Horizontal expansion matters more than going global
Being global isn’t necessarily important, but securing the possibility of horizontal expansion is very important. It’s generally difficult to grow a business properly on the back of a single, one-off offering, no matter what the business is.
Let me clarify one point so there’s no misunderstanding: even a service that looks, from the outside, like a pure one-off is, internally, growing through changes such as expanding its business segments or incorporating and merging with other services. A product with many bottlenecks that would obstruct such a growth strategy will struggle to grow in the mid-to-long term, so you should kill that possibility at the planning stage as much as possible.
That said, I don’t think everything needs to expand globally. Global expansion goes wrong far more often than people expect. There are several reasons, but to summarize them in one phrase: “resource problems originating from cultural differences.”
Don’t underestimate “cultural differences” when you expand overseas. Customers’ everyday lives differ, and business customs differ too.
Take my time developing high-end audio equipment: the structure of houses differs greatly from country to country, to begin with. At the time, we planned and developed products assuming houses with fairly large living rooms, because we had the US in mind as our main market. Would that assumption actually hold in Southeast Asia?
We also ran into a problem that kept occurring only in Russia, and when we investigated, we concluded that the installation location of the device was extreme in one direction or the other — abnormally cold or abnormally hot. Can you imagine what that means? Audio equipment is generally placed at the edge of a room. The area by the window in Russia must be quite cold. So where’s the heating equipment? Right next to a fireplace, or by the window, or sometimes both at once. That was the kind of chaotic environment we were dealing with.
When you run into use cases like that, you need to fundamentally change your approach to quality assurance. The job of properly identifying and absorbing these cultural differences generally falls to local expatriate staff. Local staff can sometimes do it instead, but they often don’t know Japanese “culture,” so expatriates are effective in most cases.
What does it cost to send out an expatriate? Calculate it at $230,000 a year per person, and that figure seems to roughly match the reality at many companies. That’s quite a large amount. You rarely find staff at early-stage startups being paid an annual salary of $230,000.
But sending out expatriates — properly expanding globally — means being prepared for exactly that kind of expense. Many companies try to cut corners here and fail. It’s well known that when Mercari expanded into the US, all of its directors relocated to America. That’s the level of commitment I think they understood was necessary to succeed in overseas markets.
That said, I do think some types of businesses expand globally easily. Here are the conditions:
- Non-verbal
- No regulatory constraints (or a globally common standard)
- Closely tied to daily life (used the same way, in the same places, everywhere)
In short, these conditions boil down to one thing: the intermediate cost (effort) of sorting out needs, explaining the product’s value, and introducing it is extremely low. Products with simple structure and simple use cases seem to meet these conditions reasonably often.
The content of this post is part (the original text) of the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/1206/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.