CCS captures carbon from fossil fuel plants and stores it underground
I took the online class “CCSx: Climate Change: Carbon Capture and Storage,” offered by Edinburgh University on edX.
https://learning.edx.org/course/course-v1:EdinburghX+CCSx+3T2020/home
You get a certificate like this when you finish the course (for what it’s worth).

https://courses.edx.org/certificates/48fa366825894691a33a4f3deab01760
I’m going to summarize what I learned over a few posts, mainly as notes for myself, and hopefully useful to someone else along the way.
A simple explanation of CCS
Most CCS facilities currently in operation are installed at fossil fuel and biomass fuel plants. There, the technology captures the CO2 generated, compresses it into liquid form, and injects it via pipeline into reservoirs several thousand meters deep — depleted oil and gas fields, saline aquifers, and the like — to isolate it from the atmosphere semi-permanently. CCS itself often draws its energy from surplus power plant output or renewable sources.
Global CCS Map
https://www.sccs.org.uk/expertise/global-ccs-map
Here you can check the operating status of CCS facilities around the world and how many Gt of CO2 per year they’re planned to sequester.
Where is the carbon?
Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a gas present in the atmosphere in very small quantities — about 0.042% of the atmosphere, or 1 molecule out of every 2,400. Before the Industrial Revolution it’s said to have been 0.028%, or 1 in 3,500.

The diagram above is very useful for understanding where carbon is stored and how it moves from one place to another. Similar diagrams turn up often in IPCC reports and the like.
Here’s what we can gather from it, for a start:
- The amount held in geological storage is overwhelmingly larger than other reservoirs
- It’s 5 or 6 orders of magnitude larger than the amounts in the atmosphere or in plants
- Even compared with the deep ocean, which has a reputation for storing enormous amounts of carbon, it’s 3 or 4 orders of magnitude larger
- The amount extracted as fossil fuel is vastly out of balance with the amount returned to the geological cycle
- The scale of geological transfer is extremely small compared to the scale of carbon exchange among the atmosphere, living things, and the ocean
- Fossil fuel combustion plus deforestation together amount to roughly 100 volcanic eruptions’ worth
- It’s fair to say that without human activity, atmospheric CO2 would never have increased at all
Scenarios for global warming

The above is an example of a warming scenario published by the IPCC. The horizontal axis is the amount of CO2 accumulated in the atmosphere since the Industrial Revolution. The vertical axis is the temperature rise that accompanies it. The model runs a variety of scenarios corresponding to different patterns of natural and industrial change, but broadly speaking, if the goal is to keep the temperature rise under 2°C, total emissions need to stay under 3,000Gt — that’s the target line. Put another way, once the total exceeds 3,000Gt, “emissions < removals” must hold at all times from that point on. (That remaining allowance is called the Carbon Budget.) Extrapolating from the current situation, we have roughly 1,000Gt of headroom left.
Image: Figure SPM. 10, IPCC, 2021: Summary for Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Masson-Delmotte, V., P. Zhai, A. Pirani, S. L. Connors, C. Péan, S. Berger, N. Caud, Y. Chen, L. Goldfarb, M. I. Gomis, M. Huang, K. Leitzell, E. Lonnoy, J.B.R. Matthews, T. K. Maycock, T. Waterfield, O. Yelekçi, R. Yu and B. Zhou (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press. In Press. Available here.
One thing to watch out for: whenever global warming is discussed, everything being described is the “global mean temperature.” It’s not at all strange, then, for this to diverge sharply from the subjective impressions of someone living in a particular place — things like “summers have been brutally hot lately” or “we’ve had a lot of cold spells these past few years.” A change of a mere 1°C or 2°C, averaged over the entire surface of the globe and further averaged over a year, is essentially impossible to perceive as anything other than a “statistic.”
So conversations along the lines of “X is happening lately because of global warming” need to be treated with caution. In most cases, what’s actually being discussed is a trend over a few years to a few decades in a localized seasonal wind, ocean current, or pressure pattern. Whether the globe is warming or cooling, Arctic ice will melt a lot in some years and not much in others.
The Paris Agreement
The Paris Agreement, agreed in 2015, was a groundbreaking framework that brought together countries accounting for 55% of global emissions. The United States withdrew in 2017, but the coalition’s cohesion didn’t waver — if anything, the US rejoined in 2021.
Climate Action Tracker https://climateactiontracker.org/ A site where you can track whether each country’s efforts in various categories are consistent with the “below 2°C” or “below 1.5°C” targets.
The dilemma CCS faces
CCS can be installed at plants that use fossil fuels and can immediately capture and sequester the CO2 emitted. This creates a logic whereby the oil industry and others could invest solely in CCS, without investing in reducing carbon dioxide itself, reasoning that once the capture rate eventually hits 100%, the Carbon Budget will never be hit. But following this logic risks funneling excessive investment into CCS, a field that still has considerable room for improvement in cost and equipment, needlessly driving up the cost of carbon capture.
Carbon Overshoot
Current IPCC reporting and elsewhere already assumes, in many scenarios, that “the amount of carbon still to be emitted” will exceed the “2°C line” — in other words, an overshoot. So it’s taken as a given from the outset that “negative emissions” from removal will be necessary. The amount of removal needed by the end of this century is said to be 600 to 800 billion tons.
Tipping Points
Explainer: Nine ‘tipping points’ that could be triggered by climate change
Provided by the European Climate Foundation. A list of “if this happens, climate change gets really dangerous” thresholds. Nine tipping points are currently listed.
The importance of BECCS

