Wind Power Ranks Second Among 100 Fixes For Global Warming
Drawdown: The Most Comprehensive Plan Ever Proposed to Reverse Global Warming
Drawdown is a project-style book led by an American writer, with contributions from researchers around the world. It lays out what can be done to bring about “drawdown”—the point at which carbon dioxide levels begin to decline—organizing the material broadly into an overview of what is already being done and an introduction to future technologies. The “understanding of the current situation” section in particular was a shock to me personally: it covered many things I didn’t know the details of, or hadn’t even been aware of at all. I’d call it required reading for working adults. But at over 400 pages in two-column format, the book is easily equivalent to three ordinary books, and even for me, a fairly fast reader, it took more than a month to finish.
Here I’d like to extract and organize the essence of it to some degree. In any case, it’s an ideal book for grasping the big picture.
First, let’s look at the energy sector.
At present, an estimated 1.1 billion people in the world live without any electricity at all. Renewable energy is essential to supplying power to these people, and this is one of the reasons technology development and investment capital have been shifting direction in recent years.
Wind power
The impact is enormous. In the book’s own calculation of “expected CO2 reduction,” it ranks second out of all 100 solutions. The key point is that the cost is extremely low. Cost comparisons across different power sources are often published, but caution is needed: fossil fuels receive overwhelming subsidies, and things like free cooling water aren’t included in the cost, which can make them look relatively better than they are. In Denmark, wind power already accounts for 40% of total electricity generation.
Geothermal power
The basic pattern of geothermal power generation is to draw up steam, generated by heat underground, through pipes and use it to turn a turbine. Geothermal energy is said to exist in quantities 100 billion times humanity’s energy consumption, but fewer than 10% of locations are suitable for geothermal power generation (Japan is one of the few such areas). Geothermal power is well advanced in Kenya, where it supplies half of electricity; in Iceland, a third; and in El Salvador and the Philippines, a quarter. But digging into the ground releases CO2 that was stored underground, so geothermal projects have to watch for pollution issues like foul odors and for land subsidence. There is also a system (EGS) that transports water to locations that have heat but no water, in order to generate geothermal power.
Solar power
Solar power accounts for 8% of generation in Italy and 6% in Greece. Floating solar farms in particular are meaningful because they also suppress the generation of water vapor, the top greenhouse gas. The first solar panel was made in 1884, two years before Edison built the first thermal power plant. Distributed solar is especially powerful in off-grid environments, areas with insufficient transmission lines, and that has gradually shifted which countries invest most aggressively in developing solar technology. Solar power used to carry a high carbon cost in manufacturing, requiring processes like incineration, but this has improved dramatically in recent years. In 2016, Germany had several hours in which solar power supplied 88% of all electricity.
Tidal and wave power
This traces back to the oscillating water column originally developed by the former Imperial Japanese Navy. The mechanism: a buoy moving inside a column compresses and expands air, which turns a turbine. It’s an impressively eco-friendly mechanism, but there are many challenges, such as operating for long periods in salt water and avoiding harm to marine ecosystems. In fact, there is only one tidal power plant in North America, and no one has yet settled on the best structure for generation efficiency.
Concentrated solar power
This is the bold idea of doing, on a massive scale, what you do when you use a magnifying glass to focus sunlight and burn a leaf. It’s actually an old idea—Leonardo da Vinci is said to have built a giant lens to heat a pool. But there are many problems: it must be built in a capital-intensive way, generation efficiency is poor, and birds get burned to death in midair by the heat. On the other hand, heat itself has the advantage of being cheaper to store than electricity, through molten salt storage. Molten salt melts at 224°C. Once it has absorbed heat, it can retain it for 5 to 10 hours.
Biomass power
Among renewable energy sources, this has the largest number of power plants. But some of it involves cutting down forests and burning them, because of a shortage of waste wood—which, in short, defeats the purpose. In terms of the carbon cycle, this is the closest to natural. But biofuels like corn, poplar, and switchgrass have poor energy conversion efficiency. There are simply too many steps in the process, and energy is consumed along the way in things like transport. In net terms, they produce only a little more energy than is consumed, and the whole approach survives only through policy and subsidies. It’s likely to eventually be replaced and disappear in favor of cleaner energy.
