Borrowing from parents to start a company carries real risk
I once had a realization from something a friend of mine with an MBA, a company executive, said to me in Silicon Valley. “Raising equity is the worst-case option.” There’s a related saying too: “You only do an IPO when you can no longer raise funds any other way.” Both ideas carry heavy implications for fundraising in startup management.
In any business, the key thing is controlling the balance between risk and reward. Money itself has no color. It doesn’t have wings, and it isn’t strong or weak. No matter where you pull it from, a dollar is a dollar. So choosing a fundraising method is a huge opportunity to minimize risk while keeping reward intact.
I’m not a corporate finance expert, so here I’ll just lay out a few points at a level anyone can grasp easily. If you’re interested, go consult a specialist about your specific situation.
A company can’t operate without money. Broadly speaking, there are two ways to get it: “borrow it” or “exchange it for something.” For example, even if you put your own money in during the early days of founding a company, processing it as a loan from an officer counts as “borrowing” (even though it’s the founder’s own money), while folding it into capital stock and holding 100% of the shares counts as “exchanging it for equity.” You can also generate money by raising sales. If that comes from selling some kind of asset or providing a service, that too is, in the end, an exchange.
In the borrowing case, what matters is the interest rate and the repayment terms. The lower the interest rate, and the longer the grace period or repayment period, the better you’re controlling risk.
In the exchange case, the important question is “what was exchanged for how much.” This gets a bit more complicated. To take an extreme example, if you got paid in exchange for something you didn’t need at all, the risk was close to zero. But if you give away something that will become enormously valuable in the future for a pittance, risk and reward are out of balance. When what’s exchanged is a product or service, it was made from the start to be exchanged for money, so as long as the business model isn’t a failure, risk and reward should be considered under control. The real issue, then, is equity funding.
People joke that “raising equity is like getting married, except you can’t easily get divorced.” Giving away equity carries several risks, but the biggest one, needless to say, is “where control of the company lies.” The lower the current management’s ownership stake falls, the more their influence tends to shrink. In the worst case, there’s an outside takeover. Some executives barely worry about their ownership stake at all. It’s not unusual for a founder to hold under 10% at the time of an IPO, but a founder who’s gotten close to that level even at the private stage must have real nerve. There’s also the problem that each round of equity funding raises the valuation, and once that gets too high, raising the next round gets harder. If someone wants to put in a large sum, they naturally want a commensurate stake, but once the valuation has risen, getting that stake requires putting in an enormous sum. When that sum becomes something nobody can afford, an IPO becomes the last resort — which is the idea behind the opening quote. Taking a company public and scattering shares across the market is, in a sense, like entering into a terrifying number of simultaneous marriages. Worse, from the company’s side, you don’t know who your partner is, and you have no idea what they’ll do. And you can’t refuse them.
Given that raising equity always carries some degree of risk, it’s natural to ask, based on the balance described above, “what about borrowing instead?”
Many companies run on borrowed money. Equity funding in particular comes from people who care about capital gains, so the company is expected to deliver exponential growth. But the world doesn’t have that many businesses that lucrative. My friend Y, an executive, runs a music school and related services. Since it’s an equipment-based business, his basic approach to fundraising is borrowing. He often consults me saying “I really want to raise equity,” and I always tell him that if he can borrow, that’s the way to go. His reply is always something like, “Yeah, I know that, but still…” Looked at one way, running on borrowed money is an external recognition of “ordinary growth,” while raising equity is an external recognition of “dramatic growth.” Any executive probably feels some pull toward the latter. A truly skilled CFO balances borrowing and equity. That takes considerable skill, and it’s not something I can easily explain myself.
The annoying thing about borrowing is that it’s still money you have to pay back. Obviously. Debt comes with a repayment period — the period in which you must pay it back — and contractually, paying it off in full within that period is absolute. But in reality, refinancing before the repayment period ends is common. For a bank, what matters is building a track record of lending and receiving repayment, and that feeds into a simple behavioral principle: lend more to stable borrowers. In other words, if a company has kept up stable repayments and happens to be short of repayment funds right now, the bank will extend additional financing, pay off the current debt in one lump sum, and sign a new loan agreement. The longer and more stably a relationship with a bank continues, the more it can feel like an illusion of permanence takes hold. But in reality, cases where additional financing gets cut off, repayment is demanded, and the company goes bankrupt are everywhere. Everyone knows this, so people always approach borrowing with some wariness. Generally, companies try to reduce risk by borrowing from as many different banks as possible, while banks try to lock in a main bank relationship and consolidate debt as much as they can — this tug-of-war plays out everywhere. A syndicated loan can fairly be called one of the bank-led mechanisms (strategies) pursuing that latter goal.
At this point, you probably have a reasonable sense of the pros and cons of both approaches. So what’s the strongest fundraising method of all? It’s still “borrow from your parents.” First, you give up no equity. There’s nothing to exchange. Even though it’s technically a loan, if it’s treated as a personal gift, it can be folded into capital (effectively deferred payment once you succeed). Unsecured, low interest (sometimes no interest at all), and extremely flexible on repayment terms. Few quality funding methods offer such favorable conditions all at once.
Naturally, this isn’t about the phase of “raising $X million in a Series A.” It’s about the few thousand dollars or tens of thousands of dollars needed to build a prototype in the earliest stage. If you’re working and have reasonable savings, just spend that. But if you’re a student about to hand over excessive equity in exchange for $8,000 or $15,000 from an investor, stop that foolish move right away, buy some good sake, go home, and talk to your parents. As someone running a company, I think you always have to pour your heart and soul into controlling risk and reward. Presenting to your parents, bowing your head, enduring complaints and scolding, and pushing and pushing until you somehow work something out — that strikes me as the bare minimum of what “pouring your heart and soul into it” means.
The content of this post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please get a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1069/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.