A Physicist Explains Why Time Does Not Exist
Carlo Rovelli
I want to try explaining “The Order of Time,” the bestselling book by the Italian physicist Carlo Rovelli.
Honestly, this is a fairly difficult thing to attempt. The provocative title is easy to grasp if you have some background in physics, but for a beginner it runs completely against intuition. So the correct advice would really be “just read the whole book.” People who can understand it will understand it, and people who can’t, won’t. But the content is so interesting that it would be a shame to leave it there, so I want to try anyway, if only to help spread the word. If I unpack the key points in order, I think even a beginner can reach a certain level of understanding.
My goal is for my wife (a former nurse who wants nothing to do with IT, startups, electricity, or physics) to understand it if she reads this maybe 20 times.
Note that this book mixes together:
- content that is already widely accepted
- claims from the author’s own research group that are currently being debated in academic circles
- “hypotheses that were wrong but worth discussing,” proposed by past scholars
so some caution is needed when reading.
Now, let’s begin.
<There is no such thing as one’s own time>
First we need to understand that “absolute time does not exist.” This is relatively easy to grasp. For example: ① Time passes faster at higher altitude ② Clocks on airplanes run slow ③ If you could video-call someone on a star one light-year away and ask them “what are you doing right now?”, you could never hear back about the “now” you recognize
① and ② are mainly Einstein’s achievements.
Time runs fast or slow
“Gravity slows down time” is already an “absolute fact based on observation.” Measurements have been taken in various places, and it has been repeatedly confirmed that the passage of time differs with altitude. There’s nothing to do but accept this. In other words, objects fall on Earth because time runs slower near the ground — that’s the thinking — and unraveling the mechanism behind this gravity is one of the biggest themes in modern physics.
The story of clocks running slow for fast-moving objects is often told using the example of twins, where one rides a spaceship back and forth to another star while the other waits on Earth, and the one who waited on Earth ends up older (I also became extremely interested in this after reading a book about Einstein in elementary school) — but what led Einstein to notice this was a question that arose while he was solving Maxwell’s equations (the thrillingly elegant equations describing the relationships of electromagnetism) for “moving objects.” It’s impossible to solve the equations without introducing a t’ that differs from the t describing time. Einstein interpreted this as “the clock of the person who is moving.”
In other words, even if people are in the same place, “a person standing still” and, say, “a person repeatedly making small left-right oscillations” will have subtly different rates at which time passes for them. This too has been experimentally verified. Despite being in (almost) the same place, the passage of time differs. It becomes clear that there is no longer any “time” common to all things.
It’s a well-known story that Einstein worked at a Swiss patent office in his youth rather than at some famous research institute, and it was there, while handling patents related to clock synchronization, that he realized “perfect synchronization of time is impossible.” That may well have been what drew him deep into this world.
What is “the present”?
Finally, ③ is, simply put, a matter of communication speed: after you ask your question, it takes a year for the other person to hear it, and their reply takes another year to reach you, so the reply arrives a total of two years later (and it answers what the other person said a year after you asked) — but various alternatives can be considered. For example, suppose you decide in advance on a date and time to make the report. But as mentioned above, once location and speed of movement differ, it’s no longer possible to maintain a single shared clock. In other words, your “now” and the other person’s “now” are already out of sync from the moment they started moving. Suppose there were a telescope that let you see someone one light-year away, and you thought, why not just treat what you’re seeing right now as “now”? But if a method of moving at the speed of light were ever developed, the other person might be right next to you the instant you saw that image. In that case, which one is “the other person’s now” as you perceive it? What you see through the telescope is, after all, not “now.” In other words, the “now” you perceive cannot recognize the “now” of something far away.
And yet we go about our lives without feeling the kind of inconsistencies described above. That’s because the gap in time that humans can generally perceive is at best around 0.1 sec, and as long as we’re talking about events on Earth, the gaps that occur there are smaller by many orders of magnitude than the limits of our perception. So as long as we limit ourselves to “humanity on Earth,” it’s entirely possible to feel like we’re sharing a “now.”
<The history of “one’s own time”>
In fact, until the first division of standard time zones in 1883, it was taken for granted that “time differs depending on location.” This is only natural if you think about it from the angle of convenience.
In an era when communication was far less developed than today and personal clocks were not widespread, so that people were loose about time, it’s easy to imagine that for most people, information like “how many hours until sunset (time to wrap up work and have dinner soon)” or “how many hours until the sun is at its zenith (when should I light the kiln)” mattered far more than “what time is it by standard time (so as not to be late for a meeting).”
The “delay” we feel day to day in communication isn’t a discrepancy in time itself, but rather the sum of things like the time needed for modulation and demodulation of communication signals, the time needed to process audio and video, and slowdowns caused by processing speed being squeezed by other tasks on a computer — it’s purely a technical matter.
As far as the historical record goes, the first person to express a skeptical view of “one’s own time” was actually Aristotle (seriously, what a monster). Time is a count of the number of times things change; if nothing changes, time does not pass. In darkness we experience nothing, meaning time does not pass. But we do think of something. That means time passes. That’s roughly the idea. At first glance this looks like a far-fetched conceptual argument, but it actually fits remarkably well with the worldview that modern physics has since unraveled (truly a monster).
