The Smartphone Never Became the Device We Expected

In the 200xs, we faced the trend of the “smartphone” and were filled with joy.
“The device we’d been waiting for has finally arrived!” we said.
Demand for a mobile device form factor combining computing power and usability had always been predicted.
Feature phones had always aimed at exactly that, and you can trace the lineage back as far as Palm.
Windows CE obviously aimed at it too, and many manufacturers released cool products running Windows CE.
But none of them managed to dominate the market, and “mobile computing device” came to mean, for everyone,
“a passing fad that only a handful of gadget enthusiasts buy, and even they get bored with it quickly.”
It was close to resignation.
Amid that, a product appeared with enough undeniable presence that everyone believed, “Ah, this is the final form we’d been looking for!”
That was the shock of the iPhone.
An era in which “almost everyone around the world carries roughly the same thing” is probably rare today.
Now even manufacturers other than Apple keep making things nearly identical to the iPhone, staying just on the right side of patent infringement.
The smartphone has become something like jeans.
At a glance, none of them have any distinguishing features. Except for a segment that cares deeply about such things, users don’t particularly ask for that either.
That’s because content matters, and the device itself doesn’t.
Give it another ten years and most young people will no longer know it all started with the iPhone. Perhaps in developing countries, where there’s hardly any Apple product and the market is dominated by cheap Chinese-made smartphones, that’s already the case.
In the end, roots and the philosophy embedded in them don’t matter.
In the course of this dramatic generalization, what’s demanded of smartphones has changed considerably.
At first, I think what was demanded of mobile devices was a small terminal as a place for creativity.
That is, a device that lets you do things like edit documents, write code, or do some app development while out and about. (This was especially true in the era when using the internet on the go wasn’t particularly cheap.)
But that idea lacked economic rationality after all.
Mobile devices carry all sorts of technical difficulties. Just fitting a battery and an LCD into such a small device is already hard enough. On top of that, small devices are at a severe disadvantage when it comes to things like electromagnetic compatibility.
In short, it costs money.
Building something for a need as modest as “creativity” simply doesn’t pay off.
So the iPhone turned toward becoming a more general-purpose information terminal.
It dramatically expanded its user base, dominated the market, and evolved into a business model that squeezes every bit of value out of being a platform.
Of course, early on, considerable extensibility was guaranteed through external devices. But today, how rare is it to even find someone using an external keyboard?
And it’s fair to say that today’s smartphone has exactly one primary purpose that matters above all: functioning as a “receiver and display of information.”
Here, something occurs to me.
Does a mere information terminal really need this much processing power?
If anything, the development of smartphone SoCs just keeps accelerating. Why is that?
Processing high-resolution photos, real-time image recognition, watching large-capacity video, and so on — there are endless reasons.
In short, it’s a response to the diversification of content and of the smartphone’s own uses.
As for the diversification of smartphone uses, to be precise it’s really an absorption of uses — a phenomenon in which activities once handled by dedicated devices are gradually being replaced by the “convenient device” at hand, with its abundant processing power. And if you think about it calmly, which is cause and which is effect isn’t actually clear.
As for content, it seems to me we’ve arrived at the classic gap between what users want and what manufacturers assume the specs should be.
For instance, is the desire to watch 1080p-or-better video on a mere 5-inch display really essential?
In an era when most content ends up being consumed on a smartphone or, at best, a tablet, what’s the necessity of shooting content in 8K?
The VR narrative has come around again — who knows how many times now in history — but what did we actually learn from the great failure of 3D TV?
“Providing more than what the user asks for” is an idealized image manufacturers always hold up — and it’s a false one.
I deliberately call it a “false image” because, in most cases, that act has nothing to do with “the user’s latent desires.” It’s simply a hard sell of the manufacturer’s own values.
So why can this kind of hard sell keep going? By the logic of economics, it shouldn’t. And yet nothing about it is wrong. Quite simply, it’s profitable — not through the hard sell visible on the surface, but behind it.
As someone involved in developing electronics, if I were handed the brief “develop a smartphone from scratch equivalent to an iPhone or a flagship Android,” I’d say it would be extremely difficult to bring it to market at $900.
That holds whether you’re talking about recouping development costs or working through the unit cost of each individual component — the conclusion probably doesn’t change.
And yet many smartphones are sold not just near that price but well below it.
Why? Because of data.
It hardly needs saying at this point, but usage data is collected on most devices and apps.
The brazenness of listing ads in recent years is almost frightening.
