Japan Runs on Air, Not Logic
The Study of “Air” (Bunshun Bunko)
Masks and air (this isn’t about breathability)
I had this exchange with someone the other day.
“Why does everyone wear a mask walking around out here? The streets are wide and it’s pretty far from the station, so there’s hardly anyone around.” “Huh? That’s obviously just deference. They’re hedging against the risk that if someone spots them without a mask, it’ll leave a bad impression.” “Is there really anyone who’d react badly over something like that at this point?” “Well, that depends on the air of the times, doesn’t it.”
This exchange is probably playing out all over Japan right now.
Against that backdrop, the head of the Tokyo Medical Association recently proposed relaxing mask requirements.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OlanHbgjBT0
When I brought this up with the same person, the reaction was:
“Ah, that’s a brave thing to say. I hope it changes the air out there.”
So what exactly is this “air”?
Being Japanese myself, I know perfectly well that in Japan, air governs most situations. Conversely, when I worked in the US, I often felt that many of my colleagues said things without any regard for air at all.
But what exactly is air?
As it turns out, someone studied this more than 40 years ago, in the book mentioned at the top, “The Study of Air.” I’d like to summarize it here.
Air arises from grasping an object as if it were numinously present
“Grasping something as numinously present” means, put simply, feeling that something which isn’t there is there, and then treating it as absolute. You could also call it attributing to a physical object a value beyond what it physically is. Idol worship is a clear, concrete example. A lighter-weight version would be good-luck charms.
The realist understanding that an object is just an object, existing only to perform its function, is what causes air to collapse.
A simple example of air: an incident when a joint Israeli-Japanese excavation team unearthed a large quantity of human bones. During the handling of the remains, only the Japanese members fell ill. A large quantity of human bones strongly evokes some kind of tragedy—war, perhaps, or massacre, or an epidemic. So for the Japanese staff, performing a purification ritual on the spot became necessary. Only the Japanese shared this sense of something immaterial being present. An air that outsiders couldn’t quite grasp genuinely existed for them.
The enlightenment education of the Meiji era kept condemning the unscientific. But as the psychic powers boom showed, the things that get denied are often the ones that persist most stubbornly.
This kind of numinous grasping always involves one-sided emotional projection and dependency. It brushes aside logic and technical understanding with ease, and entrenches itself firmly.
The danger of absolutizing objects
It’s easy to make a villain out of a physical object, since it never talks back in its own defense.
Absolutizing means clearly declaring something good or evil.
Relativizing, by contrast, means comparing the degree to which each thing has strengths and the degree to which it has weaknesses. It doesn’t declare anything definitively.
Absolutizing invites a halt to thinking, and for humans, not having to think is very comfortable. So people use it liberally, everywhere.
Western society absolutizes less readily. You could frame absolutizing as equivalent to deifying, but for Westerners, God is singular and unique, not something that just anyone can conjure up on the spot, or that shifts with the tides of the era.
When Arai Hakuseki forced the deportation of Japanese Christians, he voiced a particular concern. Christians believed that an individual connects directly with God, reflecting on themselves and receiving guidance there, and Hakuseki judged that this belief could well destroy the cultural system of Japan, a system governed by air.
When Japan surrendered, Emperor Shōwa declared “I am not a living god.” But in fact, he had never once said “I am a living god.” This too was a form of air-based domination, exploiting the fact that no one was going to contradict him.
The Pacific War and domination by air
Postwar accounts explaining why the battleship Yamato sailed out even though defeat was known to be certain record this comment: “it wasn’t an atmosphere where dissent could be voiced.”
There’s an expression, “throwing cold water on something.” It’s almost always used negatively, but its original meaning is stating reality plainly, in opposition to a mistaken air that’s building up.
Before the Pacific War, Japan had no financial resources, and its oil supply had been cut off. “How exactly are we supposed to win in a situation like that?” Plenty of clear-thinking people must have wanted to say this, but it wasn’t an atmosphere where it could be said.
In the closing days of the Pacific War, the situation had degenerated into a game of chicken over who would be the one to say surrender. One army officer, the moment unconditional surrender was decided, went to check whether his land and tenant farmers were safe. Everyone had simply been wearing a monster costume, hiding, in deference to air, the perfectly natural feeling that their own property and family mattered far more to them than the war ever did.
The old Imperial Japanese Army regarded liberals as useless people, good for nothing. People who plainly said what they saw and heard didn’t fit the organization’s norm of mutual concealment: the father hides it, the son hides it.
Absolutizing and media strategy
The Satsuma Rebellion is said to be the first war in Japanese history in which media strategy was used. The imperial army used newspapers to spread the claim that the Satsuma forces were senseless savages who apparently amused themselves by cutting up corpses.
Absolutizing has weak staying power and tends to produce a repeating cycle of relatively short, decisive battles. The result is rebounds, or booms that simply fizzle out once people grow bored. This too is a characteristic effect of air.
Japan is culturally prone to intense swings of fad and decline (people in the 70s thought so too) because it casually deploys multiple instances of this absolutizing at once.
When you discard some old custom and re-grasp a new idol as numinously present, you get the illusion that your self has been transformed. When you throw away an old fad and seize a new one, you get to feel good under the misapprehension that you’re a pioneer blazing the leading edge of the trend.
There’s no denying this was effective during postwar reconstruction. But it doesn’t last.
In closing: arguing fairly
Personally, the thing I felt was important in the US, and which I find very difficult in Japan, is, first and foremost, arguing fairly.
I often see conversations lacking something I consider utterly basic: a flat, even exchange that doesn’t condemn the other side as good or evil based on whether they agree or disagree.
This isn’t some unrealistic demand like “kill your emotions” or “say only things backed by scientific evidence.” It’s more a kind of frustration: if people could just have a flat conversation that includes emotions too, why can’t they manage it?
“I feel anxious.” “I feel uncomfortable.” “Honestly, this is getting irritating.”
These are important factors too. They should be laid out on the table and discussed. Quantify them, through surveys for instance, and it might become possible to line up even these vague emotional dimensions alongside scientific evidence and discuss them rationally.
But if some kind of air already exists, and no one properly unpacks and lays it bare instead of concealing it, air wins. Air beats almost everything, without fail.
Take the example from the opening: you could run a survey asking, “On a street with good visibility, wide enough that you pass only a handful of people even after walking for 20 to 30 minutes, do you actually feel anxious about infection if you’re not wearing a mask?”
Science reached its conclusion on this long ago. The risk is extremely low (if anything, other negative factors, including their uncertainty, are more worth worrying about). But scientific evidence alone stands almost no chance of beating air. Only once the emotional dimension is laid out alongside it does air seem likely to finally break down.
Or perhaps, going by a distinctly Japanese cultural framework, the more realistic solution is setting up a new idol (the vaccine never managed to become that).
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2022/05/888/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.