Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Drawdown Shows Agriculture's Huge Untapped Potential

DRAWDOWN: 100 Ways to Reverse Global Warming

“Drawdown” is a project-style book led by an American writer, with contributions from researchers around the world. It organizes what can be done to achieve “drawdown” — the point at which atmospheric carbon dioxide levels begin to decline — into two broad categories: an overview of what’s already being done, and an introduction to future technologies. The “understanding of the current situation” section in particular struck me personally, since there were many items whose details I didn’t know, or hadn’t even been aware of. It’s fair to call this required reading for working adults. But at over 400 pages in two-column format, the actual volume is easily equivalent to three ordinary books. Even for me, a fairly fast reader, it took more than a month to finish.

Here I’d like to extract and organize the essence of it to some degree. In any case, this is a book perfectly suited to grasping the big picture.

On the agriculture sector

Personally, I was struck by the huge potential of the agriculture sector — how much remains undone that should be done.

Meat

Greenhouse gas emissions from livestock rank second after fossil fuels, and if you add in deforestation and food waste, they rank first. It’s become widely known in recent years that ruminant animals produce methane, but in the United States in particular, this is propped up by enormous livestock subsidies. Without them, meat would presumably have remained an “occasional treat.” Today, the average person in North America is said to consume 90g of protein per day, against a healthy guideline of 50g.

Food Waste

A third of all food production is wasted. Despite this, 800 million people go hungry. Food production naturally involves fossil fuel use and CO2-emitting processes, and a third of that is wasted for nothing. Compare the scale of this waste to countries by emissions, and only the US and China exceed it. Nitrogen fertilizer, for example, is a source of nitrous oxide. Fully 1.2% of total global energy use goes into producing nitrogen fertilizer, but most of it ends up in the atmosphere as the greenhouse gas nitrous oxide, or flows into the ocean, causing algal blooms, oxygen depletion, and mass fish die-offs. In low-income countries, the main cause is unintended waste from underdeveloped supply chains. In high-income countries, the waste that occurs is intentional, and avoidable.

Multistrata Agroforestry

Layering multiple crops and plantings increases water retention and raises the efficiency of carbon storage. It also happens to produce food. The basic way to grow coffee, for example, is shade-grown, which produces the best quality. Growing it in direct sunlight yields more but dramatically degrades the soil. Mix coffee into a multistrata farming system, though, and you can secure a certain degree of permanence. A home vegetable garden counts as a long-standing form of multistrata agroforestry. It makes you realize that you can feed yourself somehow, as long as there’s sunlight, without needing the exceptional knowledge or skills of an expert. Nuclear power and ethanol aren’t solutions — they just create new problems. Multistrata agroforestry requires land with high moisture, involves high initial costs since mechanization is difficult, and takes time to pay off, losing out to other farming methods in terms of immediate yield. But once established, it’s resilient to weather variation, effective at curbing deforestation, highly capable of capturing carbon, and can produce 1 calorie of nutrition using just 0.02 calories of energy — a level of performance that stands out above the rest. Agriculture, as the saying goes, depends on cheap energy. There are indeed cases where 10 calories of fossil fuel go into producing 1 calorie of food, simply because that’s more economically rational: the energy balance doesn’t add up, but the economic balance does.

Zaï Farming

Farmers in Burkina Faso arrived at agroforestry on their own. By digging bigger holes and adding compost, they increased not only yields but tree cover too. Fallen leaves act as mulch, a covering that retains moisture. Trees are seen as assets rather than weeds, and are sometimes sold. The more trees there are, the richer the land becomes, providing fodder for livestock and increasing wildlife as well. Burkina Faso has a history of Europe repeatedly and capriciously introducing the latest farming methods, but in the end those methods lost out, and the local residents’ own approach was proven right. In Mali and Niger as well, agroforestry has become commonplace.

