I Read Drawdown and Share My Thoughts on Climate Change
DRAWDOWN — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming
I’ve organized notes on the contents of Drawdown across several posts.
[Related links] ・Notes on Drawdown — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming (Energy Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming (Agriculture Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming (Nature Conservation) ・Notes on Drawdown — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming (Transportation Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming (Construction and Urban Sector)・Notes on Drawdown — 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming (Materials Sector)
What genuinely deserves admiration, I think, is how many problems remain and how many countries are pursuing various efforts to solve them.
I once worked on a project to collect air pollution data.
At the time, I struggled to find anyone who understood what I was doing, whether in America or Japan.
That’s a thing of the past now.
It’s deeply encouraging to learn that people all over the world were working on these issues since before I started that project — in fact, long before.
So why was there such a large gap in awareness? That’s one question that comes to mind.
Back then, I often heard comments like this:
“America has clean air and plenty of land, so nobody there feels this is a problem.” → true, in fact “The environment doesn’t make money.” → true, in fact
Both of these are indeed true.
And yet the WHO and the EPA alike keep sounding the alarm about rising numbers of deaths from air pollution, and India and China report serious air pollution damage almost every month.
Despite that, indifference persists. In other words, for people in many countries, environmental issues still haven’t become something they feel is “their own problem” — that was simply the reality I was confronted with.
Someone might donate $10 to food aid for Africa, but they wouldn’t think of going to the field to provide concrete support, let alone imagine investing tens of millions of dollars to back a project — that’s the scale of the gap we’re talking about.
Historically, too, the environment has been treated as a “shared asset” placed outside the market economy. Whether you make it better or worse carries no direct economic rationality. If there’s a regulation, people comply; if there isn’t, they don’t — put crudely, that’s how it’s always been.
In recent years, though, that’s shifted considerably.
Concretely, this means the introduction of carbon taxes, and further, the growth of the carbon credit market.
The environment is now being absorbed into the economy. Some people no doubt view this negatively.
The Hungarian economist Karl Polanyi, active in the first half of the 20th century, identified “labor,” “land,” and “money” as “fictitious commodities,” arguing that these should not be fully commodified under capitalism.
In other words, these should only be traded under various political constraints and forms of management, not purely on economic rationality.
What would Polanyi’s perspective make of “the environment”?
For instance, the extreme urbanization that has resulted from the commodification of land is a shared problem across developed countries. It became the root cause of bubbles not only in Japan but in many countries. This is exactly what Polanyi warned about.
Yet the carbon credit market has drawn attention in Europe, Oceania, South America, and elsewhere, and I understand this as an attempt to:
“rebalance the world’s power map by creating a new financial market.”
Everyone understands that the era in which you could solve everything by aggressively extracting fossil fuels and exploiting the Global South through mass production and mass consumption has completely ended. Carbon credits can be seen as one attempt to sketch out the picture of the society that comes next.
Personally, I see it functioning rather cleverly as a strategy to drag people who can’t grasp this as “their own problem,” as mentioned above, onto a shared table whether they like it or not.
Right now we’re in a period where “private carbon credit markets” are running rampant. What determines whether “commodifying the environment” succeeds is what kind of platform emerges to manage this in an integrated way, and who ends up controlling it.
That’s a bit of a digression. Beyond the above, it’s fair to say the surrounding conditions for environmental measures and environmental business are coming together from many angles.
Amid all this, Drawdown was packed with ideas about what challenges remain where, and how to think about gauging their impact.
The sector where I felt the strongest impact was “agriculture.” There are several points, but they can broadly be summed up in the following two:
・Technical integration has not progressed sufficiently ・It’s unclear which countries are technically advanced
First, on technical integration.
On many points, there doesn’t seem to be sufficient global agreement on “what the correct answer is.”
For example, conservation agriculture or regenerative agriculture is said (according to the author) to be superior to conventional farming methods both in terms of environmental burden and cost-effectiveness. Yet efforts to switch to it seem only sporadic.
In another example, a different book mentioned that agroforestry has been common in Australia since the 1980s.
It seems to have spread there thanks to proper policy recommendations from the government as well as favorable conditions like vast tracts of land.
I don’t think you see that kind of scene in Japan. It’s still the old pattern — “fields are fields,” “paddies are paddies,” “pastures are pastures,” “forests are forests.”
On weed management too, the book described several promising approaches, none of which appear in what you’d call standard agricultural textbooks (meaning there are likely very few cases where they’re actually adopted in the field).
When you read books on “natural farming” in Japan, they describe almost the same approaches.
The symbiosis among microorganisms captured in the “wood wide web” section, and the negative effects of fertilizer on it, are described in almost exactly the same way.
Many researchers realized this long ago.
But in a book by Professor Nakajima of the University of Tsukuba, he notes that the lack of established technical methodology remains a challenge.
