I Explain My View on Industry-Government-Academia Cooperation

My own career has never taken me inside a government body, but through my work I have dealt extensively with government institutions, and I have also found myself coordinating closely with academia. These days, I am fortunate enough to hold a seat, however minor, in academia as well.
The greatest benefit of collaboration is that each party compensates for the other’s weaknesses. So what are the respective strengths and weaknesses of industry, government, and academia?
The clearest case is “government” — that is, government institutions. Government effectively has inexhaustible funds. In practice it faces constraints from various external factors, such as the need to control inflation or adjust interest rates, but in principle a country like Japan, which can issue fiat currency, has enormous flexibility in its funding sources. Japan’s general account expenditure for 2021 exceeded ¥100 trillion. Recent years have seen widening inequality, to the point that the wealthiest few percent of the world are said to hold more than half of global wealth, yet even so the gap is only one or two orders of magnitude. A national budget dwarfs that. The weakness of government, though, is that it cannot act for small, immediate gains. Holding a vast budget and bearing the mission of strengthening the nation and protecting its citizens, it can rarely make decisions purely for this year’s results or for the benefit of a handful of people. Push that reasoning further and decisions inevitably become slow. That is government’s weakness. I once received investment from a government-affiliated “joint-stock company” called INCJ. It was an organization set up under the leadership of the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry during the first Abe cabinet, and while it had the form of a joint-stock company, the government interfered with it in many respects. Even so, its investment funds were enormous — more than ten times those of Japan’s major venture capital firms at the time — and people even said that “if properly deliberated in the Diet, this amount could be doubled.” INCJ actually invested more than ¥200 billion in Japan Display, among other moves that are, in a sense, “unusual” in ways the private sector could never manage.
Next, consider “academia.” Academia’s strength is, above all, intellect. Through my work I have dealt with professors and associate professors across various fields, and as someone who is, at best, an outsider with a vague sense of understanding, I am continually astonished by the sheer depth of their knowledge. I also believe researchers maintain the most seamless stance toward developments overseas. From a young age they read papers in English, attend conferences abroad, and collaborate with researchers around the world as a matter of course, and I suspect this keeps their perspective broad rather than insular — a very positive effect. Academia, though, nearly always carries one very large problem: budget. My own footing is always on the business side, so my sense of budget when tackling a new product or a new theme is naturally calibrated to that of a business enterprise. With all due respect, the budgets researchers have access to are an order of magnitude smaller than that — in some cases two or even three orders of magnitude smaller. Truly critical themes that attract research funding easily may sometimes receive a large budget. But even then, compared to the budgets behind truly massive industrial development projects — smartphones, say, or new-generation CPUs — the figures are, in most cases, still one or two orders of magnitude lower.
Finally, consider “industry,” particularly startups. Startups lack almost everything. Capital, of course, but also human resources, connections, organizational strength. Even specialized expertise, which ought to be a strength, often falls far below world-class levels. Startups often present something like a “member list” when meeting investors — perfect pedigrees, flawless careers, truly “a winning team.” Personally, I think this kind of cheap appeal is quite meaningless. But it works surprisingly well, doesn’t it. In reality, in an organization like a startup where people constantly come and go, a résumé carries meaning only for the co-founders and the CEO. No matter how formidable a lineup you assemble for CTO, CFO, or COO at the outset, retaining talented people is extremely difficult, as I have written elsewhere. One might as well call it impossible. So in truth there is nothing. All that exists is momentum.
The fallacy government falls into: “We hold the vision, so we should guide the whole.” People who set visions with no feasibility are called dreamers or swindlers in the real world. The fallacy academia falls into: “We know a great deal, and we judge what is worth attempting and what is not.” Science has always advanced through refutation. In the 1960s, concerns about global cooling were widespread, and later research brought global warming to the fore instead. I personally think there is a fair chance the logic for cooling could coalesce again someday. Discovering phenomena that classical Newtonian mechanics could not explain, and attempting to account for them, led to the development of quantum theory and relativity. Even when we believe we have explained everything, there is always more that remains unknown. Holding to that stance is what scholarship is.
In other words, the above can be called “the fallacy of believing one knows the answer.” This is nothing other than classic overconfidence, arrogance, and a lack of humility. Discarding these properly, I believe, is the key to collaboration among industry, government, and academia.
In most business domains, there is no convenient thing called “the right answer.” In this world, even the relationship between addition and multiplication must be questioned. What looks correct on a scale of ten or twenty years may not be correct on a scale of a hundred years. But if we dwell on that, we become unable to move. We become unable to do anything at all.
Now, let us bring this discussion to its conclusion.
An organization that can act without certainty — that is the startup, and it is industry’s greatest advantage. For better or worse, the world of industry overflows with failure. An ecosystem has formed in which something is learned from failure, and even so, society as a whole avoids catastrophic loss, and that cycle keeps turning.
Most of an executive’s talk of “a winning strategy” or “a path to victory” is invented after the fact. Knowing this, everyone understands that there is nothing to learn from success. This connects to the idea that we should instead learn from failure. Many inventions begin by chance. The meeting of Jobs and Wozniak was chance as well. Nothing can be set in motion through calculation alone.
In other words, government and academia should use industry as a kind of “proxy for making wrong answers.” Of course, it won’t move the way you intend. So the shape of it is this: startups charge forward toward whatever innovation they have convinced themselves of, academia supports them while thinking “perhaps a challenge like that could produce something after all,” and government institutions simply need to watch over the process with a straight face — clearing away regulations so as not to obstruct the path, and, on the rare occasion that results do emerge, helping to ensure they are properly returned to society.
There was a time when government-led innovation carried great significance. The American moonshot of the Kennedy era — the Apollo program — is perhaps the ultimate example of that. Many new technologies emerged in the course of it, and they eventually became a wellspring of various forms of prosperity that reached even into ordinary people’s lives. But this scheme itself is nothing new. It is old and well-worn, used since long, long ago. Yes: war. National competition against other countries strengthens nationalism. Indeed, the push behind the Apollo program carried a clear intention: to restore the pride of an America that, at the time, was showing signs of decline.
It seems to me we no longer need to rely on such an old scheme. A major reason is that information asymmetry is weakening at an accelerating pace year by year. Today even a grade-schooler can use the internet to check whether what some dignitary at the United Nations says is actually true. Before long, national projects will no longer be monopolized by a handful of large corporations alone.
Industry charges ahead, academia follows along, and government cleans up afterward and makes the story add up. That kind of collaboration among industry, government, and academia has already begun, here and there.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/08/505/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.