Entrepreneurs and fraudsters sit closer than people think
“I paid $3 million for a single sheet of acrylic,” entrepreneur I laughs, half-joking. When he took the stage at TechCrunch, he used a small sheet of acrylic to convey the image of a product that didn’t yet exist in any form. It turned out to be a huge hit, and he went on to raise $3 million in funding. He’s obviously no con artist, so he properly launched the business afterward and is still respected today as a pioneer in AR.
But at his next company, he raised money the same way, and this time the launch didn’t go well. It spiraled, and in the end, despite being the founding CEO, he was pushed out of his own company. Some people, on the strength of that outcome, call him a fraud.
I think part of this comes down to just how good he is at presenting. Many entrepreneurs speak in a way that blurs the line between “what’s already working” and “what we’re about to do.” This isn’t malicious — for them, that boundary doesn’t carry much meaning. But it carries enormous meaning for investors and for the employees working at that startup. When the gap comes to light, the entrepreneur gets called a “fraud.”
Handling media coverage in particular calls for caution. Faced with that kind of blurred boundary, the media will, as a rule, steer the impression toward whatever is more sensational. They don’t distort the facts — they simply frame things in whatever way can be taken that direction. In practice, this means stripping out the caveats and supplementary context the person gave earlier, or cutting out just one fragment. I’ve always believed startup executives should keep their media exposure to a bare minimum. If a friendly outlet always covered exactly what you wanted said, that would be a great blessing, but in most cases the media says what it wants to say. A gap opens up here too. It starts small, but it builds up gradually, and once it’s grown large enough, if the discrepancy with the truth comes to light, you get called a “fraud” all over again.
Most founders who get unintentionally labeled frauds — practically victims themselves — fall into this pattern. But some startup founders do commit outright fraud, deliberately and with malicious intent.
In Silicon Valley, for instance, the Theranos story is extremely famous. It was a medical startup founded by Elizabeth Holmes, who took the world by storm with the powerful message that “a single drop of blood can reveal every disease.” It raised tens of billions of yen, but no such technology had actually been established — in reality, many of the tests had been faked. It was a shocking, landmark scandal. From the perspective of someone involved in startups, the reaction is basically “give me a break,” because it was certain to heighten investors’ wariness across the board. I was involved in healthcare at the time, so I think I felt this more strongly than most.
Even so, part of this has to be taken as a lesson in watching others to correct yourself. For anyone involved in startups, isn’t this true to some degree for everyone? Raising a big, bold banner the way they did is exactly what nearly every startup does, without exception. I’ve never seen a startup that only talks about what’s achievable right this moment. Honestly, a company like that wouldn’t even be called a startup. If asked whether something is possible, whether there’s real prospect of it, wouldn’t most people answer immediately and confidently, “Yes, there is”? When you’re digging up numbers like market size, don’t you pick whichever dataset looks best out of several and put just that one in the slide deck? Don’t you quietly tuck away into a desk drawer the data that isn’t exactly negative, but just doesn’t look as good?
When an engineer says, “There’s no way, we won’t make it in time,” haven’t you told the outside world, “We’ll make it in time”? When the CFO says, “If we don’t raise funds by the end of the year, we can’t keep the business running,” haven’t you told a business partner, “We won’t have any funding issues for the next two or three years”? Haven’t you talked up a partner you’ve only met once or twice as “we’re in talks on a business tie-up with Company X”? If those small bluffs eventually grow into a problem that drags in stakeholders, you risk being called a “fraud.”
At the same time, I think there’s room for the view that making the bluff real is precisely what makes being an entrepreneur worthwhile. Professionals in startup investing size up people and businesses with that bluffing already factored in. You might call it a game played between professionals. But with Theranos, what made it especially egregious, I think, was that many of its stakeholders — its backers and supporters — weren’t specialists in either medicine or startups. They were simply “people with power.”
This post is an excerpt (original text) from the following book. If you’re interested, please pick up a copy.
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
The Shape of a Happy IoT Startup
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/08/1066/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.