BECCS is the fusion of bioenergy with CCS. There’s nothing especially technically difficult about it. It’s simply a matter of using CCS to geologically sequester carbon when generating power from biomass fuel. What matters is that, through a somewhat roundabout process, carbon can be sequestered from the “atmosphere” into “geology.”
Plants capture CO2 from the atmosphere and store it within themselves. But this is eventually dispersed back into the atmosphere. This sequence takes a few decades, or at most around a century — far too brief given that what’s needed is semi-permanent carbon sequestration.
By the same logic, simply using biomass fuel without further thought isn’t enough. Burning it returns the carbon to the atmosphere. Combine it with CCS, though, and carbon can be sequestered along the path “atmosphere” → “plant” → “energy” → “geology.” And since energy is obtained in the process too, the benefits are substantial.
Why isn’t planting trees enough?
One reason is the short duration of carbon sequestration by plants. The buildup of atmospheric carbon since the Industrial Revolution is a problem that needs to be resolved over a span of centuries, and one that must never be allowed to recur, semi-permanently. Sequestering carbon for just a few decades to around a century isn’t an adequate solution. And trees absorb carbon mainly only while they’re growing.
Another point is the strain tree planting places on farmland. Suppose we tried to cancel out the world’s CO2 emissions through tree planting alone. Per-capita CO2 emissions vary enormously by country, from 0.03 to 37.29 tCO2 per year, averaging around 4.79 tCO2. The amount of CO2 a tree can store also varies by species, location, and age, but an average tree can absorb roughly 25kg of CO2 per year. If every tree planted survived, offsetting one person’s emissions would require planting 192 trees every year, continuously. A dense forest can hold about 2,500 trees per hectare. A single square kilometer of land could hold 250,000 trees, offsetting the annual emissions of 1,300 people.
This might look like a promising approach at first glance, but offsetting the annual emissions of roughly 7 billion people would require newly planting 6 million square kilometers of forest every year. That’s 1.8 times the total area of India. Unless the plan is to keep planting the equivalent of two Indias’ worth of forest every single year, “why don’t we just plant trees!” isn’t a serious answer. By 2050, the entire Eurasian continent would end up nothing but forest.
What’s more, land suitable for tree planting is, in most cases, also land suitable for farmland. That forces a choice between reducing existing farmland and forgoing new farmland needed for food security. Scaling back the tree-planting effort would improve compatibility with these other concerns, but at the cost of reduced emissions-reduction impact. Unless this dilemma can be resolved, tree planting isn’t a particularly effective measure from the standpoint of reducing CO2.
DAC = Direct Air Capture
We’re still buzzing from the launch of #Orca. In case you missed it, watch our video tour that takes you through our history to retrace the milestones that enabled us to realize our vision of bringing large-scale #DirectAirCapture to reality. Watch here: https://t.co/k7URCnC2Ey pic.twitter.com/qFMGF0eEQg
— Climeworks (@Climeworks) September 23, 2021
DAC captures carbon directly from the air and sequesters it underground as-is. Switzerland’s Climeworks can be called the world’s leading frontrunner in this space. However, it’s currently only projected to sequester a few thousand to a few tens of thousands of tons per year, and further innovation will be needed going forward. As of 2022, Climeworks has received over $780 million in funding.
Note that nearly all of the content of this post is a summary and supplement of content belonging to “EdinburghX” (CC-BY 4.0)
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/07/916/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.