Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Markets, not technology, should drive the business model

I want to focus on just these two contrasting faces here.

First, let me say this up front: there is nothing good about a technology-led approach. Not just technology — any “business model starting from an asset” is bound to fail, or at least run into serious trouble, from the outset. This claim runs counter to a lot of conventional management thinking, so let me explain.

Compare business to hunting: a team works together to catch a deer that flees quickly.

Starting from the market — a mindset of following the situation — lets you weigh the best approach from many angles: where the deer tends to appear, the time of day, whether it moves in a herd, what weapon fits accordingly, whether the terrain favors you, and so on.

Now suppose the first deer gets away. You examine what went wrong and how far things did go well, and based on that you work out your next move. That’s a pivot.

Starting from an asset means the “weapon to finish the kill” is already decided. Say you chose a throwing spear. At first glance it doesn’t look like a bad choice. Your team has a skilled spear-thrower, and the spear has long range.

But you fail with the first deer. The reason: throwing requires a preparatory motion — drawing back, then winding up — and during that motion the deer is bound to notice. Hitting a fleeing deer with a thrown spear is a formidable feat even for a skilled thrower.

So what do you do? Everyone starts offering opinions: “Maybe we should drive it into a cave,” “What about setting up nets and surrounding the area,” “What about laying traps aimed at its legs,” and so on. Then the spear expert says, “Wait a minute. Think properly about how to make the kill with my spear. In other words, how do we stop the deer from moving.” ”…(if we could stop it from moving, we wouldn’t need the spear in particular, would we)” — the mood in the room grows awkward.

A fixed “finishing move” like this can be a great asset depending on the situation, but in most cases it unfortunately becomes nothing more than a shackle.

<Assets come with an expiration date, but you never know when or where peak performance will appear>

Everyone is familiar with “fixed assets.” When you purchase expensive equipment, you register it and depreciate it as an expense each year according to the statutory useful life. Its book value gradually declines until, in the end, it has served its purpose and is disposed of.

Assets rot.

The same is true of technology — some technologies fall out of favor, some become unnecessary, as the times change. So it’s easy for anyone to understand that clinging to past legacies narrows your field of view. But even if you look toward the future rather than the past, deploying a specific technology at precisely the right time and place is extremely difficult. Achieving that balance within a single project is an exceptionally hard thing to do. That’s why many companies separate their pure-research R&D division from their applied-research and product-development divisions.

Technology can become the decisive factor that differentiates you from competitors. For a startup, it can also be an important factor when thinking about an exit plan. But if you compare technology against the market, consider this: the target market rarely changes within a given plan (I won’t say it never changes), whereas the more options you have for which technology to adopt, the greater your chances of winning.

In other words, the correct planning process does not start from the asset — technical capability, patents, brand strength — but first considers the full range of business possibilities starting from the market, and only then adopts the idea for which the asset seems likely to be useful.

Make the effort to push the question of “how do we make this happen” as far back as possible. “Effort” is exactly the right word here.

Inevitably — especially if you’re an engineer — the moment an idea comes up, the means of realizing it and the technologies required come rushing through your head. This can be done, this can’t, this needs new development, that existing technology can be repurposed — and in that fashion things get sorted instantly and a conclusion is reached. But what percentage chance is there that this conclusion is perfectly correct? Are there factors you’ve overlooked? Are there options you discarded without realizing it in the course of thinking?

Bringing a discussion of methods down to the level of the planning idea like this leads, in many cases, to being misled.

The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/1209/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.