Electronics face a patchwork of safety, EMC and substance rules
This is a consultation I get very often, and I don’t think there’s much good content out there that explains the overall picture of regulatory compliance in a systematic way. The reason, I think, is that regulations differ from country to country and keep changing constantly. Large companies typically have a dedicated department that researches standards and keeps an eye on trends in each country. Small companies more often ask an outside consultant for an opinion when the need arises.
So here, rather than aiming for strict precision, I want to explain things in a way that captures the overall picture as much as possible. For the most current details, base your judgment on the latest information from the appropriate authorities.
What’s very helpful for understanding the regulations around selling electronic devices is “what’s actually sold in the market.” Once something clears regulations it usually gets a mark attached, and looking at those marks shows you the overall regulatory picture.
For example, look at an AC adapter and you’ll probably see things like “PSE,” “VI,” and “RoHS” written on it. These mean, in order, that it clears standards for “safety,” “energy efficiency,” and “contained substances.” The content of regulations differs between products that plug into a primary power source (an outlet coming out of the wall) and those that run on a secondary power source (such as USB bus power or a battery). Safety test standards also differ by country, so depending on the device you may see other marks like “UL” or “CCC.”
Next, look at the product body itself — a laptop, for example — and you’ll notice a huge number of marks and certification numbers printed on the bottom or back. This is because laptops are mostly sold globally, so lining up all the appropriate marks ends up being quite a lot. I’ll avoid listing everything here, but broadly speaking these marks are based on roughly two types of regulation.
One is “electromagnetic compatibility,” also called EMC. The word “compatibility” is used in the sense that a device has to hold up on both fronts: not emitting illegal radio waves, and not malfunctioning when exposed to radio waves flying around in the environment. The commonly seen FCC mark, the CE mark, and what’s colloquially called the giteki mark all fall into this category. Some countries impose comprehensive, high requirements regarding electromagnetic compatibility, while others only require meeting part of it. Regulations differ subtly between countries, but each is built as that country’s own standard after reading and interpreting the underlying IEC standard. (Sometimes it’s a flat-out copy.)
The other is recycling-related requirements. These differ in detail depending on the materials used and whether a battery is present, but proper guidelines are provided, so I don’t think it becomes much of a problem as long as you research it carefully.
When people consult me about regulatory compliance, I think what most of them worry about is safety and EMC. As for safety, since many recent products run on secondary power, in most cases all you can do is require the manufacturer of the AC adapter or power unit to pass the relevant standards. As a countermeasure, I think it’s important to always have multiple candidate components in mind early in product development. On the other hand, what you need to watch out for with EMC is emissions, the outgoing side. Emissions include both intentional radiation and unintentional radiation; the former only applies to communication devices that use radio waves, but the latter applies to any device.
When an electronic circuit operates, current flows. Unintentional radiation is when the noise generated at that time doesn’t stay contained within the PCB or enclosure and leaks out to the outside. This happens in most devices. Unintentionally, as the name suggests. Intentional radiation is emitting targeted power exactly as intended, so even if it fails, countermeasures are relatively easy; with unintentional radiation, since there was never any intent to emit anything in the first place, people often struggle to find a fix once it fails. There’s no silver bullet that guarantees everything will be fine, but one thing I’d recommend is taking a measurement as early as possible.
In most cases, once the main IC and its operating speed, the internal communication speed and frequency, and the rough wiring layout are decided, the degree of unintentional radiation is largely determined. Of course, a prototype’s measurement results aren’t what gets you through certification, but once the configuration is roughly finished and the device powers on, taking a measurement at that point gives you a sense of how much risk you’re carrying.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1122/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.