Public Transit Needs Density, Not Sprawl, Drawdown Argues
Drawdown: The Most Comprehensive Plan Ever Proposed to Reverse Global Warming
“Drawdown” is a project-style book led by an American writer, with contributions from researchers around the world. It lays out what can be done to achieve “drawdown” — the point at which carbon dioxide levels begin to decline — broadly divided into two parts: an overview of what’s currently being done, and an introduction to future technologies. The “understanding of the current situation” part in particular shocked me personally, since it was full of details I either didn’t know or hadn’t even considered. I’d call it required reading for working adults. But at over 400 pages in two-column format, the book is easily equivalent to three ordinary ones, and even I, a fairly fast reader, took over a month to finish it.
So I want to extract and organize the essence to some degree. Either way, this is the perfect book for grasping the big picture.
This post covers the transportation sector.
Public Transit
In American metropolitan areas, public transit usage is below 5%. In Singapore and London it’s half. Public transit wins on carbon, but it needs high-density cities. That’s the opposite of urban sprawl, which is what’s generally happening now.
Bullet trains cut carbon enormously, but cost issues keep them from spreading. California’s high-speed rail plan is also headed nowhere, with costs doubling and no end in sight. Few high-speed rail routes anywhere in the world actually turn a profit. Construction itself consumes huge amounts of cement, so the emissions are unavoidable.
Modal Shift
Curitiba, Brazil is a model city. Buses are prepaid, stops are everywhere, and bus-only lanes mean the transport capacity (passengers × distance) beats private cars.
Mayor Jaime Lerner put it this way: “If you want creativity, cut one zero from the budget. If you want sustainability, cut two zeros.”
Electric Vehicles
The concept goes back to the era of Edison and Henry Ford, but it never took off because battery technology didn’t keep pace. In the early days of the automobile, internal combustion, electric, and steam were evenly matched. Then Ford’s influence drove down the cost of internal combustion vehicles, and oil discoveries within the United States lowered gasoline costs, and internal combustion took over.
Electric bicycles caught on in China around the 1990s, when air pollution had gotten seriously bad, but poor recycling of lead-acid batteries became a problem.
Ridesharing
Ridesharing actually began during World War II, when carpooling to work was encouraged to conserve resources. It drew attention again in the 1970s because of air pollution, which is when carpool lanes appeared (special lanes to ease congestion, open only to cars carrying two or more people — common in the US).
Trucks
Trucks make up about 4% of vehicles and about 9% of distance traveled, but they account for a startling 25% of emissions, a reflection of how poor their fuel efficiency is. Switching to newer, more fuel-efficient vehicles actually pays for itself in 1 to 2 years. But split incentives — where the person who pays for the vehicle isn’t the person who benefits from the lower fuel costs — often get in the way.
Airplanes
Airplanes are the toughest category for cutting fossil fuel use; their emissions are said to run 47 times those of shipping. A shift to biojet fuel is the hope, but cost and infrastructure are both far from ready. Requiring airlines to submit fuel efficiency data has actually cut consumption, partly by pushing airlines to reduce time spent in holding patterns before landing.
Bunker Fuel
This is the residue left over from petroleum refining, sometimes used in shipping. It’s high in sulfur and a source of particulate matter. Carbon emissions from ship operations currently face no standards or regulations.
[New Technologies and New Initiatives]
Hyperloop
Elon Musk’s concept, backed by $5.5 billion (¥600 billion) in investment. The plan connects San Francisco to Los Angeles, running trains inside a depressurized tube to make the trip in 35 minutes.
The original idea came from rocket scientist Robert Goddard in the 1910s.
Power consumption is a groundbreaking 90% lower than conventional rail, but even a slight curve subjects passengers to dangerous G-forces, so the route basically has to run in a straight line — and flat, straight land is extremely hard to come by.
The Ray
A project by Interface, a company originally known as a carpet maker. EVs charge while driving on it.
[Related Links] ・Notes on Drawdown (Energy Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown (Agriculture Sector) ・Notes on Drawdown (Nature Conservation)
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/12/820/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.