CCS Can Push Carbon Positive Plants Toward Neutral Or Negative
Continuing from the previous post
This is the next installment in a series summarizing what I learned from “CCSx: Climate Change: Carbon Capture and Storage,” an online class offered by the University of Edinburgh on edX. These are mostly notes for myself, but I’d be glad if they help someone else too.
Where CCS is headed
In manufacturing: concrete and steel. And energy. Decarbonization that relies only on renewables and nuclear will clearly exhaust the carbon budget within our generation. Restricting energy use itself is, arguably, not ethically acceptable.
Carbon Negative / Carbon Neutral / Carbon Positive
Carbon Negative covers things like BECCS and DAC.
People usually associate Carbon Neutral with hydrogen or with facilities that run on heat from fossil fuels, but these aren’t truly neutral — generating the primary energy itself releases emissions into the atmosphere.
CCS can push these “almost-but-not-quite neutral” sources closer to neutral or even negative, and applying CCS to Carbon Positive facilities — oil, coal, natural gas plants — can contribute enormously to CO2 reduction.
The four stages a technology passes through before acceptance
- Dismissed as impossible science fiction
- Seen as expensive, complicated, and nearly impossible
- Seen as requiring major investment but necessary
- Becomes part of everyday life
Power generation has passed through these four stages and arrived at stage 4. Sulfur, which causes acid rain, is another example: recognized as a problem in the 1970s and 1980s, it was addressed over the following 20–30 years through advances in desulfurization technology at thermal power plants. The cost has since fallen to under one-fifth of what was projected around 1990, and it’s still falling.
So where does CCS stand right now?
Cement
Discovered in Britain in the 19th century. Producing one ton of cement emits 800kg of CO2. Global production runs at 4 billion tons per year, and cement production alone accounts for one-fifth of all CO2 emissions.
Manufacturers make cement by crushing and mixing limestone (calcium carbonate), silicon, aluminum, iron, and other materials, then heating the mixture to 1400°C. Here the reaction CaCO3 -> CaO + CO2 takes place.
The IEA estimates that CCS will need to be fitted to 30% of cement production facilities by 2050.
Steel
Steel production emits 1.5 to 3 tons of CO2 per ton produced. Producers turn out 1.5 billion tons worldwide, accounting for roughly one-sixth of all CO2 emissions.
Blast furnaces exceeding 2000°C are where iron ore reacts with coal in a specific state, and two-thirds of the sector’s emissions come from there.
Scrap steel recycling and similar measures are cutting total emissions, but no one has found an alternative to coking coal, and no silver bullet exists that can deliver the 80%-plus emissions cut this category needs. This is an area where CCS is essential.
Fertilizer production
The chemical fertilizer market is global in scale and enormous. Fossil fuels will likely remain in use here, and CCS can be readily introduced in this area as well.
Sankey Diagram

This is a typical way of representing energy balances.
Direct Emissions refers to things like direct emissions from cars. Indirect Emissions refers to indirect emissions from things like electricity use. Coal is used heavily in power generation, and that flow feeds back into construction, among other sectors. Stopping these individual flows would reduce CO2 emissions.
Here’s how it changes once renewable energy enters the picture:

Here’s how it changes once hydrogen energy becomes common:

Here’s how it changes once CCS enters the picture too:

And here’s the big change once CCS enters heavy industry:

Hydrogen energy
Hydrogen makes up 50% of city gas. It’s actually already a familiar energy source. At present, producers make most of it from natural gas, a process that releases methane (CH4) and ultimately CO2. This is an area that’s a very good match for CCS.
The UK is actively building out pipe network infrastructure to supply hydrogen, and the cost outlook looks good too.
A case study video from Leeds:
Northern Gas Networks H21 Leeds City Gate film
Blue Hydrogen and Green Hydrogen
Hydrogen produced via CCS is called Blue, and hydrogen produced via electrolysis is called Green. For Blue Hydrogen to reach Net Zero overall, reducing methane leakage in the upstream process is a major challenge.
A 100% renewable energy society
Some people aim for all electricity to come from renewable energy. But this may not be efficient at all.
Wind and solar are the main players in renewable energy, but neither can generate power on demand to begin with. That’s why current proposals call for simply oversizing wind power capacity as much as possible. There’s also a line of thinking that goes “the wind is blowing (or the sun is shining) somewhere on Earth,” leading to proposals for cross-border transmission grids. But given how low the utilization rate of this infrastructure would be, it’s quite likely not cost-effective.
The problem of power storage also has no clear prospect of being solved. For instance, weather scenarios considered plausible within the next decade include high-pressure systems that bring weeks of cold, windless conditions worldwide. In other words, anyone serious about pursuing a “100% renewable energy society” would need a power storage system capable of withstanding weeks with almost no wind or solar power at all. Frankly, at this point that’s an extremely unrealistic prospect.
So options like nuclear power, low-carbon-emission thermal power, and BECCS will definitely be necessary. The IPCC estimates that without CCS, the cost of hitting the 2°C target would rise by 50–200%.
On the cost of 100% renewable energy:
Power generation
Power generation accounts for 13Gt of emissions per year, 40% of all CO2 emissions — more than double the transportation sector’s share (2014 data).
Countries with access to cheap natural gas can achieve a one-time emissions reduction by shifting to it, but that alone won’t reach neutrality.
More than 50% of renewable energy comes from wind and solar, but because they can’t operate on demand, older thermal power plants can’t be closed. The solution is to convert them to low-carbon thermal power plants using CCS.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/926/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.