How To Raise The Productivity Of Unproductive Meetings

There’s no way I, someone who already hates meetings to begin with, would tolerate unproductive meetings. Lol
So what exactly counts as an “unproductive meeting” here? There are several patterns, but let me list the typical ones.
- A meeting whose purpose is unclear
- A meeting where just one person keeps talking the whole time
- A meeting where nothing beyond information sharing ever happens
- A meeting that keeps going down rabbit holes or off on tangents
These can naturally be avoided with proper facilitation. But if you do find yourself facing a “typical unproductive meeting,” it’s because the facilitation is either ambiguous or just not good enough, and you need to step in.
At times like that, the prohibited move people tend to reach for is “let me sum this up.”
To begin with, the whole point of a meeting is for multiple members to exchange opinions and clash in discussion. Especially when you hold a leading position within the group, you need to be careful not to wrap things up too much around your own opinion. I won’t say never do it, but it should be avoided, because if you’re the one summing it up with your own opinion, the meeting wasn’t necessary in the first place. Just say “I’ll Slack it later” and break up right then.
So what does facilitation that steers things in a productive direction actually look like?
<Set the premise up front>
The moment you sense “this meeting might be going badly,” take the lead for just the first few seconds. If there’s already someone in the facilitator role, phrase it as a question to them, and state the “premise,” “purpose,” and “goal” of the meeting as concisely and memorably as possible, in a way anyone can retain. Say it even if everyone “surely” already knows it. People forget more than you’d expect, and they’re often not even consciously aware of it.
<Thoroughly eliminate anything that isn’t moving toward the goal>
Commit yourself almost entirely to the role of listener. And take on the role of the one who jumps in. One of the important jobs of that role is bringing the conversation back to the main thread. Icebreakers matter. Some pleasant small talk is probably needed too. But you need to cut that time off sharply. If nobody cuts it off, it often just keeps going forever. Be the one who steps up and cuts it off. What matters here is “not giving off a cold vibe.” You could call it a kind of humor. Even hearing that, it might not click right away. There’s no one-size-fits-all method for this, so try it a few times and develop your own style. One method I use is “slip in a question as if it’s nothing.” Something like, “sorry, there was something earlier I didn’t quite follow.” This brings the conversation back very naturally. It also makes it easy to convey a soft “sorry to interrupt while things are getting lively,” so it can be used gently.
<Don’t flounder for more than 5 minutes>
There are discussions that simply won’t reach a conclusion easily. In fact, that happens all the time. How to solve a technical problem, what the next action should be based on verification results, whether to ship at this quality level or instead spend more time and money improving quality. Opinions among members diverge, data is presented that could support either side, and reaching a conclusion is extremely difficult. At times like that, just put an end to the discussion for now.
I make it a rule to “give up on anything that doesn’t reach a conclusion after 5 minutes of thinking.” I give up on reaching a conclusion, and instead think about “what’s missing in order to reach a conclusion.” Doing that should surface something — information, the opinion of someone with real expertise, an additional experiment — something you can point to and say “if we just had that, we could reach a conclusion.” In the actual meeting, find a good moment to propose this and steer things toward putting the conclusion on hold for now. What matters is that it’s “a hold with the next action already set.”
<Be strict about time>
I often say things like “we’re already past the time.” For example, in a meeting where you need to reach a conclusion in 30 minutes, if explaining the premises takes more than 10 minutes, there’s no time left for discussion. And if 25 minutes have passed with no clue toward a conclusion yet, there may not be enough time left to get from “conclusion” to “agreement.” The opposite also happens — plenty of wasted time comes from dragging on after the punch line of the discussion has already landed. In those cases it’s fine to cut things off sharply, but if you’d rather do it gently, it’s effective to casually make everyone aware of the time. It’s not exactly elegant, but it’s easy enough to just drop a line like “oh, it’s already such-and-such o’clock.”
<Above all, stay upbeat>
There’s no time more pointless than everyone sitting there solemnly chewing over serious content. A productive mood is what creates a productive flow. Above all, act upbeat. Acting upbeat is tiring, but that’s exactly why you should use the time you save by ending the meeting early to take a proper break.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/07/521/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.