Chinese Manufacturing Is Cheap Because Of Local Chips And Shared Designs
There are various opinions at various levels about the trick behind the cheapness of Chinese manufacturing, so what I present below is only the extent of what I personally understand.
One thing that stands out immediately is the use of local Chinese silicon. In my work, I often buy products on the market and take them apart to see what’s inside. When I disassemble Chinese products, the first thing I notice is that there are several ICs mounted on the PCB that I’ve never seen or heard of before.
Since the IC surface has a part marking printed on it, I use that as a clue to search for a datasheet. But every datasheet I can get my hands on is in Chinese only, and even when I can barely make out the general outline, honestly I don’t understand the details. For some parts, I can’t even obtain a datasheet at all. When I manage to understand what little I can read, I realize, “Ah, this IC is the equivalent of such-and-such product from such-and-such company.” Working through the circuit configuration gives me even firmer confidence.
There are various theories about why local silicon is cheap, ranging from the wholesome to the not-so-wholesome, but I think the mildest and most reasonable answers are things like “it’s made using spare fab time or surplus materials originally meant for overseas products,” or “it’s a reproduction of a mature IC, so there’s effectively no asset left that needs to be depreciated,” or “the supply chain is simple and short, so no extra costs get piled on.”
When you hand a schematic or bill of materials designed in Japan to a factory in China, in many cases you get a single line back: “you’re using nothing but expensive parts.” Naturally, designers in Japan (or in the US, Europe, or Southeast Asia) also work hard to find reasonably priced, reliable parts when designing a circuit. If you check prices on widely used global sites like Mouser or Digikey, it’s not at all the case that every part is expensive. But for Chinese designers, the parts handled on those kinds of sites are, to begin with, themselves “expensive parts.”
Next is something you can’t tell by looking at a single product on its own, but which becomes clear once you buy multiple products on the market and take them apart: there is a level of diversion of design assets going on that would be unthinkable in Japan, the US, or Europe. Say, for example, there’s a healthcare band that measures and displays your pulse.
Generally, if you search on Amazon, say, you can get one for around $20. But in China you can get one for a few dollars. I once tried gathering up about 20 such products as a test, and it turned out there were only roughly two or three circuit patterns in total. Same parts, same circuit configuration, and in the worst cases even the same enclosure. All of them were made by diverting design assets.
A few explanations come to mind. Perhaps the manufacturer is actually the same across all of them. Perhaps design data originally created on commission for one client is being improperly diverted. Perhaps the design data itself is circulating behind the scenes. I don’t know which of these is correct, and it’s probably more reasonable to think it’s a case-by-case matter.
Either way, there’s a habit of pumping out products one after another into the world without putting much design resource into them. This naturally affects cost by greatly cutting down the underlying cost base to begin with, and it also contributes significantly to lowering procurement costs through economies of scale by standardizing parts.
On the other hand, this leaves questions on the customer support side and in terms of business longevity. For some products, even though they’re IoT products, it’s not uncommon to see everything simply handed off with a note like “for the app, please use such-and-such from such-and-such company.”
A very positive point is that when you work with Chinese engineers, you notice that they’re all young and talented. Outside a few major cities, the general cost of living in China is lower than in Japan, but even so, a lavish meal in central Shenzhen, for example, ends up costing just as much as in Japan, if not more.
Even in that kind of environment, young, ambitious people feel far more motivated by turning out a hit product and growing a business than by making a quick profit and drawing a high salary. That’s no different in Japan or in other countries. So they work themselves to the bone while earning barely enough to live on.
It seems to me that the fact that young people like this in China are actively involved in manufacturing contributes enormously to keeping the entire industry cost-reasonable.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please go ahead and get the book.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1128/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.