Drawdown Maps 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming, Materials Edition
Drawdown: The Most Comprehensive Plan Ever Proposed to Reverse Global Warming
Drawdown is a project-style book led by an American writer, with contributions from researchers across the world. It lays out what can be done to bring about “drawdown” — the point at which atmospheric carbon dioxide levels begin to decline — and splits broadly into two parts: a survey of what’s currently being done, and an introduction to future technologies. The survey of the current state struck me in particular, since I didn’t know the details of many of these items, or wasn’t even aware of them at all. It’s fair to call this required reading for working adults. But at over 400 pages in two-column format, the book amounts to a good three ordinary books’ worth, and even for me, a fairly fast reader, it took more than a month to finish.
So I’d like to extract and organize the essence of it to some degree. Whatever else you can say about it, this is a book perfectly suited to grasping the big picture.
Here I’ll cover the materials sector along with items that didn’t fit neatly into any category.
Recycling
Some poor countries have recycling rates on par with developed nations. In fact, small-scale recycling is a typical business model for small enterprises.
Der Grüne Punkt, the Green Dot: a German system in which businesses collect waste at manufacturers’ expense. EPR, Extended Producer Responsibility: the idea of obligating producers to handle collection and recycling, used in the Netherlands and elsewhere. Materials marketplace: an online marketplace for trading secondary raw materials, i.e., recycled materials.
Refrigerants
This is the item expected to deliver the greatest reduction in greenhouse gases. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs), once used as refrigerants, caused ozone layer depletion and have been phased down. But their substitute, hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), has a greenhouse effect 1,000 to 9,000 times that of carbon dioxide. 90% of greenhouse gas emissions from refrigerants occur at disposal, so reuse or neutralization is the challenge. If these emissions can be avoided, the reduction effect is considered greater than any other measure.
In China, air conditioner penetration rose from 7% to 95% between 1995 and 2007.
The Kigali Amendment, created in 2016, includes enforcement mechanisms and penalties.
Natural refrigerants, using propane, ammonia, high-pressure carbon dioxide, and the like, are expected to play a role.
Bioplastics
Polymers — chain structures that impart plasticity — exist everywhere, and there aren’t actually many reasons we need petroleum to make plastic.
- Cellulose is the polymer that forms plant cell walls
- Chitin is the polymer that forms the exoskeletons of crustaceans and insects
- Potatoes, sugarcane, tree bark, algae, shrimp — all contain polymers
Ivory billiard balls once drew criticism, which led to the development of celluloid. It ultimately wasn’t suited to billiard balls, but it found use in combs, toothbrushes, film, and more. Petroleum-based Bakelite followed celluloid, and bioplastics were forgotten until the oil crisis of the 1970s.
In 1941, Ford built a soybean-based bioplastic car, but it lost out because petroleum was overwhelmingly cheap at the time.
Polyethylene (PE) shopping bags made from sugarcane or corn don’t biodegrade, but polylactic acid (PLA) does, at high temperatures. Some varieties biodegrade even at low temperatures and are considered helpful for the ocean plastic problem.
Only 5% of all plastic is actually recycled; the rest is incinerated or landfilled.
Concrete
The Pantheon in Rome, built in 128 AD, is the oldest and largest unreinforced concrete structure and has strength exceeding that of typical modern concrete. Concrete saw no further advances until the 19th century.
One method improves concrete strength by having it absorb carbon dioxide. But emissions from the concrete manufacturing process itself are far larger.
Cement is burned in kilns, a process that separates out carbon dioxide. Blast furnace slag, an industrial waste product of steelmaking, and fly ash, an industrial waste product of coal power generation, can serve as substitute materials in cement processing. Fly ash doesn’t require a kiln. New York uses crushed glass bottles instead.
Paper
The paper industry’s greenhouse gas emissions exceed those of the aviation industry.
The following items didn’t fit neatly into any category.
DAC: Direct Air Capture
A technology that captures carbon dioxide using chemical substances (amine-based) or porous honeycomb ceramics. Applying heat after capture releases the carbon dioxide, letting the absorbent be reused.
The problems: you need to bring a huge volume of air into contact with the absorbent to extract a meaningful amount of carbon dioxide, and releasing the carbon dioxide afterward requires energy input. The market for compressed carbon dioxide is difficult too. There are uses — as fuel, in carbonated beverages, and so on — but since carbon dioxide is already abundant, it can’t compete on price. Burying it is pretty much the only option.
Cookstoves
40% of humanity still cooks using primitive stoves. Fuels include firewood, charcoal, animal dung, crop residue, coal, and more. These produce soot and smoke that shorten residents’ lifespans.
Indoor air pollution causes more premature deaths than HIV, AIDS, and malaria combined.
Soot (black carbon), produced by incomplete combustion, has a greenhouse effect a million times that of carbon dioxide, but it disappears within about ten days (SLCP: Short-Lived Climate Pollutant). This means reducing black carbon has an immediate effect. A quarter of black carbon originates from households.
GACC, the Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves, is a long-running project, but results have been insufficient. Many companies have developed new stoves, yet progress has been poor: most manufacturers either failed to understand user experience and built products that missed the mark, or built products with little effect on greenhouse gas reduction. Stoves need to blend into culture.
Gender Equality
Data shows that women reinvest a greater share of their income into health and education. There’s also a correlation between progress toward gender equality and crop yield per unit area.
Malala Yousafzai won the Nobel Prize for advocating women’s rights under Taliban rule. She has also survived a Taliban attack. “Social vaccine.” She argued that simply improving girls’ education would solve most of the world’s problems.
Population
The population problem isn’t a problem for countries like Uganda or Uzbekistan. It’s a problem for countries like the United States, where 45% of women experience unintended pregnancies and per-capita fossil fuel use ranks among the highest in the world.
[Related Links] ・Notes on Drawdown (Energy Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown (Agriculture Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown (Nature Conservation) ・Notes on Drawdown (Transportation Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown (Construction and Urban Sector)
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/12/824/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.