Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Molds are manufacturing's biggest cost risk

It’s true. Molds are the biggest risk factor in manufacturing, straining both schedules and wallets.

For example, making something as simple as a box with an upper and lower half can, depending on the case, cost tens of thousands of dollars. If the structure is complex, or it requires multicolor molding with multiple materials, or there are tight precision constraints, the cost rises further, and cases running over $76,000 are far from rare. For large resin parts like an automobile’s front panel (interior trim), the mold can reportedly cost upwards of $380,000.

A large upfront cost makes pricing a headache. Amortize a $76,000 mold over 10,000 units and you add $7.60 per unit. Amortize it over 1 million units and it’s just $0.08. Depending on how you look at this, the selling price can swing by thousands of yen.

It would have been nice to offer some trick like “do this and cut your mold cost to a tenth!” but unfortunately no such convenient method exists. Instead, here are a few basic cost-reduction techniques.

This means producing multiple parts from a single mold. In some cases, these parts could even belong to a different product. The former reduces the mold cost itself; the latter increases the number of units over which it’s amortized.

Shared tooling, mentioned above, requires certain conditions to align and can’t be applied indiscriminately. A simpler and more effective approach is to reduce the number of parts in the first place. This demands skill on the designer’s part. But fewer parts and a simpler structure also reduce assembly man-hours, which is itself a direct cost reduction.

There are two meanings here. One is to put off making the mold for as long as possible. You need to think seriously about at what stage of prototyping a mold truly becomes necessary. Corrections made after a mold has been cut cost both effort and money. In some cases, they risk forcing a remake from scratch. Starting the mold as late as the schedule allows, and locking in the design so no further changes come after that, is a quietly effective way to prevent cost increases down the line. The other meaning is this: is there an option to make the product without a mold, or with a simplified mold? When production volumes are low, amortizing a mold becomes a real headache. But simply raising the selling price to compensate makes sales shaky instead. In such cases, consider using a simplified mold. “Simplified mold” covers a wide range of things in practice, but essentially it means a mold that skips the processing used to boost durability and maintain precision. As a result, the shot count (the number of times it can keep delivering the required performance) ends up lower. Still, when production volume is low, there’s often room to compromise on this point.

Mold prices are heavily affected by the price of raw materials. Various steels go into molds depending on the target being struck, but essentially the work itself is just cutting and surface-finishing them and assembling the result — demanding work, but a conventional process done for a long time. The raw material, on the other hand, is a large chunk of metal. Availability can be an issue, and availability issues often cause unit prices to spike. Rather than always going back to the same supplier, get several competing quotes each time; that lets you build the mold at the best price available at that moment.

Molds are certainly a major risk factor, and there’s no cheat code for them. But it’s disheartening to see them become the bottleneck that keeps a product from moving forward. Don’t give up thinking there’s nothing to be done. Seek support from professionals and keep piling up small improvements.

The content of this post is drawn (in its original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please go pick up a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1125/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.