Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Merchants and Gatekeepers Chase Different Missions and Clash

This is a consultation I often get from members rather than from executives or leaders. I also often hear leaders venting, having vaguely sensed friction and frustration among their members without being able to sort out what’s going on.

So what do I mean by “mission misalignment”?

Let’s work through it with an analogy: “the gatekeeper and the merchant.” (This one is my own.)

There was a country called N, surrounded by walls. Trade was strictly restricted, and the whole country had only one gate; you could not leave or enter N except through it. Free trade outside the country was banned, and all transactions had to take place at the state exchange under government supervision.

The merchants had received instructions from the Minister of Finance: “Next spring we will go to war with Country B. So procure twice as much iron and gunpowder as last year. However, we’ve only secured a budget of 1.5 times, so work to negotiate cheaper deals.”

Meanwhile the gatekeepers had received instructions from the battalion commander: “We are currently in a state of tension with Country B, and Country B is allied with Country C. We have intelligence that they may send in spies, so entry and exit from those two countries especially must be tightly restricted. Also, every year there’s a steady stream of illegal entrants from Country D. After entering, they sometimes form criminal organizations within our borders, and the Minister of Defense and the Minister of Foreign Affairs have issued a strict order that the roughly 100 illegal entrants we see from Country D each year must be brought down to zero this year without fail.”

The merchants traveled around to other countries and did their research, and found that they could procure double the quantity at 1.6 times the budget from Country D, or at about 1.8 times from Country E. But it turned out that Country C could supply double the usual quantity at a much cheaper cost, about 1.3 times. The merchants were eager to trade with Country C and requested that a large delegation be dispatched from Country C.

When the Country C delegation arrived, the gatekeepers were alarmed.

The delegation agreed to limit the number of people entering and to partial disarmament, but refused full disarmament, saying it was needed “for minimal self-defense.” They argued that it was simply unreasonable to ask them to come unarmed into N, a country with poor relations with B, their ally.

The gatekeepers consulted the battalion commander about what to do, but the commander and everyone above him held firm: “If they won’t agree to full disarmament, absolutely do not let the people from Country C enter.”

Meanwhile, the merchants noticed the delegation’s arrival was behind schedule, and when they came to the gate, they found the gatekeepers in the middle of some sort of dispute.

“Why can’t the delegation enter?” “Because they won’t agree to disarmament.” “No, this is an emergency, and all they’re doing is trading, so can’t we overlook a few things this time?” “No, no. As you all know, our country N is in a tense standoff with Country B, and Country C is B’s ally. There’s no way such a convenient argument would hold up. Why Country C, of all countries, at a time like this anyway?” “For such and such reasons, we absolutely need to trade with Country C.” “In that case, what about Country E? They’re on friendly terms with our country too, and people come and go from Country E almost every day.” “Country E alone won’t meet the target. Then at least let half the delegation enter this time. If we can close half the deal now, we can settle the rest with Country D afterward and hit the target that way.” “Did you just say Country D? You must be joking. Country D is a hotbed of criminal organizations. It’s one of the countries we especially need to crack down on this year. I hear that every organization handling iron and gunpowder — the raw materials for weapons — inside Country D has ties to criminal groups.” “But there’s always been traffic between us and Country D. If that’s the concern, tightening the regulations is fine, but it’s not as if we can’t trade with them at all.” “Well, that’s true enough. Fine, Country D it is. Drop Country C and settle the deal with Country D instead. Given the numbers from before, it looks like it’ll go a bit over budget, but you’ll need to sort that out with the Minister of Finance.” “What are you talking about? Don’t you know how strict the Minister is? He won’t compromise one bit. If we fail to meet this mission, we’re certainly getting demoted. Just let the Country C delegation in already!” “If you have a mission, we have one too. Entry from Countries B and C especially needs to be tightly restricted. Carrying weapons is out of the question. If anything goes wrong, it won’t just cost us our heads — it’ll become a huge problem!” “Enough. If you have a complaint, take it up with the Minister of Finance. We’re just following orders and carrying out our mission!” “We’re acting on the policy handed down from the Minister of Defense and the Minister of Foreign Affairs too. If you have a complaint, take it up the chain!”

The two sides’ missions are at odds, and they’re going in circles. Now, how should a situation like this be resolved?

To the executives and leaders who’ve read this far — I’m sorry, but this isn’t actually a moment for you to step in.

This is a moment that calls for “horizontal coordination.”

Here, the missions given to both sides are both tied to a shared goal — in this case, “the prosperity of our own country.” Maintaining domestic security matters, and so does withstanding invasion by other countries and, at times, expanding one’s colonies for the sake of prosperity. Each leader has set an appropriate mission for their own area of expertise toward that end. So even when a clash like the one in this example arises, adjusting the mission itself is not desirable. Do that too readily, and the mission itself — and eventually the goal itself — gets hollowed out.

Ideal horizontal coordination produces not “compromise” between the two sides but “conviction.” Let’s explore a few cooperative solutions for this case.

What if neutral Country E were to escort the Country C delegation? Country E is a neutral country and also an important trading partner for N. If N promises Country E, “We will not harm the Country C delegation,” and lets them in under that condition, then anything that happens in front of Country E’s escort would cost N Country E’s trust. The Country C delegation might well be satisfied with that arrangement.

Naturally something would need to be given to Country E in return, but that could be covered from what’s left of the budget after procuring the goods cheaply. From the gatekeepers’ perspective too, relations with Country E are extremely friendly, and the rules around both sides carrying weapons are clearly established through things like joint military exercises, so the arrangement can be judged extremely safe.

Country D has strong negotiating leverage backed by its military power. It also has diplomatic relations with Country C, and if Country D steps in, it could pull off buying double the quantity for just 1.2 times the usual budget. On top of that, if N buys it from Country D at 1.5 times the price, Country D skims a large margin at zero risk. There is almost no chance Country D would pass up this deal. People from Country D also tend to be shrewd about business and, perhaps because of confidence in their military strength, individually tend to be relatively unguarded. They would likely have no qualms entering N even under the condition of a small group and full disarmament. That would let the gatekeepers keep the risk to a minimum.

As you can see, a bit of ingenuity brings many solutions to light. And all of this “without breaking the mission” and “without specifically needing the approval or judgment of superiors.” Building an organization that can actively devise and solve this kind of friction on its own, and the people who make up such an organization — that is exactly what executives and leaders should be focused on.

The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/1166/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.