Regenerative Agriculture and Conservation Agriculture

The basic thinking is similar in both, and in Japan this is called “natural farming.” When the goal is to restore abandoned land, it’s called regenerative agriculture. No tilling. Before the 18th century, fields were barely tilled at all. No-till farming methods emerged in the 1970s. Tilling releases methane from the soil, and the land loses its ability to retain carbon. When carbon is absorbed into the soil, microorganisms increase and soil quality improves. Earthworms dig holes that improve nutrient absorption and increase water retention. The idea is that well-nourished plants become resistant to pests and no longer need fertilizer. Without tilling, seeds are sown and harvest residue is either left in place or covered with cover crops, which block sunlight and suppress weeds. Farmers find it easy to adopt, and it tends to show results quickly, but the crops planted, the methods of rotation and intercropping, and whether herbicides are used lightly or not at all, vary by farm, so the practice hasn’t really been modeled well. Conservation agriculture sometimes uses both fertilizer and herbicides. Regenerative agriculture has already been shown to outperform current approaches in both productivity and profitability. And it’s good for the environment.

Silvopasture

Raising cattle within forests. This has been practiced on the Iberian Peninsula for 4,000 years. Forests sequester 5 to 10 times more carbon than grassland of the same area. Treating forest as grazing land actually improves the soil, eliminating the need for compost or herbicides. It feels counterintuitive, but it’s true. The bias that trees interfere with grass growth is hard to shake. Silvopasture can be considered a variation of intercropping forestry.

Composting

Composting prevents methane emissions. It’s like turning trash into treasure. The EU composts 57% of its plant waste, the US 38%. The Haber-Bosch process for producing nitrogen fertilizer was revolutionary for agriculture. But at the time, a figure named Sir Albert Howard championed classical composting and opposed the Haber-Bosch method. Denmark stopped landfilling organic matter 25 years ago.

Perennial Crops

Annual crops release carbon into the atmosphere every year. Grapes, bananas, avocados, and the like are perennials, and they don’t damage the soil. Annual crops yield more nutritional value per hectare, but combining various perennials may make it possible to match that. No tilling is needed, they’re resilient to weather changes, drought-resistant varieties can be chosen, they work even on slopes, and the cost of transitioning to perennial crops is minimal. The cultivation of annual crops and rice dates back to around the end of the last ice age, 10,000 years ago. With annual plants, the roots die off too, leaving only the seeds. With perennial plants such as sesame and rapeseed, the roots stay alive and the seeds remain as well. Perennial plants use relatively little carbon during growth while also sequestering carbon. Their drawback is that mechanization is difficult — you can’t just harvest them roughly with a combine.

Soil Microorganisms

In the 19th century it was chemical fertilizer and pesticides, and in the 20th century genetic modification: the belief each time was that nothing could be done without them. And it’s true that yields increased. But because the activity of microorganisms in the soil was entirely unknown, no one realized the soil was being damaged. Until Jan Baptist van Helmont’s discovery in the 17th century, people believed that plants ate soil. In the early 19th century, Nicolas-Théodore de Saussure discovered photosynthesis. This led to the misunderstanding that plants obtained only five essential elements — water, carbon dioxide, nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium — from the soil, so it was assumed that supplying just those would be enough. Soil ecology has so far only managed to grasp the reality of about a tenth of soil microorganisms.

Managed Grazing

Overgrazing depletes land. So would removing the grazing animals help? No — the land doesn’t return to its original state. Without animals eating it, in other words, land doesn’t become rich. Techniques include controlling herd numbers, fencing and rotational grazing, and dividing land into zones moved through on a set schedule. The cattle’s behavior changes accordingly. Instead of eating tough, low-nutrition grass, they actively move around and eat protein-rich weeds, which makes herbicides unnecessary. Ruminants penned inside a fence are merely a source of methane, but released onto open land, they support the ecosystem. The issue is that this is still very experimental, without a fixed model. No for-profit companies have entered the field; it’s progressing through networks of farm owners and researchers.

