Making It In China Is No Longer A Sure Thing
It’s rare for someone to ask that question to your face, though it does happen, but I can feel that it sits in the back of many people’s minds.
To begin with, China has only held enough influence to be called the world’s factory for roughly the last ten years. In the ten years before that, China was a reasonably priced subcontractor and a destination for large companies’ investment, including equipment. And in the ten years before that, no small number of people were starting to sense that China was still risky, but was clearly changing.
When thinking about a country like China, it often makes more sense to view its activity as a whole from a macro perspective rather than treating it as a single undifferentiated thing. Seen that way, manufacturing in today’s China has largely finished playing its role. China has already achieved sufficient economic prosperity and no longer needs to chase foreign capital so aggressively. Naturally, to keep its existing equipment and companies running at full capacity, China will probably continue acting as the world’s factory going forward too, but that stance will be clearly distinct from the one it took 20 to 30 years ago, when it was hungrily grasping for dominance. Put simply, it means a shift toward high quality and high added value. This has happened before, in one country after another. Before China, it was Vietnam and Malaysia. Before that, Taiwan. And before that, Japan itself occupied that position. History repeats. China will almost certainly follow the same path.
Nearly 20 years ago, a prediction circulated that within a few years, wages at Chinese factories would become indistinguishable from those at other Southeast Asian factories. That prediction turned out to be completely correct. China’s originally cheap labor was built on a finite, predictable cycle: workers from rural areas came in as seasonal migrant labor, and once they had earned enough, they went home and never came back. In other words, it was a strategy exploiting regional disparities between rich and poor, so once that cycle ran its course, it was bound to end. It did not end overnight — wages rose gradually. But everyone understood, including the people involved, that China would gradually and surely stop being a bargain. That, too, is history repeating itself.
Coming back to the question at the start, whether it is “a sure thing” depends on what you are expecting. If you are building an electronic PCB with a BOM that has already been fixed, there is almost no benefit left to manufacturing it in China. On the other hand, if you are making a product with parts whose unit prices fluctuate easily, a Chinese factory with bulk-purchasing power may buy cheaply and manufacture stably. But this has nothing to do with country or region — it is purely a matter of purchasing power. So if you blindly choose a Chinese factory expecting cost, supply stability, and production capacity, you risk getting badly burned.
Looking at it from the angle of quality, I doubt many people living today would say Made in Japan quality is the best. Of course not. Made in China is also excellent. In most areas, Japan’s technological edge disappeared long ago. This closely resembles the 1970s and 80s, when Japan rapidly closed the gap with the American semiconductor industry. This, too, is history repeating itself.
You might then think: why not just go with China for now? But manufacturing overseas, not limited to China, comes with its own particular set of difficulties.
One example is shipping costs and tariffs. Manufacturing follows various patterns. Some products are made once and that’s it; others are made in a fixed quantity every month; still others require flexibly adjusting quantity and delivery timing each time. The more frequent the manufacturing runs, the more shipping effort and cost pile up. International shipping generally takes time, including customs clearance, and if a short delivery deadline forces you to use air freight instead of sea freight, that pushes shipping costs up further. Depending on the item, extremely high tariff rates can also apply. Even if you check this in advance, it can change due to some trigger, so it remains a risk.
Another issue is management. Overseas cultures differ. It would be a serious mistake to think that imposing Japanese customs on everything will simply work. In my experience, this becomes especially apparent in how people act when something comes up that wasn’t specifically instructed. In a Japanese sensibility, if someone discovers an item in their delegated work for which no specific instruction was given, there isn’t much choice in how to act. Nine times out of ten, they ask the client. They stop what they’re doing and inquire about what has come up and what the correct response should be. But overseas, across countries, regions, levels of maturity, a patchwork of differences, the responses are just as much a patchwork. Honestly, you cannot predict how people you are working with for the first time will behave.
So what do you do? The orthodox approach is to station someone on-site. Pre-manufacturing preparation, confirming the setup, checking progress on the production line, pre-shipment inspection — at every stage, you keep at least one member physically present to observe and step in the moment trouble occurs. This kind of on-site presence happens even with domestic manufacturing, of course. But you need to factor in beforehand that doing it overseas raises both the labor and the cost involved. For example, if trouble occurs and you end up needing to send a manufacturing lead, an operations person, one development staffer, and one project lead, four people total, to that overseas factory, that alone can easily wipe out a price difference of $7,600 or $15,200.
As an alternative to stationing someone physically on-site, many large companies use a long-term resident staff member. A resident, by staying in that country for years, comes to deeply understand its customs and builds direct personal connections with people there. Having such a person in place resolves a lot of the anxiety around prior coordination and sudden trouble response. But maintaining a resident involves substantial cost. For a startup that has only just launched, stationing someone there is hardly a realistic option. The remaining viable approach, then, is to hire a local Japanese consultant.
Rather than blindly choosing China, if you properly understand its strengths and weaknesses and keep a few precautions firmly in mind, manufacturing in China can be a thoroughly attractive option.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please consider picking up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1131/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.