Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

A flawless pitch loses to one that digs into its strength

Let’s assume we’re looking at a presentation at the early stage of product planning. This is the kind of setting where you explain things to senior people and get their approval.

First, what does a flawless presentation actually look like? Wouldn’t it be one that covers everything — the concept of the plan, the market research results behind it, the specific product and service specifications, the schedule, the budget outlook, the required personnel, external partners, the promotion plan, unit pricing, and so on — all laid out so that the relationships between each piece and the consistency of the numbers are perfectly aligned?

That’s obviously too much.

There’s something called the “peak-end rule.” It holds that people’s overall impression of a conversation is almost entirely controlled by how the “most exciting part = peak” and the “last part = end” came across. You might think “surely it’s not that extreme,” but this is a well-established phenomenon in behavioral psychology. Simplified into more of a practical rule of thumb, it might land better as “no matter how long you talk in a presentation, the listener ends up remembering only two or three points.” No matter how much you lay out at length, in reality there are at most two or three points that leave an impression.

When I was pitching in Silicon Valley, I ran into a very interesting phenomenon. You don’t see this much in Japan: investors stop the pitch partway through and ask questions. I think there are a few reasons for this.

① They don’t want to waste time watching a long presentation ② If they don’t ask when the thought occurs to them, they’ll forget ③ They don’t believe an investment decision needs that many factors

On ①, I was told this directly: “Sorry, but if there’s even one slide I can’t get interested in, I’m leaving the room.” (Terrifying.) ② can be thought of as a countermeasure against being misled by the peak-end rule mentioned above. As for ③ — whether it’s a business plan or a product plan, what actually matters at the early stage is extremely limited.

What happens instead, more often than not, is an “argument over points that don’t matter” — unnecessary nitpicking. And that, ironically, is the pattern a “flawless presentation” tends to follow. (It might sound contradictory, but it’s true.)

Take a product plan themed around “healing,” for example. The most important point — the one you want to convey — is how you interpret this somewhat vague indicator called “healing,” and how you plan to approach it. In a case like this, something like market size is meaningless. There’s essentially nobody who thinks “who needs healing, yeehaw.” Everyone seeks some form of healing suited to themselves, to a greater or lesser degree. Market size depends entirely on how you cut the segment, so it isn’t something that’s naturally determined. But if you clumsily bring up data like “we surveyed 100 women in their 30s” here, you’ll invite unnecessary nitpicking like “so I guess men in their 50s aren’t the target?” I also very often see presentation materials where, despite being at an extremely early planning phase, the budget and business plan details are written out with great precision — a textbook pattern for inviting unnecessary nitpicking. Even if you do write something, it’s more effective to just roughly present a budget outlook broken down by milestones — quarterly, or for the project as a whole, or up through the end of the first phase. That way you convey the message “it’s not that we haven’t thought about it, but at this point it’s not especially important,” and that lands well.

Now, I’ve described getting nitpicked in a fairly negative light, but you can actually give the act of being nitpicked a very important role. It’s a kind of presentation technique.

This is know-how I often heard from development team members at Yamaha who enjoyed working on product planning. Put simply:

In other words, it’s actually better to leave some gaps. Rather than closing every one of them, it’s smarter to spend your time conveying — and getting people to understand — your idea, your originality, your sharp concept.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/08/473/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.