Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Pricing starts with business model and business form

Pricing is something you must always decide when releasing a product.

There’s a rough rule of thumb that says “three times the cost is a safe bet,” and it turns out to be remarkably accurate most of the time.

The first things to think about when setting a price are the “business model” and the “form of the business.”

Put simply, a business model is “how you make money.” There’s the simple model of selling a product and taking a profit on it, and there’s the model of making money by offering a subscription service to the people who buy the product. There’s also a long-standing business model where you don’t make money on the product itself but instead profit from accessories or optional services. Depending on the business model, the judgment of whether you must secure a profit here, or whether it’s fine as long as you just barely avoid a loss, differs. Apple might look at first glance like a company that makes its money from services, but apparently it’s actually “a model that makes money on both.” No wonder it’s become such a huge company.

The form of a business concerns what kind of company it is, how many people it employs and how, and what assets it has invested in and how much — and these factors greatly change how you think about profit. In management-speak, these are “fixed costs” and “depreciable assets.”

A large company with a big, impressive office, housing everything from development and sales departments down to back-office functions, carries very high fixed costs. Simply owning a factory, warehouse, or other facilities means costs keep accruing for management and maintenance. Also, after a product is released, the development department’s expenses taper off, but costs for ongoing customer service and support start accruing instead. At a company like this, you can’t set the product price from parts cost alone — you need to properly calculate the costs sitting behind the scenes and layer them onto the cost basis. In many cases, this gets calculated using fixed values or coefficients that the company or department sets on a yearly or quarterly basis.

A business form that’s a small organization with only the minimum necessary staff, one that outsources most of its work, makes cost calculation easier and more accurate. As a result, managing price and profit precisely becomes easier. That said, costs may end up inflated overall, since each outsourcing partner adds its own reasonable profit margin.

Assets aren’t just equipment and the like — they include development costs too. What’s included in development costs isn’t just obvious expenditures like purchased goods, prototypes, and mold costs — it’s also common to apportion and accumulate the personnel costs of the development team members.

So on a project developed over many years, the accumulated assets become large. Those assets begin to be depreciated over a set number of years starting when the product is released. Since that depreciation counts as a loss in accounting terms, you need to cover it with profit from a management standpoint. How much this depreciation amounts to depends on the asset amount and the depreciation period, so it can’t be stated in general terms — but deliberately underestimating the asset value or setting the depreciation period longer than reality can lead to serious mistakes in pricing.

I’ve written some fairly complicated things here, but here’s the interesting part: if you do a rough calculation in a spreadsheet using the above as a reference, you’ll often find that setting the price at around three times the parts cost secures sufficient profit.

The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup

The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1119/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.