Nuclear power
Depending on how you look at it, this is a clean form of energy. But the price isn’t expected to fall any further, and the overall trend favors the US halting new construction and Germany abolishing nuclear power entirely. At present, China is investing the most heavily in nuclear power. Notably, NASA’s Hansen, a climate researcher and activist whose papers are cited extensively in IPCC reports, is pro-nuclear. His argument is that renewable energy still needs time, and that climate change cannot be stopped without nuclear power.
Cogeneration
This is the idea of reusing what would otherwise be wasted during processing, but power generation doesn’t use it much. The efficiency of thermal power generation is below 40%, and that of internal combustion engines is below 25%. The remaining energy can be said to go toward warming the planet. CHP: Combined Heat and Power. In Denmark and Finland, biomass power is generated from wood, and the resulting heat is used for heating. Doing so eliminates the need for cooling water. This should be pursued together with distributed power generation, which is why it’s often government-led. The US lags far behind.
Small-scale wind power
In fact, about 1.1 billion people worldwide live relying on small-scale wind power. Small turbines are less efficient, but they’re quiet and don’t spoil the view. High locations are advantageous, so builders sometimes install them as backup power sources for buildings—the Eiffel Tower is one example.
Small-scale hydropower
It’s cheap, easy to maintain, and has a small environmental footprint. It’s typically used off-grid in mountainous areas, but in urban areas there’s conduit hydropower, installed in the main water supply pipes (Portland). But the field is still young, with no large corporations involved, and the startups tackling the problem have run into plenty of issues, damaging the flow of waterways or failing to withstand increased water flow.
Methane digesters
When organic matter decomposes, methane is produced. The practice of collecting food waste and the like, having microorganisms break it down, and using the resulting gas as fuel goes back more than a thousand years. Many developing countries also fix methane and make use of it.
Power generation from incinerating industrial waste
This is the worst idea, but Sweden does it to the point of importing garbage for the purpose. It produces CO2. It also produces staggering amounts of particulate matter. Mercury, lead, and cadmium are released too, of course. But many countries, especially those with little land, want to burn waste to solve their garbage problems. Filtering and reprocessing technology more or less supports this; for example, electric filters electrostatically charge particles to make them fall out. Burning waste is cheaper than recycling it, and it also reduces landfill volume by that amount. Since landfills generate methane, there’s a certain logic, not entirely without merit, to the claim that establishing clean-burning technology could reduce methane as a result.
Pumped-storage hydropower
This involves moving water up to a reservoir when there’s a surplus of electricity, then releasing it to generate power when demand rises. There’s also a version where loads are hauled up a mountain and power is generated by the friction of a rail car’s regenerative brakes.
Solar water heating
A quarter of a household’s energy use goes toward hot water, so generating hot water directly from solar heat saves electricity. In Cyprus and Israel, installation in homes is mandatory, but the high initial cost and installation effort remain challenges.
Smart grids
Geothermal, hydro, and biomass are energy sources available steadily, without seasonality. Solar and wind, on the other hand, depend on climate and vary widely by time of day and season. Integrating these sources and stabilizing the power supply that underpins social life requires a new grid structure.
[New technologies and new efforts]
Fusion reactors
TAE Technologies: Irvine, California. Rather than the conventional fusion of tritium and deuterium, they aim for the fusion of hydrogen and boron. Conventional methods produce neutrons, which gradually contaminate the fusion reactor with radioactivity, but hydrogen-boron fusion is completely clean. The catch: it requires a temperature of 3 billion degrees Celsius. Eighteen years after founding (the founder has since passed away), the company achieved plasma stability, spinning it like a top. The plan is to reach the necessary temperature using the force of the plasma’s rotation.
Artificial photosynthesis
Nocera: a researcher at Harvard. Supplying high-pressure CO2 to a catalyst and bacteria produces hydrogen energy at ten times the efficiency of photosynthesis.
Wave power
Developed by a company in Seattle. A very simple structure, in which the distance fluctuation caused by waves between a float and an anchor generates an electric pulse via a magnet, converting it into electricity. Cost viability, covering maintenance, power transmission, and so on, is still a work in progress. But the kinetic energy of the ocean is said to hold a hundred times the potential of the electricity currently needed by the world’s population.
Kelp
Soybean-based biofuel produces four times the CO2 emissions of fossil fuels. Kelp is a promising alternative. Georgia Tech has developed a technology that uses alginate extracted from kelp to increase the storage capacity of lithium-ion batteries tenfold. There’s also a grand plan in which turning 3% of the world’s oceans into seaweed farms could cover all of humanity’s energy consumption.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/12/813/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.