Equity Exploitation Is The Real Danger In Startups
In startups, the phrase “exploitation of passion” comes up often. Even when work carries plenty of meaning, a cash-strapped startup can’t pay wages to match, so it ends up imposing low pay and overwork, or getting many people involved for no compensation at all. I don’t take a particularly negative stance on this.
Motivation
The motivations of people who come to startups vary from person to person, but one thing holds true for many of them to some degree: they’ve grown disillusioned with existing companies — sometimes large ones — and are looking to startups to make up for that. Beyond the question of meaningful work mentioned above, they carry a kind of frustration: doubts about the growth prospects of the company they worked for, doubts about their own career growth within it. In most cases, though, startups only hold out the “possibility” of filling that void for them — the substance usually isn’t there.
So even without any intention to exploit, all the elements are in place for something that inevitably gets called exploitation of passion to emerge. From the standpoint of the individual working at a startup, the important thing, I think, is not to depend on the startup too heavily for too long a stretch of time.
Startups aim for dramatic growth.
Put the other way around, a startup that isn’t growing at all over the long term is no longer a startup. At that point you should switch your mindset to one of simply working at a small or medium-sized company, seriously consider whether staying there can actually fill the hunger or dissatisfaction described earlier, and in some cases, it’s perfectly fine to choose to leave.
Manage the challenge and its closing properly like this, and you won’t end up being exploited by the startup. If anything, you’ll come away with valuable experience that can’t be bought with money alone.
Shifting now to the perspective of a founder, there’s another kind of exploitation in startups that calls for great caution, from a different angle.
It’s the exploitation of equity.
My wife is a former nurse, so she doesn’t know anything about technology or startups, but as the saying goes about the temple novice picking up scripture by osmosis, she sometimes grasps the heart of a matter surprisingly well. Once, when I was watching an online video titled “Startup XX Contest! The winner gets $X million!”, she muttered from behind me, “Is that prize money? Or investment?” — and I was genuinely impressed. I’d read the fine print of the terms. It wasn’t prize money.
It’s investment.
And it said that at least 30% of the equity would be taken.
I’ve never seen a textbook that says what percentage of equity is appropriate for someone to take depending on how they’re involved. But anyone involved in startups carries some rough sense of this, and it doesn’t vary all that much from person to person. Outside that “market sense” are young people who have just launched a startup. They are, so to speak, easy marks. If they’ve already received investment from a sensible angel investor, or have experienced advisors involved, that’s one thing — but take, say, “an AI venture just founded by three graduate students,” and for a bad-faith adult, it’s open season for deception.
You might think this sounds like a scam story, but in reality there are sickeningly many cases of it. Still, startup fundraising is basically decided behind closed doors, so no outsider knows what’s happening. Then, once the company has grown steadily and reaches an IPO, a prospectus full of questionable details suddenly surfaces.
The solution
The way to avoid this kind of exploitation is simple: talk to people around you. Not just the angel investors or advisors mentioned earlier, but also founders of startups who recently raised funding, speakers from seminars you’ve attended, regional startup support centers, and so on. Whether you actually take their advice to heart is up to you, but there aren’t that many people in the world scheming to skim profit off people who are taking risks and working hard. Most will genuinely offer you advice with your best interests at heart.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please consider picking up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1072/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.