A clear-eyed CFO shows startups suit specialists without stock options
There are all kinds of people at startups, more than you’d expect.
Some are young, ambitious, bursting with energy, exactly the type you’d picture when you think “startup.” Others look for all the world like ordinary middle-aged salarymen.
At some companies, as one founder put it, “even when we throw a drinking party, basically nobody shows up.” The average age of the team is high, some have families or have just had a child, and the team is made up of people with low sociability and a craftsman’s temperament. Zero party vibe. Quite a few startups look far removed from the common stereotype of young people staying up late together and doing outdoor activities as a group every weekend. I privately call this kind of company a “mercenary startup.” Here I want to talk, with a very clear-eyed view, about my friend H, who belonged to one.
He changed jobs to join a certain startup in his early thirties. His specialty was finance, and his career included time at an audit firm in Silicon Valley. A few years after joining, he became CFO, but he never received stock options. Of course he held no common stock either. In other words, he was CFO with zero capital gains exposure to the company whatsoever. Honestly, I’d never heard of such a thing. His reasons, in his own words, were: “I’m not worth that much,” “I’ll be leaving eventually anyway,” “It’s cleaner to just take cash,” and “Not having options or stock lets me say what actually needs to be said.”
“I’ll be leaving eventually” comes from his own self-assessment that “I’m not good at building something from zero to one. And my skill set isn’t suited to raising rounds above tens of millions of dollars.” In other words, he believes it’s “mutually preferable” for someone like him to join a startup partway through, help it grow to a certain size, and then step away partway through. This is an extremely clear-headed self-analysis paired with a total absence of lingering attachment. When I heard this, I was honestly impressed.
And his statement that “it’s better not to hold stock options” is something that anyone who works at a startup, or aspires to, should listen to carefully. The downside of holding capital gains is holding capital gains itself. Stock options in particular do nothing just by being held. To actually realize the gain, an IPO or a buyout is essential. Only at that point can the options be turned into cash. He’s saying that isn’t necessarily the right path. I agree wholeheartedly.
Take IPOs, for instance. They tend to fall into one of two extremes. “We can’t raise any more money, so let’s IPO” and “We could probably IPO, so let’s IPO.” The former is, in a sense, a healthy kind of IPO. The valuation has grown so large that the amount needed for the next funding round is too big for anyone to invest. In that situation, turning to the public markets instead is reasonable in most cases. Occasionally a company on the verge of bankruptcy bets everything on an IPO as a last chance, but that’s rare.
The problem is the latter case. An IPO takes enormous effort. It costs money. It’s not something you can do on a whim; it requires time and advance preparation. You have to meet with people across many different areas, consult them, and line up their cooperation. And many people who have been through an IPO say more or less the same thing. “During that period (while preparing for the IPO), the quality of our service dropped.” Often the growth curve people were hoping for afterward never materializes, and the company ends up being called an “IPO as the goal” story. If you can see that story unfolding at your own company, the right thing to do as an insider is to oppose the push toward an IPO. But once you hold stock options, the equation “IPO = my own near-term personal payout” locks into place, and you risk losing the ability to make the right call each time it matters. Ideally, it would be admirable to say, with iron resolve, “I won’t do anything that isn’t good for the company!” But people can rarely hold themselves to that standard. “That includes me,” H says.
Eventually earning capital gains by working at a startup is, certainly, a story everyone dreams of, and it has real appeal. Naturally most people’s dreams don’t come true, but a small number do reach that harvest. But in reality, if you join a startup partway through as an employee rather than a founder, the capital gains you end up receiving are, in most cases, roughly equivalent to “getting, all at once, the bonuses you never got along the way.” The story of every employee becoming a millionaire when YouTube was acquired by Google is famous, but that’s an extremely rare event that happens maybe once every few years somewhere in the world.
Let’s take a step back here. The appeal of joining a startup is by no means limited to that. So why is an “IPO as the goal” story a bad thing in the first place? Because it only makes some of the stakeholders happy. Customers and employees in particular get left behind. But a company should really exist for the sake of its customers and employees above all. What makes startups genuinely exciting is the closeness and the high level of commitment you can have with those stakeholders who should be the priority. For someone like H, who takes pride in his expertise and holds a clear-eyed self-assessment of both his strengths and weaknesses, this makes for an extremely rewarding kind of day-to-day life, one that puts his own value to the test in a very direct way.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1097/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.