Japan Can No Longer Beat China At Mass Manufacturing

Whether this counts as “winning or losing” depends on the definition, but in the sense of “becoming like China,” I think we can say that’s no longer possible. The reason is the overwhelming gap in capital. Many Japanese companies lack the capital, the stamina, and the human resources to invest in new large-scale production lines.
Still, the pandemic made many people aware of the danger of relying too heavily on other countries for supply chains, especially for goods essential to daily life. And conveniently, Japan is no longer a developed country in the old sense. Wages aren’t especially high, and years of deflation have kept prices from rising much, so the cost of living isn’t especially high either. So it’s fair to say that the case for running manufacturing operations in Japan has strengthened in recent years. This is very good news.
At this moment, when many people are starting to question the neoliberal global economy, a moment of genuine transformation, I think it would be a very good thing for Japan to push manufacturing forward with a new vision. But the gap in capital and resources I mentioned earlier can’t be denied. Which means competing in a market built on mass production and mass consumption is, by necessity, not a good idea.
There’s a domain where the logic of capital doesn’t exert much force, and that doesn’t necessarily mean luxury goods. It might be luxury goods in some cases, but the key point is that it involves things that take effort. Things that take effort inherently resist the logic of capital. They’re hard to streamline and hard to automate. I think manufacturing in such domains holds real opportunity, not just for Japan, but for local businesses everywhere.
I also see this as something of a turning point for the era in which China could serve as “the world’s factory.”
Manufacturing that can be divided into separate tasks lends itself to formalized processes, and that brings benefits in capital efficiency, whether through automation or outsourcing. But that’s precisely what also means “anyone else can do it.” So naturally, “the world’s factory” has kept shifting throughout history. In that sense, China probably has little motivation to artificially hold back that flow, and in practice it has no means to stop it anyway.
A country like Japan doesn’t need to take anything back from China. It’s enough to keep in mind a vision where, when creating something new and high-value, companies manufacture it in collaboration with local businesses as much as possible, growing together with partner companies rather than alone.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/08/527/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.