Millennium Villages

Eliminating hunger in Africa and providing clean water is good, but it presupposes an injection of funding and isn’t sustainable. The target is always “some one village,” then “the next village somewhere,” without ever becoming standardized. Relying on agroforestry instead keeps the latest knowledge for solutions in the hands of local farmers, with no need to depend on funding or knowledge assistance from wealthy Western countries.

Abandoned Farmland

Abandoned farmland becomes a source of greenhouse gas emissions. But once it’s cultivated again, it becomes a carbon sink.

Rice Paddies

Rice paddies are an ideal environment for methane generation (10-20% of global emissions). They have a positive feedback loop in which higher temperatures increase methane production. System of Rice Intensification: a method to increase yield by transplanting seedlings earlier, periodically draining the water, and applying compost while the field is dry. It’s barely mechanized, but it doubles yield.

Biochar

Terra preta: a method long practiced in Africa of slowly baking organic matter into charcoal underground in an oxygen-free state. Soil productivity lasts a long time this way. Carbon made through slash-and-burn, by contrast, is only surface-level in the end.

Irrigation

Old-style irrigation involved flooding the field. Now it’s sprinklers. But agricultural water carries an environmental burden in terms of transport, and small farmers can’t adopt it due to cost. In Asia, irrigated area is only 4%.

[New Technologies and New Attempts]

Intensive Silvopasture

In tropical regions, growing a diverse range of plants lowers temperatures by 8-13°C. It also serves as a windbreak, raises soil moisture, and improves biomass. Leguminous shrubs are planted — leucaena, for example. Leucaena increases the amount of protein absorbable before fermentation, which both increases body weight and reduces methane emissions. Efforts like this are underway in Austria, Colombia, and Mexico.

Seaweed and Ruminants

Cattle are ruminants, and microorganisms break down cellulose and other materials in a stomach chamber called the rumen. 90% of the methane from that fermentation process is released through burps. Methane accounts for 25% of atmospheric greenhouse gases and 10% of all greenhouse gas effect. A Canadian dairy farmer noticed that feeding cattle seaweed eliminates methane production and even increases milk yield — part of the herd had been grazing along the coast. A substance called bromoform, contained in Asparagopsis taxiformis, interferes with the enzyme that produces methane. As a result, the cattle’s energy expenditure drops and milk production improves. There’s also an idea to combine this with ocean permaculture to mass-produce Asparagopsis in the sea. Researchers are pursuing a grazing-style method of farming Asparagopsis in the ocean.

Microorganisms for Nitrogen Fixation

Anaerobic bacteria convert atmospheric nitrogen into nitrates. They live in the roots of leguminous plants. The plant protects the bacteria from exposure to oxygen and gives them sugar in exchange for nitrogen.

Soil Microbiome

The potential of bacteria is still not well understood. Mutual support and symbiosis are the healthy state of a biome.

Bacillus thuringiensis

Corn, soybeans, and herbicides have already been commercialized that are genetically modified to incorporate bacteria that kill caterpillars, moths, and butterflies.

Hemp

Cotton is the dirtiest crop in the world. 36 kilograms of CO2 are emitted to produce a single T-shirt. Hemp, by contrast, is an annual crop that yields excellent fiber. It grows quickly, suppresses weeds, and can be planted densely without trouble. It can also substitute for paper, but the cost is six times that of pulp.

Yunnan Academy

Developed a plant that grows like a strawberry and bears rice grains once every few years. It grows not in paddies but in highland fields.

Deep-Rooted Wheat

Created through repeated selective breeding. It sequesters more atmospheric carbon underground, passing it to bacteria that acidify rock. The soil becomes rich, eliminating the need for tilling.

Oysters

Oysters absorb not only carbon but nitrogen as well.

[Related Link] ・Notes on Drawdown (Energy Sector)


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/12/816/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.