Fake angel investors obsess over equity percentages
There are many definitions of angel investors, but here I’ll try to define the true angel investor by approaching it from the angle of “don’t partner with these fake angel investors.”
Don’t partner with these fake (pseudo) angel investors!
① They obsess over equity percentages
Most angel investors have already cleared one lap of life’s board game. They earned a large capital gain from their own business or a startup they were involved with, or they served for many years as executives at a major company before stepping down.
The foundation of angel investing is that, alongside pursuing their own new challenges, these people invest to support the potential and bold attempts of young people. So most of them aren’t desperate, and they don’t fuss over small differences in amounts — they already have more than enough.
If they do complain about the equity ratio, it can only be in the context of “arguing to protect the founder.” That might mean flagging that a particular VC has been given too high a stake, or conversely warning that keeping the founder’s ratio too high has pushed the valuation too far up, creating a risk that future fundraising becomes difficult.
If an angel starts going on about equity for any other reason, they’re a devil wearing an angel’s skin. In general (as far as I know), even an angel investor who put in a few thousand dollars at founding typically ends up holding only a single-digit percentage, and the low end of that, once things have been diluted through Series A and beyond.
Occasionally you look at a prospectus at a startup’s IPO and see some early investor holding a huge stake and think “who is this?” It’s genuinely unpleasant.
② Traces of a “this is my business” attitude show through
It’s a very good thing when an angel investor brings passion to the business they’ve invested in, but unless they hold their position firmly as a “supporter,” they risk becoming an obstacle to running the business in all sorts of ways. Advice and tough love are fine, but once it reaches the point of “just do what I say,” that’s a serious problem.
Money isn’t that big a deal, especially for someone who already has it. Far more serious, and far more deserving of real consideration, is the fact that someone with almost nothing else is devoting 100% of the one thing they do have — their time, their mind, their passion. The respect should flow toward you, the founders.
③ They only have money
An important role for angel investors is “connecting startups to society.”
There are no small number of cases where founders and their early team members lack points of contact with society. Maybe it’s a student venture, or maybe even working adults whose experience is concentrated in a fairly narrow field. They have no connections to VCs, no connections to clients, no connections to development partners, nothing at all. In that situation, one of the supporters who can function as an “experienced mentor figure” is the angel investor.
Someone who merely holds assets inherited as a family business, or who just happened to grab hold of a windfall through stocks or crypto (these days maybe through YouTube too), may well lack the grounding to serve as that kind of “elder brother figure from the business world.” I can’t deny that possibility.
Fortunately, in Japan there simply aren’t that many “angel investors” to begin with, so it’s rare to run into someone you’d think “this guy is awful” about. Still, some people have ended up landing on that rare case, so everyone, please be careful.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1238/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.