Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Gut Feeling Alone Should Not Decide When To Mass-Produce

Instinct, gut feeling, and decisiveness. That’s what I’d like to say, but let me put down something a bit more theoretical as well.

There’s generally no technical standard for how far along something needs to be before manufacturing is allowed, so this inevitably becomes a judgment call at the management level. For most startups, I suspect, a single failed attempt at mass production drains the funding right there. So this is a truly “life or death” decision.

Some people fall into unfavorable modes of thinking when facing this decision. Let me walk through a few typical examples.

“Because it’s already set in the original schedule”

This is the height of folly. You could even say no judgment has been made at all. A schedule should, to begin with, include milestones that serve as checkpoints for “making a judgment.”

“Because it’s working fine for now”

This kind of thinking tends to show up at the level of development team members. But as I mentioned, this decision belongs to management. The fact that things are working fine only proves that development is on schedule; it’s not enough reason either to push the schedule forward or to stop it.

“If we don’t move to mass production now, we’ll run out of money”

It’s not uncommon to feel that you’ve already sunk a certain amount of budget into development, that money is set aside for mass production, and that this is the last possible moment. Honestly, I find it hard to blame someone who decides to push forward under these circumstances. I can also imagine the regret, for developers and everyone else involved, in cases where a company kept telling itself “just one more step, just one more step” and went bankrupt without ever releasing the product. But if I may say so, rather than taking an all-or-nothing gamble driven by financial circumstances, you should take an all-or-nothing gamble aimed at overturning those financial circumstances. Concretely, that could mean sharpening your differentiation from other companies, expanding the target market, or lining up new potential partners. A company’s appeal can always be expanded, and in most cases that costs less money than going into mass production. That said, this kind of decision can look like a betrayal of existing shareholders’ expectations, so proper internal controls matter here.

Now, on the other hand, here’s how I believe the decision to proceed to mass production should work.

The moment you think, “This should be put to the market,” is the moment to take the plunge.

“Proceeding because you’re certain of victory” is sophistry. If you could win every single time just by believing you’d win, business would be a dry, flavorless thing. Sometimes you put something into the market and earn a good reputation; sometimes the result is completely unexpected. Sometimes the stone you cast produces ripples from a completely different angle than you imagined. When Yamaha released a product called the “light-up guitar,” for instance, it had a feature that let you play chords with one hand. The idea behind this was the fairly silly notion of being able to play “even while drinking beer with your other hand.” But once the product actually came out, Yamaha apparently received inquiries and high praise from people with one arm.

Similarly, when I was developing a product called “DFree” for elimination care, we built it with elderly people as the main target. But once we released it, I came to feel that the people who gained the most value from it were actually households with relatively young people with disabilities. Putting something on the market requires a quality sufficient for that purpose, and nothing beyond that. Grasping, as a felt sense, where that minimum essential level lies, without falling into the trap of chasing excessive quality, is very difficult.

There is, however, a very simple solution to this. Become a user yourself.

Use it as a user would, and ask yourself honestly whether it feels good or bad. There will be small glitches and inconveniences. Are those within the range a user can tolerate? Has the feel, the texture, the experience you have here reached the point where you want to share it with many people?

Once that passion is born, it’s hard to stop. It should light a fire under you immediately, telling you there’s no choice but to release this.

The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1134/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.