Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Leaving a Big Company Does Not End a Career

This piece first appeared on ⟦1⟧.

It rather starts.

Let me put it that way, for those of you thinking something like “if I quit my big company…”

People who belong to big companies probably have plenty of moments when they think “I want to quit” or “maybe I should quit.” But most people who leave a big company move to another big company. The job market tends to follow that pattern to a certain degree. Those people don’t come to me for advice, and frankly they don’t need it from me. If your options include small and midsize companies or startups, even just a little, I overwhelmingly recommend “starting” your career.

What is it that starts?

To think about that, let’s begin by sorting out what you think is “ending” in the first place.

Take income, for example. Big companies keep things deliberately flat and steady, under pressures both internal and external — being part of an electrical workers’ union, for instance, or expectations around stable pay. In other words, it’s “a state that holds at a certain height and is hard to raise or lower.” The same goes for the benefits that supplement income. Giving that up means “stepping into a state where the average is unclear and things rise and fall easily” — in other words, taking on a bigger gap between Risk and Reward. Of course where there’s Risk there should be an expected Reward. The clearest example is joining a brand-new startup, taking low pay, and receiving founder’s shares or stock options instead. You take on the Risk of lower current pay in exchange for the Reward of capital gains. Say you work at that company for four or five years, it never grows, your salary never rises, there’s no sale or IPO, and you leave. You could look at that as simply having lost out on salary. But is it really fair to call it a loss, without looking at the growth you gained in other respects?

So next is the matter of experience. If you’re young and unattached, working at a startup or a small company will unquestionably be an incredibly exciting experience. You don’t need to worry much about income, and the experience of chasing a big opportunity and struggling alongside your colleagues will give you a huge number of insights and a real sense of fulfillment day to day. Whatever becomes of your career afterward, it will serve as enormous nourishment.

Now, what if you’re already a seasoned veteran? You know perfectly well what you can handle on your own, and you also know what you can’t do alone. If you’ve had a long career in a given industry, you have a sense of where you stand within it. But do you really know that?

At big companies, a lot of work is supported by back-office functions. That means you’re doing your job on top of a great many black boxes. So isn’t it likely that there’s more you don’t know, more you can’t do, and more you still need to learn than you think?

Big companies also have a “brand name.” When I was at Yamaha, people would half-joke that “if you’ve got a Yamaha business card, nobody will ever turn down a meeting with you” — and at least during my time there, that was simply true. Even a cold email or a sudden inquiry was never met with a cold shoulder. That’s the power of a brand name. Startups and small companies don’t have that. If anything, they carry the negative brand of “being a small company.”

Say your specialty is sales. How many times have you actually gone and tried to sell a product nobody trusts at all, to people in a category where your company’s name means nothing? Can you really call that real experience? Of course, regardless of company size, the underlying techniques and ways of thinking are the same. So here, you can do an “inventory of your experience.” Don’t you want to know how far your real career actually reaches?

Incidentally, what I wanted to know when I went to the US was this: “Everyone goes on about how amazing Silicon Valley is, but is that really true at the level of individual engineers? How far would I actually get there?”

Finally — and this is an unpleasant topic — there’s the matter of impressions.

Especially at startups, it’s common for a company to fold in six months or a year, and for you to be job-hunting again. At that point you’ll be interviewed somewhere else. This is about the impression you make there. I’ve conducted a great many hiring interviews, and for candidates with that kind of pattern, the points I watch carefully are these: Was this person actually in a central role within that company? How clearly can they explain the full picture of the project they were involved in?

If neither of those leaves a good impression, I sometimes judge the person as someone who drifted into a startup on a whim and came away with nothing to show for it. Jumping off the stage at Kiyomizu Temple doesn’t make you admirable in itself. It’s admirable because you grabbed hold of something by doing it.

The word “job hopper” is often used negatively, but I actually have a fairly positive impression of moving between jobs, in itself. There’s a lot you can’t know without trying, so trying various things is, I think, a good thing in itself. But if each individual experience along the way doesn’t connect to your next choice or to a long-term career vision, then it’s just “someone who doesn’t stick with anything.” Put bluntly, that’s a risky hire.

But conversely, the people you find yourself thinking, deep down, “all right, let’s trust this person with it!” — in most cases they’re people who picked up something of their own while moving between a few different jobs. Of course, we do sometimes hire people with a long career at a single big company, but in that case it’s usually because we want a specific, specialized skill, or because we want someone who can be relied on to deliver specific strength in a specific position — a “known quantity.” So this question of impression also comes down, just like experience, to taking on a bigger gap between Risk and Reward.

In Silicon Valley, incidentally, job-hopping is treated as normal, so someone who’s stayed at a single company for decades might actually be treated as the riskier hire — because they’ve never once proven, over the course of their career, that they can succeed elsewhere.

The biggest factor in what starts is a shift in values. Once you’ve stepped outside, you can go wherever you like from there — Silicon Valley, Berlin, Tel Aviv, anywhere.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/07/546/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.