In other words, this remains confined to interactions between researchers and a limited set of agricultural collaborators, while many commercial enterprises still can’t escape the trap of mass production and mass consumption through heavy inputs (fertilizer and pesticides).
That’s far from the ideal of “low input,” “circulation,” and “coexistence with nature.”
Next, on technically advanced countries.
As I noted in the section on the Burkina Faso case, it often turns out that methods developed locally by local residents prove most effective.
In another book, I read that in a method called nature-harmonious farming, seeds in the first year are simply scattered more or less at random, whatever’s available. Whatever grows well that way is taken to suit the land, so in subsequent years you think carefully about how to combine those crops through rotation or multi-cropping, after which a natural cycle emerges without much further intervention.
By contrast, organic farming apparently draws criticism for requiring constant soil adjustment to keep the land suited to organic methods — and you have to keep doing this to maintain it, which drives up costs.
From the standpoint of “everyday food,” the cost that can be devoted to agriculture is never large. Just look at the prices of vegetables on supermarket shelves, and that’s obvious.
The market economy has resolved this through the logic of scale.
It’s an approach deeply familiar to us: produce in bulk all at once and you can make it cheap.
That became reality through developments like the invention of the Haber-Bosch process, which revolutionized nitrogen fertilizer, and the history of pesticide improvements.
But it goes without saying that concerns have recently arisen over the environmental burden and soil sustainability these bring.
If something turns out to have been wrong, we should look back, turn around, and search for another path.
Developed countries already know the answer. Though — which countries count as “developed,” exactly?
At a turning point in history, there’s a good chance that much of what we need to learn is hidden in economically less-developed countries.
The extremely tricky thing about agriculture is that farming has to suit the particular character of each piece of land, and resisting that gets you nowhere. Knowing the land is extremely important.
What follows is purely my own hypothesis, but I think there’s a lot technology can still do on this front.
Naturally, when land is cleared for farming, the soil gets tested. I imagine detailed surveys are done, including below ground, with things like boring surveys.
But those are nothing more than a fragment cut out of time and space.
This is the problem.
Testing at multiple sites costs money, and testing over a wide area costs money too.
So the data you get is coarse in time, sampled only occasionally, and the spatial resolution is never sufficient either.
Improving this would raise the precision of template-style choices like “this kind of land calls for this kind of method,” and integrating soil data and harvest data from various locations would also expand the variations of the templates themselves.
There do seem to be private-sector attempts at this kind of data integration, but joining as a member apparently costs a fair amount of money, so I gave up on it (why can’t this be done on an open platform?).
There’s still plenty IoT can do in agriculture. I’m convinced of that.
(Though of course various people have already attempted this, so it’s worth watching closely to understand why it hasn’t worked.)
Shifting perspective a bit, the energy sector was easier for me to understand, being closer to my own expertise, but it felt somewhat saturated — I mean that in a purely positive sense.
For the various methods of power generation, the technical advantages and generation efficiency are mostly already understood, and it’s fully at the practical implementation stage.
Conversely, I didn’t feel much of a bright future for the generation methods that, despite years of effort, still haven’t gotten there.
In other words, all the cards are already on the table, and we’re now at the phase of asking what to do with them.
That makes grid-related technology all the more important going forward.
Each renewable energy method has its own drawbacks that come from following the constraints of nature, and this inevitably demands a dynamic system to optimally compensate for them. This is undoubtedly a grand and difficult undertaking, but I honestly don’t see much in the way of technical limits or constraints — it’s not really a field that calls for groundbreaking innovation. I can picture it being achieved through steady, incremental accumulation.
What’s more likely to become a problem, I think, is the political removal of vested interests tied to fossil fuels and nuclear power.
These interests survive on the excuse that renewable energy still isn’t perfect, but everyone understands that excuse won’t hold up much longer.
And vested interests involve not just capital owners but the employees who depend on them too.
The more progress is made toward low-cost, easy-to-maintain energy and toward reducing operating costs through AI, the sharper the conflict with those vested interests is likely to become.
I have no expertise in nature conservation, so my reaction there was more like “hm, that was informative” — but the discussion of ocean permaculture genuinely gave me chills. I felt enormous creativity in it.
The idea of planting forests in the ocean is, I think, genuinely worthwhile.
It would support photosynthesis, likely increase plankton, and in turn increase fish.
That much makes sense on its own, but then: using tidal and wave power to draw cold water up from the deep sea, causing vertical mixing, so the sea surface doesn’t heat up.
Kelp sequesters carbon dioxide as it sinks to the seafloor.
Combined with ocean circulation patterns, if the placement is designed well, carbon could be sequestered on a scale of thousands of years (this part is my own view).
It needs no energy input, and since no energy is being harvested, it can be done anywhere.
I was struck by the coherence and scale of the whole logic.
Honestly, I could keep writing much more, but I’ll stop here for now.
The field of the environment is overflowing with great possibility and great necessity.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/12/826/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.