Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Why I Moved My Blog Back From Note to Self-Hosting

I pulled my content down from note, where I’d been posting for about a year, and moved it back to our company blog. Here’s my reasoning for that.

Did traffic increase?

It’s fair to say the only paths to getting a blog post read are “make it turn up in search” or “post it on social media” (I don’t run a newsletter or have any kind of tie-up with another site). When I moved to note, what I was hoping for was that note itself would function as a platform, giving me a reasonable amount of inflow from “circulation within note” — people arriving at my posts from someone else’s post on note, or from a note event page. Medium, which I’d used before, wasn’t very effective on that front, though I think there were various reasons for that too. So, to cut to the conclusion: circulation-driven inflow on note turned out to be close to nonexistent, much like on Medium. Followers don’t seem to count for much either. In short, note as a platform has almost none of that landing-page effect where someone just happens to glance at this or that post. So the traffic path ends up running almost entirely through social media. And if that’s the case, a company blog works just as well.

On search rankings

Search a specific keyword on Google and note posts typically land somewhere around position 5 to 7. But even when I searched a fairly deliberate, dead-on phrase, and even for a post that had been getting a steady trickle of traffic, it rarely reached position 1. A while back, when I was running a blog as a hobby, I had an article about iOS that did well, and it kept landing at position 1 to 3 even for fairly generic keyword searches. I can’t explain this gap logically without digging into the details of the search algorithm, but my sense is this: posts on a platform like note always get evaluated somewhat favorably by the search engine, but they rarely get evaluated exceptionally well. Position 5 to 7 is, in practical terms, the boundary between mattering and not mattering. Think back on your own behavior when you search for something. You’ll usually only open results down to about position 3.

My current understanding is that note is convenient as a platform if you’re running a paid magazine or selling something paid on it. But the fees it takes are substantial enough that there are plenty of other options if that’s your goal. You could always put in a bit more effort, pull things together into a properly formatted book, and publish it on Kindle.

Building up an asset

Most of my posts are either an analysis of something, an organization of some phenomenon, or a sharing of my own experience, so I don’t think of them as throwaway content. I write with the intent of accumulation, not something to be consumed in the moment and forgotten. I never got that sense of accumulation on note. In the end, I understood that as a matter of submitting to the platform. Leaning on something and becoming subordinate to it necessarily means handing over whatever you’ve built to that thing as well. Our own domain, our rented server: these aren’t free. But even if it costs money, I’d rather build up value that belongs properly to the company, or to myself.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/06/421/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.