fact, sales of dedicated word processors peaked in 1990 and were completely wiped out within about ten years. (Sharp, the last holdout, ended production in 2002.) Nobody can accurately predict the future, and it’s awfully naive to project the future based on the present.
Now for the second point. This one is extremely important. Market size matters. Without earning money, you can’t support employees, expand your office, or fund new research and development. Still, deciding whether to enter a market based on its size alone is far too simplistic, and it misses something very important.
That something is value.
Say you wake up, flip on the morning news, tap around at FX trading for an hour, and make $8. Can you really claim with pride that this generated any value for the world? Now say instead you eat breakfast, brush your teeth, get dressed, head to a part-time job, and work an hour at a convenience store earning $8 an hour. In that case, you can clearly say you generated value for the world.
You can generate value for the world either by spending money or by earning it. Money is just a tool for that purpose. What you should really be after is value — some form of contribution you give to others.
Because of my career, I know the musical instrument market reasonably well. The market isn’t especially large, and it’s hard to imagine a huge company making a fresh entry into it. Still, it’s large enough to support tens of thousands of employees on a consolidated basis. It’s a stable market that doesn’t swing sharply up or down — not a very exciting one. If I were an investor, I wouldn’t put money into it. And yet I’ve repeatedly come away strongly convinced that this is an industry generating a great deal of value.
Yamaha Corporation, where I worked in my first career, had the slogan “Making Waves Together” (「感動をともに創る」, literally “creating emotion together”). An idealistic notion like “emotion” never fills anyone’s stomach, but looking back now, I think it was a good slogan precisely because it kept its eye on value.
I’m not saying you shouldn’t think about the market at all, but I’d recommend spending more of your time thinking about the value you want to give to society.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please consider purchasing it.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/1215/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.