Technology Does Not Automatically Make People Happy
I first raised this question around 2015, when I was in the process of launching my own business. Casually voicing this seemingly absurd question over drinks made me realize that a surprising number of entrepreneurs and engineers carry around questions with a similar core.
Philosophical thinking is indispensable when you’re thinking about a business. The word “philosophy” might make this sound like some lofty discussion, but it isn’t anything so grand — it just means taking the stance of “doubt what you assume is normal.” It’s easier to understand as “keep asking why.”
Suppose, for example, you are developing a device that detects an employee’s poor physical condition and notifies a manager. The benefits are plentiful: reduced physical risk to employees, less time spent by team leaders on management, and accumulation of quantitative data on employees’ task loads and condition. Great, this is clearly worth doing.
But let’s bring a philosophical stance here and try doubting everything.
For instance, ask “why is it good to reduce physical risk?” and you notice there are several stakeholders involved. Split them into “the executive,” “the manager,” “the team leader,” and “the member,” and you find: it’s obviously preferable for members themselves to be physically healthy; for the team leader, if a member becomes unwell the schedule slips, so it’s better to let them rest than push through illness; for the manager, being able to grasp the whole picture without visiting every site in person is extremely efficient; and for the executive, being able to avoid the risk of serious accidents or workplace injuries with a cheap service is desirable. It looks like we might achieve not just three-way benefit but four-way benefit.
Next, let’s doubt whether “reducing the team leader’s management workload is really desirable.” In essence, this means fewer opportunities for things like checking in on condition at morning meetings or talking with the leader about the situation (the device will do it for you instead — how wonderful!). For the executive, reduced workload means reduced cost, which also leads to headcount reduction, so it’s desirable (happier if people do less work). For the manager, fewer factors depending on the team leader’s skill mean less risk, so it’s desirable (happier if people do less work). For the leader themselves, though, the resolution on members’ situations drops and fewer touchpoints make managing harder. And even if management workload decreases, other work just comes their way instead, so the job doesn’t get any easier. For the member, fewer touchpoints with the leader increase anxiety. Things start to look shaky. A new proposition emerges here: is reducing workload actually correct?
Thinking in the same way, a question arises about data accumulation too: who actually benefits directly from accumulating this data?
What’s interesting is that a business plan that initially looks flawless and wonderful becomes increasingly suspect the deeper you dig with philosophical thinking. You dig and dig, convince yourself, then dig again. The state where everything is finally sorted out and feels clear is what we call something clicking into place.
Now, the skeptical stance of “is reducing workload actually correct?” can be the trigger for a very major breakthrough. That’s because converting workload reduction into monetary terms to measure the value of a system being introduced is “common sense” practiced everywhere. Let’s doubt that common sense.
I’ll avoid going into detail here, but repeating this kind of philosophical thinking usually leads somewhere. It leads to the proposition: does XX really make people happy? In the end, it’s not an exaggeration to say that people engage in every activity in order to become happy, so in a sense this destination is obvious. Along the way to reaching it, I’ve also passed through propositions like “is economic growth a good thing?” — even though I was supposed to be thinking about a business model.
The philosopher Wittgenstein taught the importance of clarifying definitions. The opposite of “clarification” is “facile generalization” — his warning that unless you properly fix the definitions of words, the logic itself becomes meaningless. A simple example is “beautiful people have it easier.” “Having it easier” presumably means “being able to live a good life.” But the definition of a “good life” differs from person to person. Some people prioritize acquiring money above all else in life, while others feel fulfilled by having time to spend with family. In other words, the sentence “beautiful people have it easier” has effectively no meaning at all, since it changes depending on how you define “have it easier.”
So for the proposition in the title, “does technology make people happy?”, we can see that the definition of “happy” is the key here. The definition of “happy” is close to that of “have it easier” from before, and varies infinitely from person to person. So let’s instead take the contrapositive. The contrapositive of “if A then B” is the proposition “if not A then not B.” Here, that becomes “without technology, people are not happy.” We can clearly see that this proposition is wrong. To affirm it would mean branding our parents’ generation as “unhappy” compared to ours, our grandparents’ generation as “unhappy” compared to our parents’, and so on back through our great-grandparents’ generation. I can’t bring myself to believe that at all. If the contrapositive can be proven correct, the original proposition can also be said to be correct. In other words, what this tells us is: technology does not necessarily make people happy — in fact, it’s close to irrelevant. Which means, if you think that introducing some technology has made people happy, that’s a major self-deception.
Am I denying technology? No, I am not.
What I want to say is that we should doubt the benefits that come from making something more efficient or convenient. Just as we think about what was lost through mechanization since the Industrial Revolution (beauty? texture? or perhaps a certain rustic charm?), we also need to think about the people laid off as a result of reduced workload, the minority suffering from new schemes of exploitation born out of the sharing economy, and the one person in a million who is disadvantaged by an AI’s unexpected input. We need to ask: does this technology actually make everyone happy?
Of course, as in the earlier example, there are plenty of technologies and business ideas that achieve not just three-way benefit but four-way benefit. To see through to the essence of things, and to avoid wasting the precious time and effort of our lives, it is extremely important to always think things through with a skeptical stance.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get the book.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1100/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.