I say “brazenness” because targeting ads that are too blatant leave me with a dreary mix of gloom and pity, not unlike running into a clumsy con artist.
The improved accuracy of facial recognition is the fruit of our having kept entering facial data into countless apps and platforms in order to build photo albums of our partners and children. This, in itself, involves users offering effort toward a shared benefit with some degree of consent, and manufacturers providing value back in the form of services. Not bad.
A music service analyzing my taste from the playlists I’ve made and recommending artists is, in a way, welcome too — because that’s precisely the purpose for which I’m using the music service to begin with.
But the TV programs I watch, the cafés I visit, my religion and social connections, my sexual preferences, which games I play and for how long each day — that information is not something we think we handed over to manufacturers in expectation of some service improvement.
And yet that kind of information is used, quite routinely, across a wide range of contexts.
From the manufacturer’s standpoint, the logic probably goes like this:
“We’re pouring enormous development costs into building the smartphone platform and its associated services. The fact that part of that effort goes toward improving the service through data collection — providing advertisers with more sophisticated ad capabilities — is, from our side, simply the legitimate recovery of value.”
And, put more bluntly: “If you don’t like it, don’t use it.”
I myself had, for a while before now, grown sick of the volume of ads on Facebook, and I barely use it anymore.
That’s my own way of saying NO to overly blatant advertising.
I’ve set things up so only mentions show up properly, and I only look at those. In other words, I’ve arranged to see only what I want to see.
Google has long offered Incognito mode. Using it means your search history and cookies don’t stay in the browser.
It suggests Google holds some position on privacy.
Unfortunately, though, this has nothing to do with whether “the website you visit extracts your data or not.”
It would really be fairer to promote systems like DuckDuckGo, which are built on the premise of blocking access to behavioral data.
What a headache. I’m sick of it.
And yet, deciding to stop using a smartphone has finally become genuinely difficult.
We already depend on smartphones for most of our means of contact.
LINE, Facebook Messenger, Twitter, Slack, Teams — the list goes on endlessly.
But let’s think about it.
Nearly everything LINE can do, SMS could already do.
And yet we use LINE. This is the frightening part of platform business — it plays expertly on human psychology.
The counterargument, that “messaging apps have improved performance beyond any comparison with SMS,” is reasonable enough.
Response speed, read/unread indicators, sticker features, and so on.
But this already steps into the “gap” I described earlier.
Whether a reply to my mother back home over LINE takes one second or ten doesn’t matter much. She won’t reply right away regardless of how quickly she reads it.
Stickers were fun as a novelty, but by now most people are already tired of them and just recycle the same handful every time.
As for read/unread notifications, it would make everyone happier not to know — they’re more often the seed of trouble than anything else.
There are surely counterarguments to all this too. But the very fact that debate over these things is even possible shows, without question, that we’ve encroached into this unstable gap zone.
Before Facebook existed, everyone kept in touch with friends via things like mailing lists.
That earlier approach was undeniably less interactive (no “like” button, for instance), and it presupposed communication only within a group of mutually authorized members. If you wanted to communicate indiscriminately with a large, undefined audience, the only available method, in the opposite direction, was something like a bulletin board — far too public.
That was a very unbalanced situation, and Facebook deserves credit for filling that gap.
But did we really want such a lightweight communication tool?
With email, for instance, you review the text over and over before sending, because once it’s sent you can’t fix it.
On social media, you don’t do that. In most cases you can edit or delete a post after it’s up.
Say something lightly, and if it goes badly, delete it right away.
That’s not behavior society readily condones. Which is why no small number of companies maintain a “no deleting” rule on their internal social platforms.
The improvisational savagery of a bulletin board, and the static stability of email.
No one thinks the era when we communicated by drawing on these two opposite poles was perfect.
But today, apart from the heyday of bulletin boards, almost the only effective means of communication left is a platform called social media, one that carries a quiet savagery of its own. Taking the time to organize your thoughts properly, bringing content up to a solid standard, and then sending something to a friend — that’s become extremely rare.
As a trial, I tried discussing environmental issues over email with a bureaucrat friend of mine, and each round trip usually took two or three days, sometimes up to a week.
That’s because it requires thinking it through carefully, researching properly so as not to make mistakes, and only then sending back a proposal or a counterargument.
That strikes me, irresistibly, as an extremely orderly and fruitful style of communication.
The fact that debates over political and social issues on social media seem to produce nothing but garbage in the cloud comes down to exactly this.
