Speaking first loses the argument
An old friend of mine, S, has a father who is a university professor.
His father once told S, while describing just how fierce power struggles inside a university can get, that “whoever speaks first loses.”
It’s a fairly unusual message, but I can see the point to some extent.
I’d put a slightly different spin on it myself: “whoever talks the most loses.”
So why does whoever speaks first lose? The usual back-and-forth of argument has an unavoidable feature: outcomes are decided largely by impression.
As with the peak-end rule mentioned earlier, humans have a sad tendency to let “correctness” be governed not by the logic built up point by point, but by the impression left by the most heated moment and the final summary.
In other words, when winning matters more than anything else, the most important thing is not giving the other side an opening to pounce on, and the way to do that is to get the other person talking first.
Then, by criticizing what they say and pointing out contradictions, you gain the upper hand in the overall flow of the discussion (creating the peak), and after that you push through your own claims and proposals (creating the end). That’s presumably the standard playbook.
Coming back to the actual subject of this post, in-house meetings, things probably aren’t always so blatantly about positioning.
If that’s so, what’s actually needed is to stop positioning battles from arising in the first place and steer the discussion toward being fair.
I think every team has members who are good at discussion and members who aren’t.
Members who are very good at discussion sometimes deploy their own arrangements of the techniques above, whether intentionally or not. They steer the discourse. You could call it controlling the mood of the room.
Reading the room is a kind of felt-presence grasp rooted in emotional projection. In other words, it treats something that isn’t there as if it is, and tries to grasp it. You cannot entrust the running of a company or the progress of a project to something that vague.
So what needs to be done is to cut that off.
If a mood threatens to sweep people along, or if someone is trying to create one, cut it off. If a conclusion is about to run ahead without sufficient discussion, throw in a precise, essential question. If someone’s mistake creates a mood in which all the logic nearly unrelated to that mistake is about to be dismissed along with it, pick out the points that can still be fairly evaluated and put them back on the table. If a short-sighted decision is about to be made out of anger or impatience, ease the mood and create room to take some time.
I imagine this sounds like a very high bar to clear.
To pull this off, you need to listen to everyone’s opinions, separate solid facts from mere impressions, and observe and organize things precisely enough to find the holes.
You can’t do this while also talking a lot yourself. So whoever talks the most loses.
Steamrolling through by talking fast and hard might succeed in controlling the room in the moment, but doubts remain: was that judgment actually sound in the end? Didn’t it just steer things toward whatever was convenient for you? Didn’t it shut the mouths of people who had better opinions? Gaining the upper hand in a discussion feels good, and having your own opinion win out is satisfying. But at the end of a pile of actions carrying that kind of distortion, there is no final victory.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please consider getting the book.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/1172/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.