The age of Newton
Time moved on, and Newton affirmed the apparent time that Aristotle spoke of, but separately from that, he believed there existed an absolute time (unobservable, appearing only in equations). And because Newton’s equations explained the physical phenomena of “most things” that we see, the prevailing mood became “Newton is right.” This is where the idea of “one’s own time” became fixed in our minds. But in fact, many philosophers and thinkers of the time took Aristotle’s side and pushed back against this idea of Newton’s.
In other words, if we think “one’s own time exists,” that’s merely because Newton made us believe it. After that, in the world of physics, Einstein published the theory of relativity, quantum mechanics developed, many phenomena that couldn’t be explained by Newtonian mechanics were explained, and theories were rewritten.
There’s probably no modern person who denies the existence of elementary particles. Nor do I think there’s a modern person who would flatly deny the many discoveries made in the field of quantum mechanics. So if there’s a modern person who affirms the existence of time, that person is simply outdated and wrong.
The birth of modern quantum gravity theory dates to a 1967 paper by Bryce DeWitt and John Wheeler. As they worked out quantum gravity theory, the variable for time disappeared from the equations. They were confused, and left the problem for the future.
<Digression: Time is not smooth. It is discrete>
The question of what the smallest constituent element of matter is has long driven physicists to research. In the end it arrived at quantum theory, and now the common understanding is: Planck length = 10^-33 [cm] There’s no such thing as a shorter length than that. Since no particle smaller than that exists, there’s no way to even measure it. Likewise, time also has a minimum unit: Planck time = 10^-44 [sec] That’s it. Since no finer unit of time than this exists, time can be said to take discrete, non-continuous values. Humans simply can’t perceive time that finely, so we only feel like it’s smoothly connected.
This might feel a bit eerie, but we live in a discrete world.
From here we cut deeply into the domain of modern physics. We enter territory that people who have only studied physics in high school have probably never heard of. This is an extremely complex area — complex enough that even the great genius Einstein got parts of it wrong.
If you break things down, the smallest unit goes: atom > elementary particle > field A field is an event. In other words, a thing itself is a “special state” of an event. For example, a stone is a special state of vibration of a quantum field. That acts on elementary particles, which act on atoms, and humans see, touch, and feel the state of “stone” that happens to have been fixed in place.
Fields are made of elementary particles, photons, gravitons — these form space. Time doesn’t appear here. Time doesn’t have a direction, nor is it a straight line, nor does it exist within curved geometry as Einstein claimed.
A quantum state is sometimes described as a “cloud of probability.” That’s because this vividly captures the basic principles of quantum mechanics:
- everything is defined by a probability distribution
- the state is unknown until observed
In the quantum world, nothing has its behavior determined except through interference from something else. Before that, there are only several probabilistic “possible states,” and “which state it actually is” is unknowable — this is a state of affairs that’s intuitively hard to grasp, but it has indeed been confirmed by numerous experiments.
In the microscopic world, this chain of interference and determination is always occurring. But human perceptual ability can’t directly see or touch it, so we can’t know the details. As a result, humans only see an approximation of an approximation of an approximation of reality, and mistake it for “the world.”
Time, too, in this world of an approximation of an approximation of an approximation (the world we live in), can be perceived as a single thing, but in the quantum world, it only appears and disappears within interactions, only in relation to whatever it’s interacting with.
Saying that time disappears might make this all the more baffling, but it’s nothing special. Everything is born and disappears. That’s due to the increase of entropy (the second law of thermodynamics). It’s enough to understand entropy as an index expressing that an orderly state is low and a scattered, disorderly state is high.
For example, firewood has low entropy (the atoms are arranged neatly), but once it catches fire and burns, it transitions to a high-entropy state (the atoms are scattered). In the universe, hydrogen has low entropy; to get to helium you need a stellar explosion, and that explosion requires a huge collapsed mass of hydrogen, which takes millions of years to form. A low-entropy state is fixed, and when something happens it moves toward increase, then it stagnates again for a while, and when something happens again, another door opens. All the workings of life follow this flow.
Objects don’t fall because it lowers their energy. Energy, in total, is conserved. The correct answer is that mechanical energy (low entropy) is transferred to the Earth as heat (high entropy).
The world is like a pile of sand slowly collapsing from the order of the universe’s birth into disorder.
And within such a world, time is not something real; the only true reality is the gravitational field.
The equations presented in the aforementioned paper by Bryce DeWitt and John Wheeler showed the connections between each matter. There, a world with no variable called time existed. Now that you mention it, even the famous Schrödinger equation is an equation describing change.
Heidegger: “Time temporalizes only insofar as there exists a being called Dasein there.” The self is born through recognition of and interaction with the world.
Augustine said, “Time is in the mind.” To begin with, why is it that even though “the present” is something that flows, we can keep perceiving “the present”? The past is memory, the future is prediction. The present is the self that perceives them. In the end, all of these exist within the self.
In quantum theory, as long as there’s no observer (something that interferes in some way), you can’t know what state an object is in, or even whether it exists at all. Time is the same kind of thing.
Time is a measure for gauging change. But there is no single variable t suited to measuring everything. This is exactly what Aristotle said.
The delay of time, the nonexistence of the present, the relationship between time and the gravitational field, entropy — these are all already-proven facts.
But the quantization of the gravitational field is still at the level of theory. There are no experimental results. Also, the claim that there is no time variable in the fundamental equations is not a settled fact either; it’s a hot topic currently under heated debate.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/08/673/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.