A finished prototype does not guarantee a quick factory order
I have worked at both companies with their own fab and at fabless companies. In most cases, startups drift toward being fabless. Owning a factory carries not just initial costs but extremely large fixed costs that continue indefinitely. Even so, many large companies continue to maintain their own fabs. I think there are reasons for this beyond cost and supply chain optimization.
That reason is the unification of mindset from prototyping through to manufacturing.
At most fabless companies, the sequence goes like this: first build a prototype yourselves, confirm it works, run a demo, catch someone’s eye and raise funding or gather money through crowdfunding, and only then does “now, manufacturing” begin.
The problem is that at this stage, no input has been sought from the factory at all.
Depending on the team’s skill set, in the worst case, it is entirely possible that only the essence of the design survives and nearly everything else has to be rebuilt. Many things must be looked after when manufacturing. I cannot claim to have a complete handle on all of them myself, but let me list a few typical ones below.
<Cost Consistency>
A product that is made is meant to be sold, and selling it means putting a price tag on it. That price tag must leave a proper profit margin. The price is not simply arrived at by adding up the cost of parts. Only once various expenses are layered on — procurement work done at the factory, creation of necessary jigs, mold fabrication, process management, incoming and outgoing shipment management — can a selling price finally be determined. If none of this is taken into account and the selling price is assumed based on parts bought casually online, a nasty surprise awaits later. In the worst case, it means starting over.
<Assemblability>
If a product has a structurally complex design, the people assembling it at the factory are, typically, ordinary line workers. The worker who assembles your product today may be assembling a completely different product tomorrow. They have not studied the structure of your product in advance, and they know nothing beyond what is written in the instruction sheet. Is the structure such that even someone like that can assemble it efficiently enough? In most cases, some degree of rework ends up being required.
<Inspection>
Regardless of how many units of a product are being made, outsourcing manufacturing to someone requires establishing shipping criteria. Without that, defective units cannot be detected. Establishing shipping criteria means establishing inspection. Some inspections are carried out with instruments, others visually. When instruments are used, several things must be thought through in advance: the observation method suited to that instrument, the connector shape if the inspection requires an electrical contact point, and the structure or jigs needed to ensure validity if it is a mechanical test. A design that has given no thought to these will, naturally, be sent back for rework.
Coming back to the opening question, the issue runs up against whether the considerations above (or more) have actually been made at the prototype stage. In most cases, the answer is no. There is no need to be pessimistic about that. So what should be done? The attitude of companies with their own fab is worth emulating. At companies with their own fab, factory members are usually brought into planning meetings from the earliest stage. Since nothing becomes a product unless the factory manufactures it, this is, when you think about it, entirely natural. In this way, mutual constraints and requirements are clarified from the start, and the prototype is developed through a process of mutual adjustment. For a fabless company, this inevitably means needing a manufacturing partner willing to engage in tight conversation from the early stages, but I think demanding that of, say, a newly launched startup sets the bar rather high.
So keep two things in mind: first, factor into the budget and schedule the expectation that various change requests will come in once conversation with the manufacturing factory begins; second, bear in mind that the risk grows the longer it takes to settle on a manufacturing factory, and adjust the priorities of the whole project accordingly.
Since the above was written in somewhat general terms, let me offer two brute-force solutions below.
- Bring onto the team someone thoroughly experienced in manufacturing
- Once you’ve done a proof-of-principle prototype, leave the rest to the factory
For 1, even if not as a full-time employee, you can bring such a person onto the team in various forms — as an outsourced contractor, a consultant, an advisor. As for 2, I honestly don’t recommend it, but many startups and small to medium-sized businesses adopt this method. The reason I don’t recommend it is that depending excessively on another company keeps the assets from ever becoming your own.
The content of this post is part (the original text) of the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy of the book.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/09/1137/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.