I’ve ended up handling several issues in parallel here (that’s how large and complicated the deterioration of industrial structure wrought by smartphones and social media has been over the past decade-plus), but what I want to put forward, in essence, is this inference:
- The diversity of communication has been thrown away, with everything optimized for the smartphone
- Social media collects vast amounts of data that has drifted away from “what the user actually needs”
- The smartphone has willingly fallen into servitude to social media
and that these are, as a result, the trigger behind much of the current instability and imbalance.
Picture a couple where one calls the other “because I wanted to hear your voice” — it’s a scene that fills you with real warmth.
It even feels true to human nature.
Compare that to being irritated that someone “read but didn’t reply” on LINE, or noticing that one particular person didn’t like a photo you posted on Instagram.
Things like that seem, to me, nothing but a foolish act — stress we inflict on ourselves, entirely of our own making, through systems we built ourselves.
That said, nostalgically saying “things were better in the old days” solves nothing.
If you’re unhappy with the current state of things, the right stance is to work out a solution.
So let’s think about it.
Take, for example, the idea of “imposing a tariff on the export of information.”
A few years ago Europe launched GDPR, and it’s fair to call that a pioneer in this.
Concretely, it effectively restricted taking personal data outside Europe.
For most manufacturers this just meant paying attention to where the servers holding customer data were located, but for companies at the center of the data industry, this was a matter of survival.
Yet it’s entirely reasonable and self-evident that no one can look favorably on a situation where the data generated by one’s own citizens flows directly into the profits of a foreign company. Regulation is a first step, and it’s worth watching how this develops from here.
Here’s another example: before the Edo period, the fatty cut of tuna, toro, used to be thrown away.
Back when transportation wasn’t well developed, the common way to preserve tuna was to marinate it, and marinating the fattier toro apparently produced poor, unappetizing results.
If something’s value isn’t recognized, it’s practically worthless. But once its value is recognized, a price gets attached and it gets traded.
And if it then moves across national borders, it stands to reason that a tariff gets considered.
Now, let’s imagine a society in which the value of information has declined, or the cost of collecting it has gone up considerably.
The quality of advertising would drop, or its cost would rise dramatically, and that would ripple out into all sorts of real-economy transactions once removed from advertising itself.
A smartphone would become something costing a few hundred dollars, no longer something you casually buy for each of your kids.
Targeting ad performance would decline, worsening the revenue structure. That would make it harder to offer apps for free. Developers would shift their focus toward monetizing through in-app purchases, and things would probably settle into something like the period when “freemium → subscription” models rose to prominence.
Meanwhile, the excessive investment by manufacturers into smartphone development would be reined in, and prices would gradually be pushed down. During the period before that shakes out, Chinese smartphones might well come to dominate the market.
The large, dominant social media platforms would decline, and several new social platforms would rise, each letting limited groups of members communicate in a style suited to their preferences. Many of them would be membership-based and paid. And the companies providing the secure platforms for freely building such communication tools would become the new winners.
In terms of market size, that looks like contraction. In economic terms, it might look like regression.
But who ever decided, in the first place, that market expansion and economic progress are automatically wonderful things?
If things are heading in the wrong direction, it’s better to accept contraction or regression and stop, even just once.
That’s no different from halting a factory’s operation once an environmental problem comes to light, or pausing a construction project to review safety standards.
Right now, it looks to me like the market is in a state where it ought to stop, caught in a chain of intense generalization and the exploitation of information.
In exchange for vast amounts of information, it produces vast amounts of electronic waste.
As someone involved in making things, I can’t help feeling a strong aversion to that state of affairs.
This isn’t necessarily resignation.
Nor is it necessarily a demand for some sudden new breakthrough or technological innovation.
A business model that delivers great satisfaction to a small number of users has, for instance, become almost extinct, as if it had been simply discarded.
But if we’re allowed to grasp this fundamentally through the simple equation “number of users × satisfaction = value,” there’s still plenty of room to recover a sense of values.
An ad for a dance school my wife searched for on her tablet, thinking about whether to send our daughter, shows up on my Facebook.
While watching TV at home, after saying something like, “Oh, this artist is getting married, huh,” a music video by that very artist shows up in my YouTube recommendations (and this time I hadn’t even searched — but I had said the name repeatedly, and the song had played in the room).
Faced with this kind of unease, I’ve started to stop doing various things.
A device that is convenient and unsettling at the same time.
I don’t want to believe that this is the final form “we” were looking for.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/05/344/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.